Make My Fish
$$ • Seafood, Fish & ChipsAbout Make My Fish
Customers' Favorites
Fried Shrimp Platter with Collard Greens
Fried Fish and Shrimp Platter
Fried Whiting Fish Sandwich
Catfish and Shrimp Combo
Fish and Shrimp Dinner
Whiting Fish Dinner
Macaroni and Cheese
Fish & Shrimp
Catfish and Chips
Mac & Cheese
Make My Fish Reviews
221 ratings
Share your opinion about Make My Fish
Excellent food enjoyed everything.
My brother took me here Aug 28 2026 I traveled from Huntington Long Island to Harlem OMG I MUST YELL THIS SO THE WORLD CAN HEAR ME LOL THIS MAN SOLD ME SOME OF THE BEST FISH I HAVE EVER TASTED IN MY LIFE AND MY FATHER IS A FISHERMAN!!! Now let that marinate in your spirit. I thought my brother made the best fish in the world and I was so wrong. I am a honest person and the catfish was absolutely phenomenal. Perfectly seasoned and fried to perfection. THATS ALL I HAVE TO SAY TY...read full review
The Owner/Cooks were AMAZING!! My husband and I found this restaurant on google. We are from Michigan so we wanted to eat what the local eat while visiting New York. The two men in the kitchen were sooo nice, they gave us a sample of catfish and shrimp which was amazing! It taste like it was cooked in fresh oil and both were seasoned beautifully. The shrimp was my favorite, it had an crispy airiness with a light sweet taste. My husband and I both got combo meals. The sides...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Make My Fish is a local neighborhood restaurant that specializes in seafood dishes. They offer a variety of options such as fried fish, shrimp, and chicken, with vegetarian sides including mac & cheese, collard greens, candied yams, and potato salad. The catfish is a notable menu item. Prices are reasonable, but it's important to note that they only accept cash and it's a take-out spot.
The service is friendly, and customers often receive generous tasting plates of shrimp and other samples before their main dishes arrive, which adds to the positive experience. The food is consistently praised for being fresh, flavorful, and made to order, especially the fried catfish, shrimp, and mac & cheese. The presentation of dishes is beautiful, and the dishes are delivered quickly, making it a good choice for a quick, tasty meal.
Although the ambiance may not be very inviting for first-time visitors, the staff are welcoming and accommodating, even when accessibility issues occur. The location is casual, with a manual glass door at the entrance, and the atmosphere feels warm and heartwarming. The sweet tea is often noted as perfectly sweet, adding to the overall enjoyment.
Overall, Make My Fish is a highly recommended local spot for those nearby or willing to make a trip from the DMV, especially for fried catfish, shrimp, and delicious sides. Parking may involve a bit of a challenge, but the friendly service and great food make it worth it.