Papa John's Pizza - 1709 Amsterdam Ave

Pizza, Take Out

1709 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 281-7272



Reviews for Papa John's

We order some pizzas here, they made it wrong by adding a topping that we did not request online. The person is allergic to the topping they added. We called them to tell them about what they did and all they did was hang up the phone. It seems as if they don't care. The guy that answered the phone knew he messed up. That's why he hung up the phone. Very negative. If I could I would give a negative star just for what they did.

Awful experience with this restaurant! I ordered food delivery, 2 hours later the food was not still delivered! I tried to call them to figure out what's the problem after couple of tries, finally they told me that the food is coming up! It took another 30minutes to get there. The food was cold and tasteless! Their customer service and quality of food is just terrible!

This is the worst Papa Johns place to order. I called and they said 27 minutes I took 1 hour. I called to find out the status of my order, and the they hang up the phone on me 3 times. The worst.!!! Will never order from this place again.! It’s sad how poor they treat customers

More Reviews(22)


Monday 11AM - 1AM
Tuesday 11AM - 1AM
Wednesday 11AM - 1AM
Thursday 11AM - 1AM
Friday 11AM - 2AM
Saturday 11AM - 2AM
Sunday 11AM - 1AM


#Popular Items | #Pizza | #Sides | #Desserts | #Drinks | #Extras

Popular Items

Create Your Own$9.99
Select your size, crust and favorite toppings.
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie$5.99
Filled with chocolate chips, cut into 9 squares and served warm
Chocolate Chip Cookie$5.99
Loaded with chocolate chips, cut into 8 slices, served warm
16 Piece - Buffalo Wings$16.99
Bone-in wings are oven baked and tossed in tangy buffalo sauce
Tuscan Six Cheese$13.99
A blend of Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, Fontina, provolone, real cheese made from mozzarella, and Italian seasoning.
The Meats$13.99
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon, and Canadian bacon.
BBQ Chicken Bacon$13.99
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, bacon and onions.
The Works$13.99
Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, spicy Italian sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
Garlic Parm - Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks$5.99
Fresh-baked and brushed with garlic sauce and seasonings
8 piece - Garlic Knots$4.99
8 Knots made with fresh dough and garlic parmesan seasoning are served with pizza sauce.


Ultimate Pepperoni$13.99
View Entire Menu

About Papa John's

Papa John's crust is famous for being soft and flavorful. There are a variety of pizza choices from basic cheese pizza to pepperoni to choose from. You can also create your own pizza by choosing the toppings you want the most. Others prefer ordering something classic, like John's Favorite, a six-cheese blend topped with pepperoni, sausage and Italian seasonings. Papa John's also offers vegetarian alternatives like the Spinach Alfredo, Tuscan Six Cheese, and Garden Fresh. And for those that want pizza but don't want to derail all their healthy efforts at the gym, Papa's Lighter Choices offer a slice of the good stuff without guilt. The Mediterranean Veggie is a fantastically flavorful option with 300 or fewer calories per slice. With a lighter portion of real cheese made from mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, mushrooms, and ripe black olives, it will satisfy your pizza cravings. Make tonight a pizza night and order a Papa John's pizza to enjoy with your family or friends. With Papa John's, you'll see why better ingredients really do make a better pizza.