13 Best Italian Restaurants in Newburgh

Primo Waterfront Italian • $$$
50 Front St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Sausage Gnocchi
Brussels and Truffles
Squid Ink Tagliolini
Royal Seafood Tower
Lobster Spaghettini
Gnocchi Alla Vodka
Lobster Pan Tomato
Octopus Casserecce
Tuna Toro Tartare
Grilled Octopus

“delicious food, great atmosphere and terrific staff!“

4.1 Good157 Reviews
Il Cenacolo Italian • $$$
228 S Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Salmon with Broccoli and Truffle Pasta
Asparagi Al Burro Nero E Parmigiano
Fish of the Day Served Arrosto
Lava Cake with Coffee Gelato
Scampi Alla Fiorentina
Stuffed Ribeye Steak
Peanut Butter Pie
Sautéed Eggplant
Gnocchi Taleggio
Chocolate Mousse

“celebrated with close friends yesterday, 💛 💓 💗 💖 never disappointed with the food quality, presentation, quantity or flavor. not to mention service, ambiance and staff.“

4.7 Superb86 Reviews
Vesuvio's Ristorante Italian • $$
300 Dupont Ave, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken
Chicken Marsala over Penne
Stuffed Sole Filet of Sole
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
Baked Clams Oreganata
Spaghetti Bolognese
Chicken Caesar Salad
NY Style Cheesecake

“The food is delicious. Staff is courteous & attentive. Great portion sizes“

4.6 Superb105 Reviews
Cafe Pitti Italian • $$
40 Front St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pecan Pie Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Pizza Frutti Di Mare
Pistachio Ice Cream
Carpaccio Di Manzo
Apple House Salad
Grilled Salmon
Charcuterie
Crab Cakes
Tiramisu
Caprese

“Good food and good music.“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Fusion @ Union Italian • $$
1400 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Personal Breast of Burden Pie
Pizza Union Sharing Plank
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Union Breakfast Pizza
Spaghetti Meatballs
Argentinian Steak
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Milanese
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari

“Ever since moving to Newburgh, this has been my go-to restaurant. The menu is so varied, and everything tastes good. My favorite part is their consistency. It’s very hard to find a casual restaurant in this area that you can rely on for quality food. While I could nitpick that the pasta can be a bit oily and there is a lack of a good sandwiches on the menu, I love their cajun chicken alfredo, spanish style pizza, union taco salad, and they have some of the BEST nachos I’ve ever had. Plus the servers are so good at their job, so polite and friendly, and now they have turned into our good friends. Could not recommend more.“

4.2 Good93 Reviews
Cosimo's Pizza • $$
1217 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Brick Oven Magrarehtta Pizza with Grilled Mushrooms and Sauteed Onions
Spicy Fennel Sausage Wood Fired Pizza
Margherita Pizza with Fennel Sausage
Truffle Portobello Flatbread
Polpette Chef’S Meatballs
Spicy Fennel Sausage Pizza
Spicy Chicken Fusilli
Jones Farm Carrot Cake
Burrata Garlic Bread
Shrimp Scampi Pizza

“Delicious food! Great service.“

4.3 Superb182 Reviews
Joe's Pizza & Deli Pizza • $
198 S Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Cheese Pizza Plus Mushrooms
Meatball Parmigiana Hot Sandwich
Chopped Italian Sandwich
Lucy's Pizza White Pie
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Veal Cutlet Hero
Buffalo Chicken
Veal Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza

“We ordered trays of wraps and salads yesterday for my daughter in laws baby shower. Every wrap was delicious, fresh and beautifully laid out on trays. The macaroni and potato salad were just like homemade! It was all perfect for the occasion! Will definitely use them for every party!!“

4.3 Superb54 Reviews
Pizza 300 Pizza • $
1208 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Peppers Roll & Pizza Wheel
Garlic Knots with Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Slices Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Meatball
Grandma
Italian

“Best Pizza I’ve had in a long time , and you can tell they use fresh ingredients.“

4.2 Good29 Reviews
9

J & F

J & F Pizza • $
474 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza Slice
Caesar Salad with Chicken
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Meatball or Sausage
Bologna and Cheese
Spaghetti or Ziti
Special Calzone
Chicken Marsala
Pepperoni Pizza

“J&F has delicious food. Their meatballs are homemade and legendary. It is a very laid- back, small, and unassuming place on upper Broadway in Newburgh. Almost all of their business is take out- hot and cold sandwiches ( locally made bread), pizza , soup, and pasta dishes all made on site. Started by 2 brothers (John and Frank) , it has remained in the family for over 50 years. Very friendly people and good food. It's our go-to place when we need a quick meal.“

4.2 Good27 Reviews
Brooklyn Pizza Pizza • $
5273 Rte 9W, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

One Topping Pizza Slice
Stuffed Garlic Knots
Chicken Parmigiana
Cheese Pizza Slice
Brooklyn Pizza
Buffalo Knots
Sausage Roll
Cheese Slices

“The Best pizza I’ve had since coming back to NY!!!❤️“

4.1 Good34 Reviews
Villa Italia Ristorante Pizza • $
1663 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Grandma Pie by the Slice
Chicken Ceasar Wrap
Salmon with Capers
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
Warm Italian Bread
Pepperoni Calzone
Gnocci Bolognese
Pollo Parmigiano
Pastafazool Soup

“Best italian food around !😁❣️“

4 Good52 Reviews
Luca Pizza Cafe Italian • $
520 South St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad Large
Four Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Garlic Knots
White Pizza
Cheese Pie
Wings

“One of my favorite pizza spots to go to. I used to live closer, but moved away from their zone and my husband and I still go back here to get their square pizza. It's our go to spot when we want really good pizza and fresh salads. We have had the wings and paninis before and both were okay overall, but not the best.“

3.1 Average44 Reviews
Frank's Pizza Pizza • $
154 S Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza
Penne Vodka

“Best pizza, Stromboli and pasta ever and friendly staff! Whenever we go to NY from Massachusetts it’s our go to place!!! Thanks for the great Italian pizza!“

3.8 Good44 Reviews

You May Also Like