20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newfane

“1st time and it was the best pizza and fries! Thank you 😊“

“I placed a larger order for my bridal party, Wilson's could not have made a better impression!! The best/ proper chicken finger pizza, and the stinger practically vanished. 10/10 remains the most consistent pizza in town.. .If I could only get it shipped.... leftovers became breakfast, lunch, and late night snacking too! Thankful for such a wonderful addition to our weekend.“

“New to the are my wife and I ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza and a couple subs. She ordered the chicken finger sub and I ordered the turkey sub with Italian dressing (a great touch). Food was amazing (even reheated for day two breakfast LOL!). Also received a chocolate chip cookie with the sub, another great touch. We will definitely be ordering again. Well done to the staff on Saturday night 01/30/2021.“

“The pie you rely on tasting all the same and never changing never disappointed!“

“Went in tonight to get a family deal. The staff hand downs did another amazing job. whoever answered the phone and was on counter staff today was 10/10 AMAZING!!!! I am very picky but NEVER do I ever have a problem when going here or ordering! Scott Brown and the staff are amazing!!! Even when scott is not there the staff is super!! They were all working super hard tonight and it is always such a positive time, never rude, orders are never wrong and the food is ALWAYS cooked and packaged the way we ask!!! Scott Brown we just wanted to pass that along to just reinsure you that you my friend are doing an“

“They have great food and friendly service !!!“

“My daughter and I are in town on vacation and decided to try Matty’s Pizzeria for takeout, and we are so glad we did! We ordered a steak calzone, boneless wings, and extra ranch, and everything was absolutely delicious. The food was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. I also have to give a shoutout to the lady at the front counter. We asked for extra ranch, and she completely hooked us up! She went out of her way to make sure we had plenty, and that level of customer service really stood out. We enjoyed our dinner so much after a long day and will definitely be back the next time we’re in the area. Highly recommend!“

“The best pizza ever!!! Thank you Pizza Oven!!!“

“Besides the order being over 20 dollars more than what was priced on the website the food is good.“

“we eat there on occasion, never a bad meal. We went last night for Valentine's day, we both had the eggplant Parm and it was wonderful. Always great service“

“I love Tim Hortons .The coffee is awesome!!“

“we enjoy all the food on the menu“

“Just moved to America and wanted pizza for dinner. Came in wanting a couple pies for me and the family. They whipped them up fast, they tasted magnificent. The customer service was immaculate understanding what I wanted with such specific ingredients. Very professional.“

“They do indeed have fast delivery. I have never had a problem with that. However, I ordered an antipasto salad. it was very sad. I have ordered this item several times burn as delivery and in the restaurant. it has always been a very large salad. It should be at $16.99. This time it was not a large salad. it would maybe feed 2. Every time I've ordered it I was able to have 4 good size meals. The toppings were making, and the delivered it with the warm bread on top of the salad. Management was almost on the argumenative side. Not an item I'll order fir derive again“

“The young lady working the sub station was so sweet and went above and beyond when I asked her if I was able to get the toppings seperate from my subs. We will definately return. I wish I got her name. She had dark hair and was wearing glasses. Very efficient and pleasant.“

“Very accommodating, friendly awesome sub!! Thank you so much!! So appreciated. I also bought a cannoli! Let me tell you it was delicious! Crispy outside perfectly sweet inside 😋❤️“

“Great food, great service ! Love the new patio !“

“My family really likes this place. Great food. We tend to get a split pizza with wings. We've also had their Philly Cheese Steak as well. Never an issue. They do use a sweeter pizza sauce which we enjoy but mileage may vary with other folks.“

“Besides the order being over 20 dollars more than what was priced on the website the food is good.“

“My wife and I ordered 4 pizzas today on Father’s Day at 10:30am at opening because we wanted to be able to relax for at least one day this week! We were looking for a cheap, easy meal for our family of 7. My wife walked in to a stressed out staff member (not her fault at all, she was fantastic). We are more than happy to wait a little longer, as we are a large family ordering pizzas just when this business opened, and understand things take longer for bigger orders. However, I personally can not get over the feeling that this business is engaging in “leaner and meaner” because the staff member felt overwhelmed.

Her customer service skills were exceptional. Little Caesars should know that the customer experience is part of the sale and if your staff is stressed, it deteriorates from the sale. If I continue to walk in here and the staff is stressed, I will not buy from here. You will lose a customer! I’m leaving a five star review for the service from the person who works here on 06/15/25 at 10:30am, not for the company!“