40 Best Burger Restaurants near Old Bethpage

“Fast, friendly service. Gyro Platter was enough for 2 meals. Excellent!“

“This is an appreciation post for Bruno, the kind gentleman working at the register. It's my first time eating at a Smashburger and I asked for a recommendation. This man did not disappoint. I mentioned liking chicken sandwiches, so without hesitation, he steered me towards the Scorchin Crispy Chicken Sandwich WITH regular mac and cheese on top, and it was... dare I say... SMASHING 🙌 He was attentive, knowledgeable, and, most of all, sincere. Great first experience, definitely recommend Smashburger and this location, mainly because of my main man Bruno 🙏“

“Great food and even better service. Nino is the best.“

“speedy service and delicious food“

“Great tasting burgers. Tasty drinks and excelllent service“

“Today was the first time we've ever ordered from Smashburger. I was intreged with the bogo burger deal and ordered from seamless. the burgers were still hot and juicy when they arrived and fries with garlic, rosemary and olive oil were honestly the best fries Ive ever had plus the Brussels sprouts were amazing!! Can't wait to be hungry again and order more!!“

“The burgers were amazing! I had the lamb burger and it was delicious! Drinks were great and the service was fantastic! Definitely going to visit again soon!“

“Best hamburger hotdog place that serves great beer near Hosfstra University. Every time I go with my wife to visit our son who is at Hofstra despite trying to go to different venues to grab a bite before we head back to Jersey. We always end up at black label because the food is so good, the service is great the people are very friendly and the service is quick. If you’re in Hempstead or Westbury and looking for a good burger, good hotdog in a simple atmosphere black label is my first choice.“

“The fries are awesome and the “Secret Sauce” is good too! The burgers could be a little bigger. The shakes are DELICIOUS as well!“

“Ordered three times via takeout/doordash and this place has been consistently amazing. Their burgers are extremely flavorful & seasoned to perfection. Same great quality & taste every time. They accompany perfectly with (I assume) their potato buns & all the standard toppings. Toppings were added & taken off as requested via phone order.

Also, ordered the onion rings which were equally as delicious. Great crunch and flavor !!! $13ish for quick takeout double burger is a bit high IMO but taste-wise worth every penny. We’ll continue to order here, easily the best burger in Huntington, NY.

Thanks for the great service & continued delicious food. We’ll be back for sure.

-Bryan B. (takeout/doordash customer)“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ to the staff, food, cleanliness and so much patience for our kings park middle school cheerleaders that came and took over to celebrate 2nd place in their competition! Dimitri,Spiro, and Nicole were incredible thank you!“

“Delicious lunch and great atmosphere.“

“Clean. Friendly and efficient service. Food made fresh to order.“

“Dinner with wife and friend. We all ordered burgers.“

“The food - so good. Awesome service. Nice atmosphere.“

“Vauxhall has been one of our favorite places for a burger or the fried chicken sandwich. Yesterday, 5//7/24… we went for a late lunch. I decided to try the new Double Smash burger. It was by far, the best burger I’ve ever had. My wife had her usual, the fried chicken sandwich. We’ve never had anything but a great meal and drink at our favorite Huntington haunt.“

“best chicken gyro I ever ate“

“The Texas Ranger restaurant has a wonderful pedigree having been moved to its current location from its former location on the Nautical mile, a restaurant which is now called Rachel's. In the early 80s, my wife and her sister worked as waitresses there and remember the goodness of the food 45 years later. From what I understand, the new owners bought the name and the original recipes for the classic dishes for which the original Ranger was known. Forty-five years later, my wife says the recipes remain true to the original and are definitely worth a visit and revisit.“

“I got lunch there today and loved it!“

“We come from far away to have the liver Viennese. So tasty and great portions“

“I stopped by “That No Good Burger Joint” for lunch yesterday and extremely surprised at the customer service and the menu filled with options. I ordered a triple smash cheeseburger with the fries and washed it all down with 2 flat tires. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to friend and family and would plan to go back soon. The burger was cooked to perfection and the fries were just right. The server was extremely attentive and made sure my and my cousin were well taken care. I would give this restaurant a 10/10 no question.“

“What a fun spot. Good food and drinks. Great atmosphere. Staff very attentive! Owner onsite!“

“I'll start off by saying with only 1 person working the grill the guy deserves a medal for how fast he accommodated a family of 6. We tried pretty much the whole menu. I enjoyed the tots and fries but not crazy about the onion ring batter it was quite thick. Burgers were what you'd expect but the real star for me was the crispy chicken sandwhich. I got it with pickles, mayo and added pepper jack cheese - it was bomb.“

“With a winter storm about to hit Long Island, we decided it was the perfect night for true comfort food — and picked up at GG’s Marsala Grill in Huntington Station absolutely delivered.

Tucked along Route 110, flanked by two large retailers, this small and unassuming spot could easily be overlooked — but that would be a mistake. The moment you step inside, you realize this place is something special. It’s warm, welcoming, and focused on what matters most: incredible food.

We ordered the Tiki Marsala (Butter Chicken), Aloo Mattar, Chicken Biryani, Tandoori Malai Kebab, and fresh Garlic Naan — and every single dish was outstanding.

The Tiki Marsala was rich, velvety, and perfectly spiced — that deep, comforting flavor that warms you from the inside out. The Aloo Mattar was beautifully balanced, with tender potatoes and peas in a savory, aromatic sauce that paired perfectly with the naan. The Chicken Biryani was fragrant and layered with flavor, each bite showcasing perfectly cooked rice and well-seasoned chicken. The Tandoori Malai Kebab was unbelievably tender and juicy, with just the right amount of smokiness from the tandoor. And the garlic naan? Fresh, soft, and the ideal companion to soak up every last bit of sauce on the plate.

Before the snow even started falling, GG’s had already created the perfect storm of flavor.

If you’re in Huntington Station and craving authentic, satisfying comfort food — especially on a cold winter night — GG’s Marsala Grill should be at the top of your list. Small spot. Big flavor. Absolutely worth stopping in.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review

I hosted a party of 20 at Applebee’s, and the entire experience was absolutely outstanding! From the moment we arrived, the staff was warm, organized, and incredibly accommodating. Handling a large group is never easy, but they made it look effortless.

Our server Alexandra went above and beyond, keeping drinks full, orders accurate, and everyone happy. The food came out quickly, hot, and perfectly cooked. Not a single mistake, which is impressive for such a big party! Every guest raved about both the service and the quality of the food.

The team Projwal Pradhan, Alexandra and Angel truly made our celebration smooth, enjoyable, and stress-free. I’m so grateful for their professionalism and kindness. We will definitely be returning for future gatherings!

Highly recommend this location for any event or large group, top-notch service and delicious food! 🍽️✨“

“The Plainview Burger King is the best I've seen. It's a very clean, well kept establishment(definitely appreciate their eye for detail. They put flowers on the tables and when the holidays roll around they make that extra effort to be festive and make it aesthetically pleasing) and the food is always fresh. And the staff DON'T carry around chips on their shoulders greeting you with rude disrespectful attitudes. Great 👍 job BK. I Highly recommend this location.
The Jericho location is crap! They don't understand the directives, they don't understand what you're saying, and then they have the nerve to get a serious attitude with you when THEY screw up because they didn't get it in the first place! Don't come here unless you speak more than one language“

“The staff is always so friendly!“

“First time at Cachapas in East Meadow tonight. We were just looking for something different for us. The food was amazing. Huge portions. Anything pernil is my recommendation. The service was perfect. We were there early, so very quiet. Staff was very friendly.“

“Went in for breakfast. Our server was decent. Walked away as I was finishing telling him my order, which came out ICE COLD & WRONG!!!! I requested a ham, COOKED/SAUTÉED ONION & American cheese omelet, fries and RYE toast with crispy bacon. My omelet was well done, the onions RAW, fries were ice cold my bacon was not cooked and not there had to tell the runner, and my toast was marble. All this for OVER &50.00!!! The server came by, we were basically finished. Asked how everything was. How would he or the runner know our order. Neither one looked at the order. NEVER AGAIN!!!“

“Just ordered for the first time and food was delicious!!! Chicken was nice and crispy. Ribs were super tender meat fell off the bone 🍖 Definitely will be ordering again“

“I visited twice:
1) August 6, 2025 (Wed). Had a double cheeseburger
2) August 15, 2025 (Fri). Had a Whopper, large fries, & Hershey sundae
Gets very busy unlike most Burger Kings. In a busy area. There’s an abandoned Burger King in the back. Cool artifact of history. Looks like it’s been closed since the 90’s. Has a Coke Freestyle Machine. But sometimes it’s out of flavors. Can get free fries in the app. Dined in both times.“

“I haven't eaten Burger King in awhile. I forgot how good a Whopper tastes. The cashier was very nice and the place was clean. My only complaint was that is was freezing.“

“They are friendly, fresh food, I recommend it

Vegetarian options: Impossible chopper

Dietary restrictions: Each portion has the number of calories *chopper* *burger*

Kid-friendliness: kids meal“

“We're a picky family when it comes to Pizza. Thin crust is important and the sauce should not be boring. We got a Neapolitan Pie yesterday and it was DELICIOUS! I highly recommend their pizza“

“Everything from the atmosphere to the server Nick to the drinks the hamburgers to the most awesome chocolate chip cookies was excellent.“

“Consistently solid Burger King. The staff is friendly, the food is always consistent, and the restaurant is spotless every time I’m here. Only reason for 4 stars instead of 5: the men’s room could use a little more frequent attention. Otherwise, they’re doing a great job.“

“1st time here, the burger and the choices were awesome, the pretzels bites yum! highly recommend the mustard, it must have honey in it. delish!“

“This review is specifically for the Wantagh NY location. The quality at BKlocations varies greatly. This one is by far the best I've been to. The orders are served hot & fresh without screw-ups. You really can't ask for more from a fast food joint.“