13 Best American Restaurants in Oneonta

The Autumn Cafe American • $$
244 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

House Braised Brisket Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich with Fries
Reuben Pastrami or Tempeh
Fried Plantain Appetizer
Veggie Spring Rolls
Nashville Chicken
Korean BBQ Bowl
Fried Plantains
Classic Burger
Grilled Cheese

“We had dinner on 8/14, our first visit, definitely not our last. Excellent bartender, excellent food and cocktails!!!“

4.2 Good55 Reviews
The Depot Restaurant and Tavern American • $
4 1/2 Railroad Ave, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Garbage Sauce Golden Sauce Wings
Wings with Garlic Sauce on Side
Deluxe Pizza Mild Chicken Wings
Patty Melt with Side of Fries
Tain Wreck Burger and Fries
Deluxe Pizza Mild Wings
Filet Mignon and Shrimp
Chicken Wing Flatbread
Black and Bleu Burger
Buffalo Chicken Salad

“Fantastic Experience Fantastic Food“

4.3 Superb60 Reviews
The Bistro – Eat. Drink. Connect.® American • $$
116 Courtyard Dr, Oneonta

“This hotel was perfect for our family. We were there for the Cooperstown All Star Village baseball tournament. The rooms were clean and comfortable and we enjoyed the pool and breakfast. The hotel is not too far from the baseball at CASV. It worked out well for us!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Our Town Cafe & Pub American • $$
5206 NY-23, Oneonta

“Was fortunate enough to be able to get pizza & wings for a last minute grad party - they were fantastic ! Just one question - when are you going to reopen? (Were told garlic knots are not usually on your menu - they were a huge hit!)“

4.3 Superb3 Reviews
Applebee's Grill + Bar American • $
5006 NY-23 Box M25, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

4 Cheese Mac and Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken Tenders
Baby Back Ribs with Steamed Broccoli and Mashed Potatoes
Half Rack of Ribs with Mac and Cheese
Bourbon Street Mushroom Swiss Burger
Shrimp with Pasta with Alfredo Sauce
Tex-Mex Lime-Grilled Shrimp Bowl
Taco Topped Queso and Chips
3 Cheese Chicken Penne
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Corn Chips and Queso

“Matt and Courtney were the amazing!“

4 Good212 Reviews
Wise Guys Sammy's Sandwich Shop • $
261-267 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Full Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli
Mikes Big F'in Chicken Sandwich
Tuscan Broccoli Potato Soup
Traditional Grandma Pizza
Bacon Lettuce Tomato
Roast Beef Sandwich
Alabama Connection
Wyatt Earp Large
California Kid
Club Buffalo

“Their food is amazing. I am gluten free due to celiac and have a hard time finding something in the area worth getting. This place is definitely the place if you are looking for good gluten free options.“

4.6 Superb64 Reviews
Oneonta Bagel Co Bagels • $
171 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese on an Everything Bagel

“Great prices, large portions, friendly service. Breakfast potatoes are banging!“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews
Yellow Deli Deli • $
134 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Potato Soup with Homemade Bread
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Sweet Potato Pound Cake
Cranberry Cashew Salad
Butternut Squash Soup
Reuben Sandwich
Veggie Burger
Cinnamon Roll
Carrot Cake
Sandwiches

“Best keep secret. This eclectic little spot was amazing. You walk in and it’s like you walked into a fairy tale story! So much to take in. The service was amazing with friendly people, and the food and choices…Yummers! We’re here for the Casey Clubhouse baseball tournament here in Coopertown, NY. Yes, I’ll be telling everyone who will listen to stop in. They won’t regret a thing! (They have several locations across the world! Next stop, Plymouth , MA location)“

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Humphrey's Gourmet to Go, Inc. Bar • $$
437 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

March 1 2 Only Special New Orleans Gumbo
Chicken Marsala with Rice and Broccoli
Meatloaf with Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Dry Aged Ribeye Steak Queen Cut
FF Chicken Marsala over Rice
Humphrey’S Famous Burger
Fudge Brownie a La Mode
FF BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Pan Seared Salmon

“That most welcome of culinary surprises. After one visit I was immediately planning my return and my next order. Well done! Hats off to you both and 6 STARS!!! ⭐️👌🤌“

4.5 Superb12 Reviews
Red's Ale House & Grill Bar & Grill • $
84 Main St, Oneonta

“Really great wings w tons of flavors. Not really sure whats up w there Hrs though....i was there a few weeks ago on a Friday at 6pm and the place was dark and no1 answered phone. the next week I was there on a Saturday at 5pm and same thing....waited until 6....still nothing. There FB page said they were open to. Hope they didn't close up cause there foods really good“

4.8 Superb5 Reviews
Shooters 5-7 Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1 S Main St, Oneonta

“Came into town for Cooperstown for baseball and this place was absolutely amazing the food is top notch and the service is amazing 150% recommend this place and especially the burgers“

3 Average4 Reviews
NAGS Bar and Kitchen Bar & Grill • $
221 Main St, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Nags Burger and Fries
Korean Fried Chicken
Super Bowl Salad
Twisted Poutine
Classic Burger
Shrimp Tacos
Meatloaf
Burgers

“Nice, welcoming layout along with staff! The food was great! The salmon was cooked to perfection, the Fajita Pita (substituted the chicken with the steak) was yummy…along with eggplant fries (huge WOW) and a classic burger which was dependably very good. Oh…you’ve got to try the pumpkin lava cake and lemon drop! Great menu. Can’t go wrong here. Highly recommend.“

3.8 Good101 Reviews
13

Denny's

Denny's Diner • $
4979 NY-23, Oneonta

Customers` Favorites

Hash Browns Toast and Two Sunny Side Up Eggs
55 Scrambled Eggs & Cheddar Breakfast
Chicken Fried Steak with Broccoli
Bourbon Chicken Sizzlin' Skillet
Scrambled Egg with Pancakes
Mile High Denver Omelette
Blueberry Pancakes Bites
Ham and Cheese Omelette
Kids Pancake Breakfast
Loaded Veggie Omelette

“My wife and I stopped in for breakfast with our two children (ages 11 and 13) before heading to our travel baseball games in Cooperstown.

The service at the Denny’s in Oneonta was absolutely fantastic — Debbie was so friendly and made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in.

The food was excellent, with plenty of breakfast menu options, and everything came out quickly and hot.

The restaurant was clean, comfortable, and family-friendly, making it the perfect stop for travelers, baseball families, and anyone passing through on their way to Cooperstown.

Highly recommend this Denny’s for great service, delicious food, and a welcoming atmosphere!“

3.8 Good112 Reviews

You May Also Like