50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oyster Bay

“Nice and easy pizzeria in the area :) I step in at quite night, self order and they bring our food to the table. This is just my test and my own opinion. I don't like the food at all but nothing wrong with the food and how they prepare it. My Italian husband love the food, he actually brings my order home and finish it later. I get shrimp in garlic oil and when the food comes, it isn't like I expect at all. So, all I want to say is I just like food that is not in thick flour and not too oily. Order I get, maybe it is an Italian style and that is how they prepare the food. Anyway, service is good, friendly and very family style.“

“We catered our Easter dinner from Pizza Cucina in Westbury. The food was fabulous, especially the Shrimp Scampi, which is something we have not ordered as yet. The meal was on time and everyone made comments about how good the food was. Thank you for a great Easter dinner?“

“The pizza was excellent and just as good as the New Hyde Park location. We loved everything about both the Sicilian and Regular pizza.🍕🍕🍕. We highly recommend and will be back!!!!“

“Hands down, one of the finest restaurants on the North Shore. Be sure to make a reservation, as it's intimate. Top notch Chef with a staff to match.“

“We had the most incredible experience at Pietro’s of East Meadow — again! This was our second time celebrating our daughter’s birthday here, and it somehow keeps getting better every time. A huge shoutout to Oscar and the team there today, who were beyond helpful and so attentive. Oscar made everything feel effortless and was so intuitive — taking care of things before I even had to ask. That kind of service is rare and so appreciated. The girls had the BEST time, and I honestly can’t say enough good things about the staff and the whole experience. Thank you for making our girl’s day so special — we’ll be back again for sure!“

“This pizzeria is top notch, my kids prefer this place over any other pizza in the area, you can literally taste the fresh quality of the food in every bite. I would 10/10 recommend to anyone in the area who is looking for food that’s made from the heart with fresh ingredients“

“Great food and outstanding services. Highly recommended.“

“😍 Outstanding Delicious Grandma Vodka Pizza . Best Eggplant Parmigiana. Amazing old school SOUPS ! Best Bolognese Sauce!“

“It was a wonderful time. The food was outstanding in the service was exceptional. We will be back in again. Pasta was outstanding. You have to try the linguini marinara.

Kid-friendliness: They were they were very accommodating and welcoming and friendly and treated the children with respect.“

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“Great local slice shop. The regular slice was solid and the spicy vodka slice was really good because of the added chili peppers but I felt the vodka sauce itself was bland. I actually had to double check to make sure it was a vodka slice after the fact but either way it was a great slice of pizza. Took a pistachio bombolone home and it was absolutely spectacular. These are a must get and they have different flavors as well.“

“We had a wonderful meal and experience at Galleria of Merrick! The spicy rigatoni is a MUST! The pasta was cooked perfectly al dente and every bite was a flavor explosion. I love that they put a unique twist on traditional Italian dishes and you can really taste the difference of the quality, care and detail that went into each dish. They truly cook with love. If you’re looking for an excellent meal in a cozy atmosphere you must go to the Galleria of Merrick. We will definitely be back!!!!

Kid-friendliness: Cozy atmosphere that is family friendly.“

“I live down the block so I'm happy this is a quality pizza place. Their regular, square vodka and chicken bacon ranch slices are great and you get good value for your dollar. The chicken bacon ranch is the best i have ever had. I would have given this place 5 stars if they made the Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices like they do the chicken bacon ranch. Unfortunately, those are usually my go to slices but for some reason they take a very different approach than they do the chicken bacon ranch and it definitely doesn't work. I recommend giving this place a try especially if you live in the neighborhood.“

“Wanted some authentic NY pizza during my stay. They nailed it! Antipasto is amazing and they couldn’t have been nicer. Kind of want to move to NY just for the food 🤣“

“Amazing food and service. Would definitely recommend. Was my first time here and it was phenomenal. Drinks amazing as well.“

“Pizza is great. We had pepperoni with hot honey. Definitely one of the better pizzas in the area. We went there on Saturday afternoon and we had to wait about 45 minutes for one pie. They only have 1 small oven, but there is bar so you can enjoy couple of beers while you wait. Even though the pizza is good, you don't get a lot of it for your money. We paid $30 for the pie, which is 6 small slices.“

“A big Shout out to GUSTOSO’s Pizzeria for hosting my sister’s 29th birthday celebration. I absolutely adored the family vibe that you feel as soon as you walk in. This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Huntington now :blush:. Owners allowed us to bring our own décor. The food was fantastic and no matter what we ordered we were delighted with our meal! But if you ask me the Chicken Alla Vodka was DELICIOUS! Special thanks to Jasmine our server, she was such a pleasure to be around, very efficient, happy, and polite. Can’t wait to return and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for a small friendly place that will make it a memorable experience to the ones you love.“

“Ate at this establishment in Farmingdale yesterday evening! Best pizza we have ever had! Fast friendly service will definitely be returning when I come back area“

“Just visiting the area from out of town! Did we ever get lucky to find this place! Amazing food!
George and Chris went above and beyond!
It’s one thing to eat a good meal but when the people working behind the counter care you can taste it in the food! Huge portions, fair prices! Don’t drive by! Stop in and see some Long Island charm!“

“creativos algo diferente...es más que pizzas.“

“Really good pizza ! ordered the upside down Sicilian and it was perfect. ordered it well done. The bottom was crispy and the dough was perfect ! Really good pizza sauce ! Also had a plain slice and it was very good! Fried calamari were Very good !“

“Visiting back up from Florida.
Yes most pizza in NY is better than FL.
But this place is insane!!!
The grandma pie is without a doubt the best I’ve ever had in my 57 years!!!
So good, we’re heading there right now to get more!
Chicken bacon ranch is on point as well!“

“Best food and pizza around!“

“Love this place ! Always a great meal ! Thanks Daniella !“

“We just had the most amazing experience with Marcianos. They are top-notch 100% professional and a fun added element to any party or celebration. They recently catered my daughter and future son-in-law’s engagement party and we had so many compliments on the quality of the food and the entire display, we will highly recommend and use again.“

“Great vegan food. The options are always appreciated. One of the most extensive vegan menus for pizzerias I've ever seen.

Hoping one day for some vegan cannolis! Haven't seen anything on the menu yet but a man can dream!“

“Pizza is amazing and sushi is fresh and delicious. My favorite place in NY“

“DELICIOUS!! The crust is so crispy, the sauce is fantastic! The hot honey pepperoni burrata slice is amazing!!“

“They make the absolutely best Pizza 🍕 the GRAMMA PIZZA US JUST THE BEST!!!“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“Even though I have to travel from 5 towns over, I will do it time and again because I LOVE everything about Mama's. Their Chicken a la Mama, as well as their Granma Vodka pizza brings me to my knees without fail. I'm a bit picky (like extra lemon butter sauce and garlic knots please) but the staff always gets it right. You KNOW a restaurant is top notch when the staff smiles from the moment you walk through the door until you leave. Thank you for everything Mama's. I'll see you again VERY soon. Dont change a thing....“

“Mike put on a great show for our scouts and then we enjoyed amazing pizza. I highly recommend them!“

“we had a pie half sausage half pepperoni it was great. the price was great to. we will definitely go back!!“

“Amazingly flavorful pizza with fresh ingredients! I loved the Metro East, cant wait to try some of the others!!!“

“Kids had fun and I enjoyed it more than I expected to. Service and performers deserve five -plus stars. So much energy and on top of the timing and service. Great place for kids to get out that built-up energy especially on the trampolines.

Kid-friendliness: The young people working there were really good at their jobs“

“Tonight I just wanted appetizers ordered chicken wings original and mozzarella sticks. Not disappointed everything was hot and delicious upon delivery. Give them a try!“

“great host,excellent waitstaff fantastic food a great dining experience very attended. nice fresh food love this place going there since opening day.“

“Amazing food! We order from them every week! I love their salad pizza and the fact that they have gluten free options makes it even better! Their minestrone soup is delicious as well! The food is always piping hot & ready, we never have to wait! Their staff is super friendly and always get our order right! Highly recommend Rustica!!! 🙂💗“

“My sister ordered 20 Pizzas for the nurses in ICU at LIJ that are taking care of the Covid patients. Roma generously gave them at half price! Please please give them your business! They gave back to our community!“

“We have been using Garden City Pizza’s catering for our parties for years. The food is always amazing & outstanding service, especially from Greg. He is honest & really cares, as if it is for his own party. He always goes above and beyond to make our parties great and helps me figure out how much food is needed. Our guests are always complimenting the food and asking where it is catered from. Their prices are reasonable & they even delivered to St James!“

“Legitimately the best pizza I ever had. I look forward to every pie she makes and I’ve never had one I didn’t like! The calzones and cannolis are ridiculously good too. 11/10 every day“

“Awesome staff and excellent pizza!“

“Amazing pizzas Esp the Roman, go and try it. The owner Rob is great too!“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“My new favorite pizza❤️🇮🇹🍕. My wife and I went on a recommendation from my friend Bobby . So glad we went. I can’t wait to take my daughters back to let them enjoy it.“

“Great food great atmosphere the owner Steve is there all the time love the meatballs drive from Patchogue to Huntington just to get that food. Much appreciate it. It’s definitely worth the drive.“

“Best restaurant bar in Long Island Has great deals Uber best spot Great customer service Highly recommend“

“We had a very enjoyable luncheon and celebratory birthday party for one of our members, Wednesday, 11/8/23 for 21 member. The food and service was excellent. The staff is very pleasant and easy to work with and the owner is very thoughtful and generous. This is the third time we have had a luncheon there and will definitely return.“

“We went there last night for the first time. Delicious food, great entertainment. The singer Al played all great songs. Loved the back dining area. Covered by a tent, flowers decorating the pillars. They desserts were incredible.. Tiramisu like its meant to be. We will be going back very very soon. Menu was huge so many things to choose from.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access“

“Best Pizza in town!! Whenever I travel from out state and desiring a pizza, this is true come and the over customer service is superb! Thank you for all you wonderful dedication to serve the public.

Parking: Parking is available at the rear of the building“