50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oyster Bay

“We catered our Easter dinner from Pizza Cucina in Westbury. The food was fabulous, especially the Shrimp Scampi, which is something we have not ordered as yet. The meal was on time and everyone made comments about how good the food was. Thank you for a great Easter dinner?“

“The vodka pizza is what makes me drive damn near 40 minutes to get. Easy to order over the phone everything was ready when I got there. Love their white pizza. Plain and pepperoni are always good but all the speciality pizzas of theirs I’ve had so far are really good.“

“The pizza was excellent and just as good as the New Hyde Park location. We loved everything about both the Sicilian and Regular pizza.🍕🍕🍕. We highly recommend and will be back!!!!“

“Hands down, one of the finest restaurants on the North Shore. Be sure to make a reservation, as it's intimate. Top notch Chef with a staff to match.“

“What a gem of a place. Made dinner reservations for the Igloos out back. The kids thought that was super cool. The inside was very warm feeling. Our waitress Rebecca was outstanding. The food was absolutely delicious.“

“It was a wonderful time. The food was outstanding in the service was exceptional. We will be back in again. Pasta was outstanding. You have to try the linguini marinara.

Kid-friendliness: They were they were very accommodating and welcoming and friendly and treated the children with respect.“

“Today we had my daughter’s high school graduation party at Red Volpe ! it housed 50 people in their aide party room- we chose buffet style- we did cash bar - and it was AH amazing ! Salvatore (the owner) and his staff were on point ! Thirty teens plus the rest of the crowd can’t stop raving about the food - chicken francais- chicken parm - vodka pasta- caesar salad- rolls - mozzarella sticks- meatballs- we got to choose what we wanted and we designed the menu ! Sal scooped italian ices for dessert and I also brought in NoFoDoCo custom mini doughnuts. I sat in the bar area and Sal made amazing drinks- blueberry smash is one of my new faves ! We also created a little space for photo back drop ! This local place is a great addition to Bethpage and cannot wait to frequent it for dinners and lunches. I have also had their pizza which is delicious as well !“

“😍 Outstanding Delicious Grandma Vodka Pizza . Best Eggplant Parmigiana. Amazing old school SOUPS ! Best Bolognese Sauce!“

“Amazingly flavorful pizza with fresh ingredients! I loved the Metro East, cant wait to try some of the others!!!“

“An amazing experience here at Bellagio. Fresh pizza, pasta, appetizers (clams, buffalo wings). They greeted us and were extremely patient and informative to all requests. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a quick slice or a sit down dinner. Also to mention they have HALAL pepperoni and Chicken, easily making them a 1 of 1.“

“creativos algo diferente...es más que pizzas.“

“Love this place. Been to it a couple of times and the pizza is amazing. The Garlic Knots Slider were good but not great and at $11 not worth it. The pizza though is incredible. Really good Sicilian speciality slices.

Had the cheese steak which was really good as well but I wish I didn't have to spend so much money to eat here.“

“Great food and outstanding services. Highly recommended.“

“Ate at this establishment in Farmingdale yesterday evening! Best pizza we have ever had! Fast friendly service will definitely be returning when I come back area“

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“We're a picky family when it comes to Pizza. Thin crust is important and the sauce should not be boring. We got a Neapolitan Pie yesterday and it was DELICIOUS! I highly recommend their pizza“

“Really good pizza ! ordered the upside down Sicilian and it was perfect. ordered it well done. The bottom was crispy and the dough was perfect ! Really good pizza sauce ! Also had a plain slice and it was very good! Fried calamari were Very good !“

“This was my 4th time back to Root & Branch Brewery and my 3rd time having pizza from Nico’s Charred Pies. Had the pleasure of being able to try their new square pie. It was very light and crispy. I would’ve liked to put some toppings on it, but was interested in just trying it as is, which is “upside down” style! I really enjoyed the crust - there was visible olive oil on there - yum! The round pie is the spicy red. Large, thin slices of garlic and a fiery kick! The crust was thin and crispy!“

“This is pizza to drive miles for!! 😋“

“Love this place ! Always a great meal ! Thanks Daniella !“

“They make the absolutely best Pizza 🍕 the GRAMMA PIZZA US JUST THE BEST!!!“

“Wanted some authentic NY pizza during my stay. They nailed it! Antipasto is amazing and they couldn’t have been nicer. Kind of want to move to NY just for the food 🤣“

“I loved the pizza truck the food and the service was amazing I recommend everyone who loves great food should hire them. They are a family owned business with the friendliest people we really enjoyed having them ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Just ordered a large pizza for delivery. Unfortunately the crust was very well done/burnt, changed the awesome flavor their pizza always has. Called them up, explained the situation. 20 min later delivery driver pulled up with the most perfect Friday Pizza Pie. Kudos to your staff. Thank you for making it right without questioning anything! This is why we order frequently from your store front“

“Gino's Pizzeria of Lynbrook is fantastic.
I had been going there since I was a young kid. The guys there are the best and treat all their regulars like family.
Back in 2015 I had to move abroad for work and when I returned back to the States I had to setttle in the Midwest.
After almost 10 years of not being able to visit Gino's one could say I missed it a lot.
Ass soon as I got back to NY on a family visit I made sure to stop there.
They remembered me the second I walked in and that speaks to the great level of how they treat their customers.
I can't say enough good things about them.
My absolute favorite place.
Their pizza is the best. Recommend their Cesar salad Pie as most places just don't get it right but Gino's Lynbrook gets it spot on.
Very traditional NY pizzeria from the atmosphere to the service not to mention their delicious menu options.

100% recommended.“

“Amazing food! We order from them every week! I love their salad pizza and the fact that they have gluten free options makes it even better! Their minestrone soup is delicious as well! The food is always piping hot & ready, we never have to wait! Their staff is super friendly and always get our order right! Highly recommend Rustica!!! 🙂💗“

“Staff was incredible and the food was delish! Highly recommend! Did I tell you the drinks were awesome?!“

“great host,excellent waitstaff fantastic food a great dining experience very attended. nice fresh food love this place going there since opening day.“

“Delicious!! Beautiful family !! Wonderful staff.. I highly recommend 😊“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“My wife and I have ordered from Previti for several years now thru Door Dash. the food has always been excellent. The other day I had a call from Previti. It was the owner, Joe. He told me that my mother had wandered in after having her car bumper come completely loose on Marcus Ave. She had no phone, and was shaken up by the whole ordeal. Joe called me for her, and gave her a cup of hot tea. I went over, picked her up and got her home. Later my wife and I returned to pick up her car. We decided to eat dinner there and take advantage of the pasta night specials. The lasagna and the rigatoni with meat sauce were both excellent. Thank you Joe and staff for taking good care of my mother, and providing us with an excellent meal! All the best!“

“Best pizza in Massapequa. This was already our favorite spot… then I decided I would ask them to make a gender reveal pizza for me and my husband. I go inside with my 3 children and ask the man to look at my email without me seeing it. He is very helpful and puts the order in for me. My husband picks the pizza up later that night and came home saying “he wouldn’t charge me for it!” Very unexpected and made it clear that what was special for us was special to them also. ❤️ We opened the pizza together later and saw a big G on it, telling us the new baby was a girl after 3 boys. We will always remember this special memory!“

“Awesome staff and excellent pizza!“

“Best food and pizza around!“

“I live down the block so I'm happy this is a quality pizza place. Their regular, square vodka and chicken bacon ranch slices are great and you get good value for your dollar. The chicken bacon ranch is the best i have ever had. I would have given this place 5 stars if they made the Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices like they do the chicken bacon ranch. Unfortunately, those are usually my go to slices but for some reason they take a very different approach than they do the chicken bacon ranch and it definitely doesn't work. I recommend giving this place a try especially if you live in the neighborhood.“

“I’ve been going here since I was little and boy have they always delivered, like if I had to choose best pizza place this would be it 100% only gripes I got are that sometimes the pizza is different like more cheese less sauce little issues every blue moon. My favorite dish here is the spaghetti and meatballs and if I had to choose taste this would be my equivalent of heaven on earth. Overall would eat here as long as I live within a 1 hour distance.“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“Great pizza, Great home made soups, friendly service“

“Always A Great Experience here. Food is Great. Staff is Excellent. Best Specialty Pies in the neighborhood. If you have not tried Pappardelle's. You Should !!“

“Great Pizza Thanks Nick,John“

“Delicious wood fired pizza with great combos of toppings. We had the Pepperoni and Peppers, Hot Mesa and my favorite - Maple Bacon. They offer gluten free with an option of no crust. Dessert was local favorite cherry pie from Young’s Farm and the Cowboy Cookie is my kryptonite. Attentive friendly service. Loved the music and the vibe. Perfect casual place for delicious pizza! Having been a fan since they opened, it’s great to see that the pizzas are offered now in local grocery markets in the freezer section. And you can make a reservation on the website which I didn’t know as we’ve been frequenting this place as a drop by for quite a while.“

“Best pizza place in town. I can't recommend them enough. The food is delicious. Order. Order. Order.“

“Amazing food and service. Would definitely recommend. Was my first time here and it was phenomenal. Drinks amazing as well.“

“Even though I have to travel from 5 towns over, I will do it time and again because I LOVE everything about Mama's. Their Chicken a la Mama, as well as their Granma Vodka pizza brings me to my knees without fail. I'm a bit picky (like extra lemon butter sauce and garlic knots please) but the staff always gets it right. You KNOW a restaurant is top notch when the staff smiles from the moment you walk through the door until you leave. Thank you for everything Mama's. I'll see you again VERY soon. Dont change a thing....“

“Love this place, always friendly people to welcome you in, All the food is Amazingly Delicious, take out or eating in. I tell all my friends about this place.“

“Great food great atmosphere the owner Steve is there all the time love the meatballs drive from Patchogue to Huntington just to get that food. Much appreciate it. It’s definitely worth the drive.“

“Yes, there are gluten free items here that are marked on the menu HOWEVER I thankfully had a waitress that basically said that their is airborne flour everywhere and that cross contamination is almost guaranteed for anything baked in the oven with the pizza (for example their baked GF chicken Parm dish). I was so appreciative how clear she was, saying that the gluten free pasta is boiled separately though they still can't guarantee it is celiac-safe. I risked it and got a pasta dish and fortunately didn't get sick. I hope they can find a way to make truly Celiac safe gluten free foods because their GF pasta was phenomenal!“

“amazing 👏 food, service, amazing all around“

“BEST PIZZAREA IN NEW YORK HANDS DOWN“

“Outstanding pizza and wings. Ice cold beer. Great atmosphere and service is top notch“