50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Penfield

“Wow! Had an awesome plate of Chicken Riggies! And the staff are all amazing! Well done Team Capone! 🖤“

“The staff Friday at 5 was awesome. Polite, friendly and helpful. My 7 y/o son like to contribute and ordered our pizza. Great service for such a young team. Manager did a great job organizing her team!“

“I’ve always loved Cam’s Pizza—they never disappoint! The staff is incredibly friendly and consistently go above and beyond. During my recent visit, I had the chance to chat with the granddaughter of the original founder, and it was such a great moment to share how many good memories I have of their pizza from growing up in the area. I couldn’t resist grabbing a few extra slices when I saw all the delicious options while picking up my order. Just an all-around fantastic experience, as always!“

“I order from Mark's in penfield pretty frequently and their consistency is out of this world. I am never let down by their buffalo chicken or old fashioned pepperoni pizzas. Their calzones are excellent and I would highly recommend all of their appetizers. Location is very convenient.“

“Fantastic food. Great atmosphere, huge menu. Highly recommend!“

“The experience was amazing, the owner took his own time to help out me and my family, we were really satisfied with our service and we will definitely be back soon sooner. we usually went to Mark’s, but then we tried Perry’s, it was way better and more importantly the customer service was fantastic. The owner took his own time to talk to me and my family, and make sure that we were satisfied. I would highly recommend to anyone else looking for a great quality pizza. Perry’s Penfield is best!“

“I just wanted to Thank the employees at Wegmans, espically the Customer Service people and Custoidians as well as the rigister staff.I lost my hearing aid on Monday. I tried to track it with my app on my phone but couldn" t find it. The Front End Staff and Customer Service as well as the Helping hands tried to help as well. I left my name and number to call if they founf it and they also alertred the custoidial staff as well but I thought it was lost. Well the next afternoon I got a phone call saying they found it!! Special thanks to custoidal staff and Alex at the register for finding it and turning it into customer service! Wegmans has a very caring staff and although we are all under stress at this time with covid, they still take the time to care. I would recommend this store to anyone. You have a great staff of people. Just know I really appreciare your caring!! Peggy Stockmeister“

“Absolutely love the food! I am the only vegan in my family and we finally found a place we can all eat at and enjoy together! The pizza is so good and the Milkshakes are Awesome!“

“Very good pizza. We had 3 12in pies, all were enjoyable. Thin crust, good toppings.

The selection of toppings is not as widely varied as dome places, but we had no trouble making satisfying choices. Stuffed garlic cheese bread very good, pie sauce outstanding.

We would happily go back.“

“The best pizza I've ever tasted in Rochester and nearby areas. It's worth every penny. You can feel the good quality of the products.Definitely my new favorite pizza spot. Continue with the tremendous service and your good quality products.“

“Best pizza the original roni!“

“Had a 12 inch cup and char pizza today and it was instantly added to my top five local pizzerias in the area. If you’re in the area and looking for a good meal, stop here!“

“Picked up a delicious pizza tonight, and bought a container of Italian cookies….the BEST I’ve ever had.“

“absolutely some of the best pizza and wings I've ever eaten. staff was so friendly as well. I highly recommend them. So delicious and cooked to perfection.“

“Awesome awesome awesome food. Loved the meatball and cheese garlic bread appetizers. Lot of flavor and lot of cheese! Also had chicken parm sandwich and meatball sandwich. Bread was great, not a tough or super thick ciabatta. Also placed a to go order and had no wait upon arrival. Very much looking forward to returning!“

“Food was good. Had wings and beef on weck. Service was not good. Sat at a booth in the bar area. This was a Saturday at 4pm. Not busy at all. Took 15 minutes for a waitress to even acknowledge us even though there was at least 3-4 that we saw wandering around. Definitely not as good as the original, but hoping they’ll work out some of the kinks.“

“I LOVE this place. Create a pizza is my all time favorite spot. I’ve been coming here for years and I recommend it to every person I come across. Especially those with dietary restrictions. The food is always delicious, there are always friendly smiles behind the counter, and the prices are pretty unbeatable. Hands down, best pizza joint in Rochester.“

“We stopped in last night everyone was so welcoming and nice and the food was great!!! It was hot and fresh and soooo good!! 10 out of 10 for us 😋“

“First time ordering here since we moved to the East side and I have to say it’s the best pizza I’ve had yet! Great for people who like a thinner crust with a healthy amount of sauce. The brick oven crust is SO good. We loved the buffalo chicken pizza, their house wing sauce they use is unique, and it was a nice shake up to traditional buffalo sauce. Also their house red on our pepperoni pizza was fantastic! 😍“

“I just found the best turkey sub on the face of the Earth“

“nothing there nasty the place is nasty the food is spoiled rat infestation health department has violations food poisoning cases owner is a supposedly a Christan but a compulsive gambler“

“This is the best pizza in Western New York. I've been going there for 46 years and never been disappointed! Tony & Mike are amazing and I always look forward to the time w/ them. Prices are beyond reasonable.“

“We did an honor flight event that sends veterans to to washing DC to see monuments made in their honor. Mozzeroni’s was so generous. They donated pizzas for our event and fed our riders. We are so grateful for their generosity. What great neighbors. The pizza is always fantastic. Thanks again They will always have our business“

“Ordered a pizza. Loved the light crust and all the cheesy pepperoni and mushrooms, and the rest was history. I would pick up next time and eat in the car so I could enjoy the still crispy crust edges. Another reviewer described it as pillowy.“

“A Huge Thank You to Mike at Cam’s Pizzeria!
I just want to give a heartfelt thank you to Mike, the manager at Cam’s Pizzeria, for his generous support of our Friday night meeting. He gifted us with so many pizzas for our group, and it truly meant a lot to everyone there. His kindness and willingness to give back to the community does not go unnoticed. The pizza was amazing as always, but it’s the heart behind it that really made a difference. Thank you, Mike — you’re appreciated more than you know. Will be back .“

“Great food, drinks, and atmosphere.“

“Our neighbor recently recommended Pizza chef so we gave it a whirl after some other very well respected pizza places in the Fairport/Bushnells basin area have REALLY fallen off. Pleased to say after ordering a couple times from here that we have a new favorite for NY style pizza. It’s been consistent each time we’ve ordered so far and tastes great. The style of pie is very reminiscent of the classic slice shops on the corners in Manhattan. Not overpriced either so the value proposition is great! Definitely worth trying if you’re craving that style of pizza. And the people working there have always been nice and pleasant. Looking forward to trying the sandwiches and other menu items in the future too.“

“Family owned and operated... they always provide great tasting food and always trying out new things and that always taste great. I try to go at least once or twice a week.“

“If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! Rhino’s Pizza is hands down the best pizza place in town. Every time we order, the food is fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious. Their classic pepperoni pizza is unbeatable. The crust is perfectly crispy, the cheese is just the right amount, and the pepperoni has that amazing flavor you cannot find anywhere else. But the real showstopper is their pickle pizza. At first, I was not sure what to expect, but it has quickly become a family favorite. The balance of tangy pickles, creamy sauce, and melted cheese is pure perfection. It is unique, memorable, and worth the trip on its own.

The quality here is consistently excellent, and you can tell Rhino’s puts real care into what they serve. Portion sizes are generous, toppings are always fresh, and the crust has that perfect texture, chewy on the inside with just the right crunch on the outside. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and service is quick whether you are dining in or taking out.

We have tried plenty of pizza places in the area, but Rhino’s stands out every single time. If you are looking for the best pizza in town, look no further. Rhino’s is our go-to spot, and once you try it, I bet it will be yours too!“

“Their pizza is amazing!! Perfect crust and not greasy at all!!!“

“This is my staple place to grab a couple slices for lunch where they give you a good amount of toppings and the flavor is on point. I usually get the War Eagle which means 1 slice of pepperoni & banana peppers plus 1 slice of buffalo chicken for those in the know. This location can get very busy and there's really only outdoor seating, but the workers are always very efficient and get your order knocked out quickly.“

“Very pleasant prompt service, quick delivery of a “build your own” pizza, piping hot, lovely thin and crisp crust. Pandora soft rock radio playing while we dined. Highly recommend!

Parking: Right near door, at least 12 spots

Kid-friendliness: Family friendly space

Wheelchair accessibility: Bathrooms are both wheelchair accessible“

“BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE ***** !!! Dave's the best“

“I had driven by this pizza place for many years and not tried it. I read the reviews and my bestie was in town and we decided to try the pizza and wings. It was the best on both accounts. It is very old school. Got to meet Nino and chat with him how he got in the business. Both the atmosphere of caring about the food he makes and the people he served is revealed in an excellent product. I would highly recommend!!!“

“Best wood fired pizza in Rochester. All fresh ingredients artfully prepared by Freddie himself. It is a must try, you will be hooked. I know I am!! Definitely five ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I love Pudgie’s pizza and especially their chicken wings….cooked so nice and crunchy….the customer service was great and it’s nice to dine inside again❤️“

“Delicious food with reasonable prices, friendly and knowledgeable staff, beautiful interior design!“

“Don’t listen to the people talking about wrong coupons or getting the wrong order, because that’s normal for small business. Honest mistakes are normal in this world. The bottom line is the food here is good and the people are great; support your small businesses!!!“

“My order of a sheet pizza and several sides was perfect for a family gathering of 11 discriming souls who fell in love with Rhino's. I decided to let them workout who got the few leftover slices.
Tasty, delicious, out of this world, best I ever had ...were just a few of the accolades I heard. Special words of praise fell on the Vegie half of the sheet.
I had to promise to bring a Rhino's Vegie pizza with me on my next out of town return visit. Well done !“

“By far the best pizza in Rochester! My , “go to” place. If you love thin slice , you will love this place ! Owners are always present and take pride in their pie ! More than reasonably priced, can’t say enough good things about this place!“

“Erin is outstanding! She made our Blaze experience amazing. Thank you Erin G.reat service. Great food“

“Beyond impressed! This pizza was the only pizza my family would order when I was a kid. We moved to Florida and over the years people have started away from them and we were always disappointed. We tried it twice and we're so impressed I had to review! Wings are cooked to perfection and the pizza is on point! ESPECIALLY the GLUTEN FREE!!! It actually looks, feels and chews like a pizza, not just a glorified tortilla. We will always order from Marks when we come to visit!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

“Love them hot fresh food food, special's, conveniently located. They often have specials like six wings and a slice with with with a drink for like 8 bucks different different specials but they're always good and even at the end of the night when they started doing like a lot of people do this this responsible for the food they are you know sell it to the public for a cheaper price you know what I'm saying just to get it out of the store you know what I'm saying so that people can eat the ones who are less fortunate .“

“it’s called the goner… so light and airy!“

“You are an absolute class act! You have donated pizzas all over the community, but just today, I learned you will be donating pizza to our children at St. Kateri for their last Field day of the school's existence! Typically the children would be given hot dogs, watermelon, and freeze pops, but we were told this year there was no money to do so...as many already know, the school is closing down for good (as St. Kateri that is). It will become Chesterton Academy, and our loving school community is officially disbanded at the end of this school year, all needing to find new homes...children and teachers alike! When we learned that yet one more tradition was coming to an end, you swooped in and came through for our children. Just received an email that you will be providing pizza for our kids on their Field Day this Wednesday. THANK YOU!!!!!! We are barely holding it together as we watch our children enjoy their school for the last time these next 6 school days, and this is at least one bright spot we can be thankful for in such a sorrowful time!!!“

“First time there. wonderful place. the food was delicious. I would go there again. highly recommend“

“You are our new #1 go to now for pizza and more! Thanks for such an amazing experience. Staff ROCKS! Hot and fresh delivery!! Saved to my phone contacts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Ordered a bbq chicken bacon pizza and a cheese pizza with wings have to say it was pretty amazing the service was great had it delivered to the hotel we’re staying at the gentleman who delivered was very pleasant the service when calling was great the prices are reasonable over all great place to order from will be ordering again when we have a stay in Rochester“

“Great food, inventive pizza. Casual and friendly“