15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Plattsburgh

“Fabulous Customer Service. Called from PA to have a sympathy meal delivered. Everything was perfect. They were very helpful even called back to verify everything was correct before delivery. Our grieving friends said the meal was terrific. Thank you Giuseppe’s for helping us express our condolences from far away.“

“Had my doubts about best pizza in Plattsburgh but after this veggie specialty pizza, hands down the best in town. Cooked & made to perfection, he definitely knows how to make & cook a true New York style pie. Will be our Friday special treat for the foreseeable future.“

“I always enjoy some slices of pizza from Zachary's and some of their awesome wings. I miss the old lunch specials like the grinders, my coworkers and I used to always be there for lunch! They did bring back the 1/2 off medium which is an amazing deal in this day and age with the costs what they are, and I think they have $.75 wings on Wednesday.“

“went to Big Sal's for the first time today. it will definitely be added as a favorite place to eat can't wait to go back. the food was amazing and the service was great. serving sizes were huge. you can easily feed 2 or more people from one order. only disappointment was they ran out of eggplant. will be my go to order next time.“

“Love the stuffed crust and garlic Parm boneless wings. I have been going here for years. Decor needs to be updated. Looks like the late 80s early 90s and always has. Had a large stuff crust pizza half was meR lovers and the other half was supreme. HD bacon cheese bread sticks and garlic Parm boneless chicken wings. ll very yummy in my wife And I tummy.“

“we ordered delivery on 12/3 waited three hours to be told the food was delivered elsewhere due to driver error..no big deal. Although this was very frustrating I feel that this has been resolved. After speaking to the manager, she was very professional and extremely apologetic, we were offered a credit to use on our next order with them. Thank you it was a pleasure speaking with you Jodi!“

“My pregnant wife was craving a Hawaiian pizza with bananas today. showed up about 10 minutes after they opened, banana in hand, and asked them if they'd indulge her. Not only did they agree to this, they had enough forethought to bury the bananas under the cheese to prevent them from burning. The wife was thrilled, the pizza was incredible, and the staff was genuinely happy that the pizza was a success. Thanks, guys!“

“Great pizza and wings. The best blue cheese dressing in Plattsburgh delivery guy was very friendly so was the young lady took my order. Definitely going to order again.“

“Best pizza around and at only $11 for a large !!! Will def be back !!“

“we had an issue with a pizza not being made properly ( It was supposed to be pepperoni on half and veggies on the other and they put everything on one half) And the manager Kristen took care of everything for us with minimum headaches. definitely recommend!“

“In a busy post-eclipse Plattsburgh, I would have settled for anything and been glad to have it. We saw "Italian" and some empty parking spaces and the decision was made. What we got was friendly attentive service, absolutely terrific food freshly made to order, and very attractive prices. If you are looking for casual dining and wonderful food, you cannot do better. Our meal and our time there was great. Thank you!“

“I have been to Mickey's several times for a quick lunch or to grab a drink with a friend, staff is always friendly and helpful. Finally made it here for dinner and it was above and beyond expectations, carbonera was perfectly done and delicious, staff was attentive as always. Only negative about Mickeys is the train tracks right next door, but it is such a minor issue it shouldn't even be taken into account!“

“We've been bowling at northbowl since my son was 4, starting on bumper league for kids. The staff and owners run a lot of specials and do a lot for the kids.“

“We order a large pepperoni pizza on DoorDash and holy smokes was it ever delicious! Will definitely order from here again!“

“We’ve had pizza from here for years- usually pretty decent. Ordered 2 large pizzas on Sunday for take out and the quality has significantly deteriorated from pizza in the past. Maybe more training for new workers? Maybe they don’t care as much?“