38 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rosendale

“Perfectly good pizza. My local pizza place. They sometimes send out mailers with coupons to make it more affordable. I am a little spooked that Google just asked me for this review because they noticed I call this place one week ago! I guess I will store the number and dial rather than hit the number provided in a Google search, now that I know they are capturing that particular bit of info. Hello big brother!!!“

“I grew up in NYC and during my teenage years in the 60's discovered middle eastern cuisine. It was the choice for "fast & delicious meals" Now my discovery in Rosendale has presented me the delicious opportunity to learn the exceptional cuisine offered at The Garden House. everything I've eaten is mouth watering wonderful. The community of welcomeness is abundant each time you visit. Enjoy a 5 star meal.“

“I love this restaurant, it’s definitely one of my all time favorites. It has amazing flatbread pizza with all the gourmet toppings you can think AND they have a few dinner specials that are absolutely delicious. Lastly, everything is fresh, tasty and not overly priced. If you haven’t been here you are missing out.“

“makes you feel at home.. great pizza !!!“

“We are from California and got in late and hungry. Ordered a marghertti pizza, Hawaiian regular and gluten free. Everything was delicious. They kept doors open after they closed to fix a pizza order for us. Great customer service.
Everything was so good we ate there again the last night of our vacation.“

“I go to Rino's for the amazing customer service - I go back to Rino's for the delicious food. While you're waitingon the0tk0p, check out the little Italian grocery section full of imported oils and vinegar and traditional ils school pasta shapes like orecchiette.“

“Expensive but good food….“

“Delicious food, friendly staff and atmosphere. Highly recommended“

“Beautiful grounds, food and wine were amazing. Highly recommend, best of all, the staff were all super nice. Can’t wait to go back.“

“I had their pizza once, after being unimpressed with one of their competitors -- and now I'm a Mario's fan for life. Pizzas are generously sized, prepared with an abundance of toppings, and reasonably priced. The pizza is so good, I haven't explored the menu much. But they also sell ricotta cheesecake a delicately flavorful, mildly sweet, lighter-textured cheesecake. Genuinely Italian.“

“Amazing hosts and great food.“

“alway good food friendly staff and good service“

“Great food and a very friendly staff. Good selection of food and drinks. Great draft beer and generous portions of food.Prices are very reasonable also.“

“the food is great there i tried some of the baked ziti and the wings and my family ordered from there half a tray of seafood too of everything it was to die for even thou i cant eat shrimp and lobster“

“Cool atmosphere, good coffee and really tasty sandwiches!“

“Ollie’s Slice Shop is a gem! Their pizza slices are delicious, with a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere make it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. Highly recommend stopping by for a slice or two!“

“I took my parents out to the Hudson River Walkway and reached the Historic Hamlet. We got a little hungry and found this very cozy place. The food was awesome for like half of what you’d pay in NYC, and all folks there were super nice. Ate too much but we walked back lol.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. When we were there, there was a table of teenagers eating. Then the owner’s own (I think) grand children came in lol.“

“I have celiacs disease so I asked if they had a gf pizza, they were so helpful and the pizza was AMAZING!!!

Kid-friendliness: super nice and friendly towards everyone

Dietary restrictions: They were very careful about not cross contaminating my gluten free pizza!“

“We had the buffalo chicken pizza, ham and pepperoni roll, and the ravioli dinner (yum, with mozzarella cheese and sauce on top). All were excellent. We did a pick-up order, and noticed when we got home that the salad was missing that went with the ravioli dinner. We called, and what seemed like only moments after I put down the phone, the doorbell rang with the salad and bread and apologies delivered -- great service!“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“If I could rate food 10 stars I would. The soups, service, and especially the grilled salmon with vegetables were all 🤩. The atmosphere was average, this isn't a super fancy restaurant so it was expected. The menu was massive with pasta, pizza, veal, steak, seafood, heroes, salads, soups, an assortment of appetizers, an impressive kids menu, and all the other stuff a fancy Italian place would have. I also thought the price was decent for your average meal but the food was so good they could have changed more and still got me to come back.

Vegetarian options: There were plenty of vegetarian dishes but half the menu was neat based.

Kid-friendliness: Faint kids menu, pizza pasta and they can get you vegetables on the side.

Wheelchair accessibility: Everything was wheelchair accessible.“

“Great pizza,awsome salads and wings !! And great prices,stop by and support them,you won't be sorry 🍕“

“Regular at Pizza Mia, my favorite slot for a slice on a lunch break in Newburgh. Location is convenient and near places to shop. The creative slices are filling, tasty, and the people here care about their end product. Their service is always above and beyond. 100% recommend stopping in and trying a unique slice that catches your eye. You won’t be disappointed!“

“El mejor lugar para comer😍“

“The Meatball and Sausage and Peppers heroes are delicious, stop by 2-3x a week. Their pizza is also the best in town in my opinion. Some other places are pretty debatable for the best spot, but it is all preference, can’t go wrong with some of the pizza places in New Paltz.Overall, pretty good.“

“My wife and I moved from New Paltz to High Falls recently, and this is the best pizza in the area. Where other pizzas lack toppings and are either over or undercooked consistently, Benny’s is always cooked perfectly with delicious dough, crust and plenty of toppings. Their dough is actually the best I’ve ever had anywhere! There’s no reason to go anywhere but here to get delicious pizza and wings (that’s all we’ve tried so far) - and I’m sure their other food is just as great. We usually cook at home and refrain from ordering out much, but we treat ourselves to a pizza from here more often than we should!

Aside from their food being high quality and delicious, this is the kind of business that you want to see where you live. My wife and I work on weekends, and after work yesterday I needed something from the grocery store, Turns out EVERYTHING is closed by 6 on Sunday. As a small business owner myself, I completely understand that people need time in their lives, but with food and groceries we need some options! I desperately went into Benny’s in search of an ingredient as my last hope, and by a miracle I left with exactly what I needed at better quality than I would have found at the grocery store. I assume it was Benny himself who generously helped me out, but either way, this is what small businesses should be. Wonderful at what they do and also holding the local community together in all kinds of unexpected ways! So happy to have them as my local pizzeria, and so happy to support people who care about their community.“

“End Cut has been our spot for special occasion dinners here and there, but tonight was a little different. On 1/26 I called to make a reservation for tonight, and to no surprise, I could not for the life of me remember if I made it for 7 or 7:30. So Michael called yesterday and unfortunately our reservation wasn’t on the books. They were completely booked but squeezed us in for 5:30. We had one of the best meals in awhile - mushroom cakes, a porterhouse for two with mashed potatoes and Mac and cheese, key lime pie and two drinks each. The porterhouse for two was $115 alone.. and I have zero clue what the whole bill was because Chef Jordan took care of our e n t i r e bill. We declined many times but they insisted, so the next best thing I can think of is to recommend the heck out of a place that not only cares about their customer’s experience, but does everything 11/10 from drinks to dessert. Thanks again Chef! We will be back much sooner than just a special occasion 🤝🏼 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I'm an RN, and work for the on call team at Hudson Valley Hospice. I cover Ulster County, and some evenings are very busy. On busy evenings, I only have time to stop for a bite to eat. Whenever I'm visiting patients in the Kingston area, I stop at (and look forward to) Picnic Pizza for a few slices. Nice people, and the best pizza around!“

“Maria and her team are fantastic - amazing - wonderful. She is a consummate professional, easy to communicate with, and provides the most delicious, satisfying food and impeccable service. She helped pull together a custom dinner for 80+ starving rock climbers without skipping a beat. She predicted our hungry behavior better than I could!! Everyone raved about the food (pasta, salad, main dishes, gluten free pasta, cookies = delish!), and we can't wait to come back to New Paltz and work with her again in the future. THANK YOU AGAIN, MARIA! YOU ARE A ROCKSTAR!“

“The food is always fresh, consistent and large portions. The owner and staff are super friendly. Tony will make you anything you ask for. A must try.“

“I have to go back another couple of three times at least until I can get to taste it all. Mid-week and it was packed. A bit too loud for conversation but I don't talk with my mouth full of fabulous fresh made gluten free pizza, thick chewy crunchy crust ( not the frozen one every other place uses) whipped ricotta cheese and fresh basil. The house well is stocked with good choices. One note is that because of the crowds frozen cocktails are pre-made so you can't pick your rum.

Dietary restrictions: Top choice for an artisan gluten free pizza ?“

“Wonderful tender tasty pizza crust with perfect amount of cheese and sauce on the pizza. Guys behind the counter are really nice. Small spot to sit in can get clogged with kids from school across the street, but relatively manageable. I love their mushroom pizza because they use canned mushrooms (I know, not a popular choice but it's what I like). I bought a pie to bring home with me when I left Kingston this weekend... It's that good.“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“I used to look forward to eating there. But the last two times I had the worst servers. One never came back to check after she dropped off my food. I had wanted a soda refill and another napkin, had to find her to get my check. Last night I came in and was told the kitchen was about to close so I needed to hurry up (I just sat down at about 9:25 pm). I ordered right away. An ice water and a coke and a meatball parm sub. I was lucky to get my soda with her attitude. No ice water was brought or acknowledged at all. I took a few bites of my food and she asked if I wanted a box. I was really irritated. If they told me to go only I would have been fine. But the way I was handled made me angry. I ate quickly and left. If I choose to get something again , it will be to go. Honestly, Caitlyn is the best server there. She is five stars. The others are not worth a dime.“

“Popped in after hair cut. Vinnie and Jeff were friendly, worked well together, got my order quickly, and enjoyed the delightful banter. Clean, well maintained, I’ll be back!“

“I have eaten there a few times and the food is always very good .“

“Ordered a large tray of Chicken Francese and it was AMAZING. Flavorful and tender even after reheating. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“