Bagels Restaurants near Rye, NY

“Its like neighbors hood bagle shop. Bagle is amazing it’s very chew and fresh. Bagel ? It's so delicious, I passed out. I could just eat it, but the bacon is overpriced ? ? ? It's over $9, but it's still a pity. You can taste a proper bagel. I guess the rent in Rai is expensive ?. The atmosphere of the store is comfortable, like an uncle or aunt’s store.“

“Never been to explore Rye. Glad I had an hour to myself to do so. Wondered and found this place. I'm pretty sure I was just following my nose. Got me an everything bagel and cream cheese. Simple, but done right. Toasted with the perfect amount of spread and the bagel taster fresh, even at close to noon.“

“Mamaroneck location: the best bagel in the Westchester Sound Shore area since H&R closed in New Rochelle a couple of years ago - sorry New Ro, Eastchester, Larchmont, and Ryebrook, Brooklyn bagels in Mamaroneck makes a better bagel, their service is AA++, great location, and great atmosphere.“

“I really liked PopUp Bagels! I will say it wasn't what I was completely expecting so just know before you go that if you want butter or cream cheese or any of those add on's you have to buy their tiny tubs of them so I opted to only get one. They are incredibly fresh, you just go to the side window and they give them to you fresh out of the oven. The bagels were great!“

“This neighborhood deli is packed with character and options. I ordered a classic lox and scallion cream cheese—fresh, briny, and generously portioned. The scallion cream cheese had the perfect tang and herbal kick, complementing the lox beautifully. I also grabbed a cup of their Oreo pudding—rich, sweet, and creamy without being overly heavy. A nostalgic treat done right.

Service was friendly and warm—the staff took time to introduce different menu items and made the experience feel personal. Between the massive chalkboard menus, fresh baked goods, and deli staples, there’s clearly something for everyone.“

“It’s a little corner bagel shop and this was superb at many directions.
I had just a quick breakfast and mine was a bagel with CC and another one with butter.
One for later obviously but with a coffee add up only to $8.
Bagels were how old school type was crispy and chewy.
Just a regular cup of coffee tasted so good much better than trendy chais like Starbucks.
Totally satisfied with the food and drink and services by the guys.
Maybe the owner.“

“Beyond good. The best bagels in and around NYC or amongst the top 5. Tight parking sometimes. However food and friendly hardworking staff make up for it. They’ve spread to many more locations in lower Westchester. Been coming to these shops for so many years I’ve lost count. Nothing compares.“

“good morning I'm visiting for the long weekend your business and bagels came highly recomended.from dear friends I am visiting took home 4 dozen for coworkers friends and loved ones now that I have your FB page I will be back to purchase more of your delicious bagels once you taste a Scarsdale.bagel all others are just bagels thank you for what you do you do it very well blessings to you and yours“

“Cash only. They seriously need to change it and not add 3% to do so. With so many loyal customers, you’d think they could make it easier to frequent.
Bagels are delicious. Warm with a beautiful sheen on the crisp crust of the bagel. Wonderful Rye!
The staff is a mixed bag. Often polite, sometimes looking like they wished you didn’t want it toasted 😥
Manager is always friendly. Not much atmosphere, because it’s a grab ‘n go, but you really see the community in their customers.“

“We were on our way home from NYC and had had real NY bagels during our stay. Our traveling companions wanted to get some bagels to take home so we stopped here. These are not NY bagels. Remember to get your bagels before you leave the city.“

“Bagels by Sophia recently changed ownership. I’m a regular and I like these new folks and more importantly the bagels!“

“Casual, with just a few tables—simple, but Onorio, the gentleman at the counter, takes your Sunday breakfast to the next level. The bagels are delicious, and his personal touch makes you feel welcome and at home. This place is a must-visit.“

“Super nice staff. Great NY bagels! Willing to cook me anything my mind makes up! Great baked goods, cozy, friendly, great coffee.“

“Favorite bagel spot 😁 I don’t think there’s any place better.“

“The bagels at Bagels and More are so incredibly good. Being from Florida, we can't get bagels like the ones served at this establishment, so these were a real treat! The atmosphere was casual and welcoming and the service was great as well!“

“We had an amazing experience trying the bagels here. They were fresh, soft on the inside, and perfectly toasted on the outside, giving them that ideal texture you want in a really good bagel. You can tell they’re made with quality ingredients because the flavor was rich and satisfying in every bite.

There was a great variety of options, and each one we tried tasted delicious and well-prepared. The toppings and spreads were generous and paired perfectly with the bagels, making the whole meal even better.

The atmosphere was comfortable and welcoming, which made the experience even more enjoyable. Overall, these were some of the best bagels we’ve had — fresh, flavorful, and definitely worth coming back for.“

“Good bagel shop here. $9 for a BEC which is pretty standard. Friendly staff and a clean establishment. The bagels are very fluffy, it’s almost like eating a loaf of bread which is a bit too fluffy for me. Full menu of sandwiches and different spreads and meats available.“

“On a stop over in New York, we decided to go find a good bagel place. We are so happy we came upon the Traditional Bagel Café. Staff was friendly, the bagels were delicious, and the food was made to order very quickly. The reason you gave the atmosphere of four is because it was cold in there because their front is all windows and in the middle of the winter it’s hard to keep in insulated. Otherwise it’s an easy place to stop and shop! I would come back again.“

“Stellar bagels. Hot, fresh and always delicious. Once I discovered this place I can’t stop going. The staff is always friendly and no matter what I order they always get it just right. I’ve been on the island for about 5 years now and am happy to have finally discovered a bagel spot where the price and quality meet hand in hand.“

“I just wanna say.I have the best experience every time I go there and it's the best cappuccino that I would ever have.There's one person who who serves me the best cappuccino? I also want to say the staff.There are also very caring and attentive. My best regards to everyone have a nice day❤“

“Donut Delight is hands down one of my favorite coffee spots! Every single time I walk in, the staff greets me with genuine smiles and such positive energy.

The coffee is always fresh, flavorful, and made exactly how I like it. Their donuts are consistently soft and delicious, and there’s always a great variety to choose from.

The shop is clean, welcoming, and has that cozy neighborhood feel that keeps you coming back. It’s the kind of place where you feel remembered and appreciated.

Side note regarding a recent negative review: If it’s the situation I witnessed, the staff handled it calmly and professionally. They were genuinely trying to help. Speaking respectfully to people who are assisting you goes a long way. From what I saw, the team remained kind and patient throughout.“

“Great spot to kill time and meet up with friends. Open, airy ambience, sophisticated and simple decor. Great coffee, great cakes, great empanadas.“

“I live in Austin, TX, and I love how I can have authentic New York bagels delivered to my front door. I am a new customer, and I love Just Bagels. I love their customer service, they answer their phone, and they answer my questions on Facebook. I will be using them again, and again. I love everything about them so far. My boyfriend is the bagel eater, and I ordered 2 dozen for him. The flavors we got were Everything, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, and Blueberry. He is in love with their blueberry bagels. Those are his favorite, but he loves them all. Thanks Just Babels for the wonderful bagels. We’ll be trying new flavors next time, but for sure blueberry again. :)“

“I love coming to this location! The food, coffee, service, and consistency are always amazing. Liz consistently makes the best coffee, and we truly appreciate the kindness, care, and effort she puts into every visit. Her friendly attitude and excellent service keep us coming back. Highly recommend!“

“OMG!!! You will not regret this Donut Delight!!! It was the very 1st one I tried and I never regret coming to this location!!! I really enjoyed every fresh donut & sandwiches purchased!!! And the best of all are the Lattés!!! The hazelnut is my favorite with whipped cream!!! The prices are perfect!!!! Starbucks just got dumped!!! I found myself a wonderful new hanging out spot!!!“

“Best bagels in Port Washington NY 11050
A huge shout out to Maria who runs the place. She’s there @ 4:30 every morning & opens the doors @ 5:30, takes large orders, always goes above & beyond w a smile. She is worthy of a big tip!“

“Long Island Bagel Cafe went above and beyond with the catering order that I placed for my sister’s morning of wedding breakfast spread. I had been recommended this place from my cousin after having some difficulty finding a local Bronx shop that would cater to the different breakfast items I was looking for. Frank was able to get my friends and family everything we needed for our morning breakfast and it was such a seamless process. Thank you so much!“

“Empire Bagel was really delicious — fresh bagels and a great variety of fillings. The quality of the food and presentation were both excellent.

Big shoutout to Kevin — he did a great job, super friendly and fast. 👍“