Sports Bar · $
1 Sayville Athletic Club
209 Railroad Ave, Sayville
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- All-Star Brisket Sandwich
- Pulled Pork Sandwich
- The Classic
“A true local sports bar with small-town vibes, cold beers, and TVs always tuned to the game — but don’t let the no-frills atmosphere fool you. This might be the best pub food on Long Island, and that’s a hill worth dying on. The brisket sandwich is smoky and stacked, the Philly cheesesteak hits all the greasy, glorious notes you want… but let’s be clear: the pastrami sandwich is the main event. It’s piled high, ridiculously flavorful, and good enough to make you forget whatever team you’re rooting for is probably losing. Come hungry, leave happy, and don’t expect anything fancy — just great food, strong local energy, and zero pretension. This is the kind of place that turns first-timers into regulars.”