Shelter Island Seafood
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$$ •
87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(516) 659-4148
Shelter Island Seafood Reviews
Freshest swordfish, tuna, salmon, etc., to grill at home, plus beautifully prepared takeout — perfect lobster rolls, oyster po’boys, fish ‘n chips, etc., as well as newer choices like tasty scallop sliders. I love to pick up a couple of the grab-and-go shrimp cocktail trays when we’re having guests — a dozen perfectly cooked large shrimp and homemade cocktail sauce in each tray. Move it onto a platter and done! Owners are so friendly and really know what they’re doing.
Stopped here after hiking and are we glad we did. We met Ted who recommended the fish tacos and the scallop sliders, both of which were excellent! Great food, nice people and reasonable prices are a winning combination!! We'll be back...
Ratings
Menu
People in Shelter Island Also Viewed
Husband and wife owners bring a true fish monger feel to the island with high quality fish and shellfish. SIS is our go-to whenever we want delicious seafood for ourselves or when we're entertaining. High recommend.