30 Best American Restaurants near Sherrill

“Great find, I love it when the reviews point you in the right direction.

Big portions, cooked properly, attentive staff, excellent prices.

Highly recommend!

The garbage omlete (pretty much everything) was one of the best I've had in a long while!“

“Had Chicken bacon ranch pizza, wings and chicken Alfredo carbonara. Everything was absolutely delicious. Well done!“

“Absolutely the best burgers around. Flavor and attention to detail is perfect. Everything we have tried has been above expectations. Highly recommend!“

“Colby is the best. Todd the restaurant manager is second to none.“

“We had a party of 12 and were very happy how accomodating they were for us on a very busy morning. The food was excellent. The waitress was fun and she'll certainly remember us...and my "brown gravy" for my pancakes.... We highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Amazing dinner. The staff were very efficient, accommodating, and very nice. Met the owner too. Highly recommend Sugar Beets .“

“The staff ! Amazing sonja, caroline and Bethany- Just so fantastic The burgers!!! Almost as amazing as the staff 💯“

“We went here for our Valentine’s Day dinner and we were not disappointed, per usual! I got the Seafood Carbonara and he got the Veal Marsala. So yummy! The owners are always so friendly as well as the staff. Food came out quickly for it being a busy night and it was hot. Can’t wait to go back again.“

“Came for brunch with my mom. Food and service were great. Sarah did a great job as usual!“

“Hosted a bridal shower there recently. Food was great and Megan was wonderful in the planning and day of event. Would absolutely recommend Lakeside!!“

“Went there for the first time today. My family and I really enjoyed it because not only was the food amazing but the atmosphere was inviting pleasant and clean. Not to mention our superb server Eliza. Who wasn't only friendly and polite but very knowledgeable worth every penny“

“I stopped after having a test at the hospital. I ordered the turkey dinner. It was the moistest turkey I have ever eaten. Big portions. Worth the drive!“

“The food was delicious. The filet mignon with Cajun seasoning was amazing and great!“

“My family and I went to The Franklin Hotel one night for dinner. We were in Rome, NY due to Capitolfest. Everything was delicious from the soft bread and butter to the gnocchi with basil cream sauce to the vanilla cannoli! The staff was very friendly. I would highly recommend The Franklin Hotel if you are in Rome, NY!“

“I miss the days of greasy spoons on weekends. This was a nice treat as I stopped by passing through town. The diner had a nice homey feel, and the food was good. I had a sausage, peppers, and onion omelet with Itlaian toast and coffee. Food was up in about 10 minutes. The waitress was kind and attentive.If I lived in town, that would be a place I would frequent most weekends.“

“Grilled chicken, Bellissimo !! As was all else we ordered Local grass fed burgers / Impressive Clean, very well run establishment appreciatively , on a cold rainy day. Can’t wait to come back and sit on outside deck Thank you from - a former sports bar owner in S FL“

“Wonderful job catering a party for us!“

“We had the Best Time and Delicious Night Out❤️Mary C was so knowledgeable about the Wine choices for Our tastings and Very Accommodating to Our Needs with Joy and Friendliness❤️We Loved the Elderberry Wine and the Wing Flight different flavor Options, Our Pizza was Amazing I've never had Shrimp on Pizza before so Yum❤️Perfect Date Night, We Will return❤️❤️❤️“

“Was not expecting a major culinary experience but was pleasantly surprised. We had the 8oz filet. Charred perfectly and perfect medium rare. The lamb entry was excellent. The sides had a upscale presentation and were good. Only disappointment was the shrimp appetizer. It was 4 small shrimp from the buffet that were peeled in a so so garlic sauce with rice. Was more a rice dish than shrimp. Would suggest removing from menu. The utica greens app was fine. The atmosphere is more in line to a typical breakfast venue. This is not a fancy restaurant but prices are reasonable. The waitress was responsive, again more like a wait staff in a diner, but no complaints. For gamblers one can bet on the horses.“

“One of my favorite place to eat the menu is awesome the food is delicious beautiful scenery of Oneida lake“

“This was our second time dining here. Previous was lunch during the summer so we sat outside. It was very nice and relaxing. Both my salad and my husband's lunch were very good. Same again last night our dinner was wonderful! Our waitress was very friendly and efficent, it was our anniversary and she offered to take pictures of us. I had the fish fry and sustituted the frenchh fries for sweet potato fries. The fish was enormous, I took half of it home. The maple aioli that was served with the sweet potato fries was a delicious and a perfect match. I also had the moscato-rita, be prepared when they say big, it is huge! Lol I am no slouch with drinks but I had to ask if I could get a go cup. Our server did not seem surprised and gladly drained the ice and I had a large go cup to take home with my meal for another day. My husband had the bang bang shrimp, loved it and he finished his meal happily! We will be back in the summer and dine outside again.“

“Hudson Valley was an amazing band! Great time with real Nashville music in the house“

“This is such a great place!! Every one that works there is fantastic,, along with the food and desserts!!!!! While staying at the beach we stopped in for dinner with friends and we were met with such a great staff. Kristie went out of her way to make our experience amazing,,, she did just that!!! The real story here is the owner who is the most pleasant, sincere person. 47 years of success proves she is devoted and loves what she does… the food is excellent!!! The desserts are fantastic!! We ended up eating there 3 of the 4 nights we were in town!!!
Jeannie, you are one in a million!!
We will be back in2 weeks for the chicken run,,, and you are our first,,, and last stop while we’re there!!5 stars for sure!!!
See you soon!!“

“We've been completely pleased with everything about this place since discovering it a year ago. It's been worth the 20+ minute drive every time. Really nice hostesses, and a surprisingly cute interior for such an out-of-the-way location.“

“We hosted the Rehearsal Dinner of our son and daughter-in-law’s wedding at The Mason Jar in April 2025. The atmosphere, decor, space and food offered us a relaxing and comfortable “night before” celebration! The staff was outstanding! So friendly and welcoming to our group. Joanne was so great to work with during planning and at the dinner. The bartender and wait staff were attentive and personable. Overall a great experience! Thank you!“

“2 visits to this bar and I have an OFFICIAL REVIEW!!!!!The first night I had a few beers with my buddy and some homemade wings. The sauces and wings themselves were made to perfection. Service was on point and definitely there when needed. The second visit I ate a burger and fries with a few more beers. GET THIS.... the bartender both times (thursday) did it all!!!! She's amazing!!!I've gotta recommend this bar because of service, football / ufc / soccer / baseball on the tvs at all times, nice dart boards, super clean and modern bathrooms, beautiful spacious outdoor enclosed patio that can seat probably 80 people including a band, very clean kitchen, outside appearance is clean as well, and the hospitality is 'Best In Class!!!'Go. Go tonight. Your gonna have a great time, great food, great conversation and meat great people. Enjoy and have fun!“

“Drinks are cheap and the people are very welcoming. The food is fantastic.“

“I Love Origlio"s food, everything is so good.“

“Great food, great service and atmosphere was good. Priced reasonable. Good waitress and hostess.“