50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sleepy Hollow

“We were traveling from VA to Maine and stopped by Sleepy Hollow. Went to Horseman Bagel’s (also Carvel ice cream) the next morning and loved them so much we stopped on our way back to VA from Maine. The bagels and cream cheeses are wonderful and the service is top notch! Very friendly husband and wife duo. I highly recommend! If you don’t stop, you are missing out! We will be back!“

“We love Frannie’s. The whole family is excited every time we take ourselves there for a treat.

The staff has always been attentive and kind.

The yogurt is delicious and the toppings are fresh with a great variety of options for both.“

“It’s an exciting and fun place.“

“The gelato, service, and atmosphere are excellent.“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“I was there for the first time a few weeks ago. Was so impressed! The vanilla soft serve actually had flavor. Most places I make them put a ton of toppings on just so it has some flavor. Also, the medium was so large my two nieces that normally want larges could barely finish it. So you definitely get your moneys worth. My only question is I want to bring a friend who’s allergic to eggs. I called the shop and they said they didn’t know if there was eggs in the ice cream (If it wasn’t for my friend, I would never know that many places like Carvel does use eggs to make it more creamier). So do you use eggs in your soft serve?“

“Friendly clean atmosphere. A great place to take our grandkids too“

“We are up from North Carolina this week and last night we were visiting our relatives who live in the Harbors. They took us to Riverside Scoops which was such a treat…Really great ice cream, lovely setting and wonderful customer service. My grandchildren loved their cones, my husband totally enjoyed his large cup with cinnamon bun and vanilla (which he couldn’t stop raving about) and I had the Smore Sundae…absolutely delicious!!! If you’re looking for a great place for ice cream on a summer evening, take a ride over to the Harbors and stop in at Riverside Scoops! You won’t be sorry 😊“

“I recently ordered (and ENJOYED) a custom ice cream cake for my wife's birthday, and I can say with great certainty, that was one of the best desserts I have ever eaten. Absolutely fresh and fantastic...thank you! 🥳🎂🎉“

“How could you NOT recommend The Blue Pig? 10/5 stars“

“Taste just like it use to ( as it should ) Never disappointed.. I always know what I’m getting myself into.. so consistent !!! 👍 👌 🙏“

“The ice-creams are delicious. They have many egg-free/vegan options as well. And the staff members are very friendly. My son dropped his ice-cream on the floor, but they refused to charge us even after us insisting.“

“Just picked up our ice cream 🍦 we love it. it is so amazing and delicious“

“Crumbl is a fun spot to visit if you're in the mood for an indulgent dessert. One of the best parts is the rotating weekly menu, which keeps things interesting since there's always a new lineup of flavors to try alongside their classic chocolate chip cookie. The cookies are served warm and have that signature thick, soft texture that Crumbl is known for.

I enjoyed trying different flavors, although I found most of them to be a little sweeter than I personally prefer. They're also very rich and filling, so sharing a cookie or saving half for later is usually the way to go. While they're definitely not an everyday treat, they're still enjoyable if you're craving something decadent.

The prices are reasonable considering the size of each cookie, especially since one can easily be split between two people. If you like trying creative dessert flavors and don't mind an extra sweet treat every now and then, Crumbl is worth checking out.“

“Deliciosos la variedad de tacos que tienes... !!! me encantaron!!!“

“After bike ride meal. Place is packed with bikers on good weather weekends though many just getting Powerade.“

“Great service and ice cream!“

“The ice cream is really good especially the ice cream nachos!!!“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“The flavors were excellent—especially the mango, which was fresh and vibrant. Each option we tried was delicious. The owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming, especially to our big group, which made the experience even better. Highly recommend!“

“The best around by far! Lots of flavors, but the simple swirl always hits the spot.“

“Best carvel ice cream shop 🍦 in the area. I was just there today. I have been going there since I was a kid. Ice cream is always good and fresh and they offer a big selection. The staff is always so nice and helpful too.“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“we LOVE this place!! the frozen yougart is delicious and not sour, Toppings can't be beat and the atmosphere is very child friendly.“

“the owner is always there. the place is spotless and it is the best tasting carvel around!“

“The best. I love the ice cream and the location is one of the most beautiful spots in Westchester.“

“Glacé 👍🏽 Milkshakes 😋 Hot Fudge Sundaes 🤗“

“Great neighborhood deli with fair prices and good food. Dianet and Sandro nail the classic breakfast sandwiches, and their house-made lemonade and iced teas are excellent. It's a nice, locally owned shop that gets the job done right. The bathrooms are also always sanitary and clean, which speaks volumes about how the entire place is operated. 5-stars all around. 👌“

“Wish you could order food from grub hub or DoorDash“

“Love going to this carvel! I come all the way from The Bronx to eat our favorite ice cream. Very clean and the staff is friendly. Highly recommend this Carvel.“

“They were SO nice in here. And I’m so happy we stopped in. The flavors are off the charts good and everything was fresh. It was late when we walked in and she still served us. I’ve been meaning to come check this place out. Definitely coming back here.“

“Held 2 birthday parties at home with Smallcakes. Each party was a hit. Tina, Lexi & Regina arrived on time with everyhing-- even folding tables, chairs + balloons. The kids colored their own frosting, used a piping bag and decorated with tons of toppings.
When the 6 year olds needed a break, their team cleaned up and turned everything over for lunch, they even included a custom birthday cake. Such a fun party, the adults enjoyed spending time with their kids while Smallcakes did all the work. 10/10!“

“Great, took little cousins and it was fun as well as delicious. Pricey but good“

“Great service!! Exceptional taste. Immaculate store.“

“Ice cream was very delicious and I plan to visit again“

“Great carvel location in pleasantville.
The store is clean and has some seating inside. The staff is very friendly and helpful !
The cases are well stocked with cakes and flying saucers and pre made sundaes.
We both had soft serve twist cones with rainbow sprinkles which were amazing.
Since I was a kid, carvel has been serving consistently great I've cream and they continue that tradition today.
If you are in the mood for ice cream stop by this cavel !“

“Try the sweet potato fries. The large can feed 3“

“Try their smoothies for the first time today. So yummy!! nice consistency and good flavor. Very fast service too“

“Baskin‑Robbins was a delight to visit. The ice cream was rich, fresh, and full of flavor, and the staff was friendly and quick to help. The shop felt clean and welcoming, making it easy to enjoy the treat. A great stop for anyone craving something sweet.“

“This Baskin Robbins is part of a Dunkin Donuts that I often visit. It is a bright and clean place that is always very busy. I often see people take out ice cream with smiles on their faces. It has a great seating area for both donuts or ice cream and space to sit outside. The bathroom is very clean. The help is very attentive and it seems to be a community place because I see a lot of the same spaces ball the time. It is located near a major college. Westchester Community College to be exact. Come give it a try any time and bring the kids if you have any.“

“Since moving to Eastchester 10709, October 2019, I used to go on Wednesday for buy one get one free sundaes. Yummy. The owner and his sister are awesome!! He has one young woman that works on certain days, she's very friendly and remembers me. Which is great for a neighborhood store. Whereas many neighborhood stores do not. He hires local students from Eastchester, which is great. This Carvel on Mill road is a great community store. I have purchased cakes; sundaes; cones and shakes. Never had a problem. B“

“I ordered a birthday cake for my son. The manager went above and beyond to make sure the cake was exactly what we wanted. Every experience I have had at the Quaker ridge carvel has been positive, and this experience was even beyond past experiences.“

“The salted caramel yogurt is amazing! and the owner Chris is a stand up guy! I especially love the outdoor play area for kids that way they can be entertained while you enjoy your delicious yogurt ��“

“Tonight... I chose to dream back to the 1970s when Baskin-Robbins were standalone ice cream parlors. This evening however in 2024, I was greeted by a terrific young fellow named Michael. I told him about my escapades with friends as kids in the 1970s with Baskin Robbins and I said would you make me the best banana split you've ever made anyone and his reply was, Sir, I most certainly will. On top of this perfectly ripened banana was Cold Brew Oreo, World's Famous Chocolate, and Jamaica Coffee ice creams. It was politely topped with chocolate syrup, butterscotch, wet nuts, a touch of whipped cream and three wonderful cherries. Not only was I reliving the 1970s but I was given a slice of heaven by a courteous young professional that made the experience worthwhile. The entire crew on tonight was stellar. So everyone, when you want great ice cream come to this location and you'll be treated like royalty.“

“Really interesting new operators. You can tell the shop is very clean and the overall quality of the products is handled professionally.

I’m looking forward to seeing this place fully up and running again. Wishing them the best!“

“Delicious 😋 varieties of different icee flavors“

“Obviously ice cream is ice cream but the guy is genuinly amazing. He works super fast and is completely generous with what he gives to you, he is a very hardworking person because every time I walk past this place all I see is him doing is cleaning or taking peoples orderes while the other guy sits there doing nothing.“

“So yummy! Cereal milkshakes are delicious! S’mores cookie was so good. Wish they stayed open a bit later but 11/10😍“