43 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sleepy Hollow

“Beautiful place and elegantly decorated. Their vegan chocolate peanut butter ice cream is to die for! I gave up ice cream for years cause I cant eat diary anymore and the vegan ice creams don’t taste well, but their ice cream is worth multiple trip!“

“Went here with my family. I don’t even know where to start first the owner and workers greeted us as soon as we stepped in the door. They gave us samples without even asking us hospitality is just top-tier. I’ve never been to a place like this before With such great customer service . Oh, and taste is incredibly great Prices are absolutely great. Like I said in the beginning, I don’t know where to start. This place is just amazing. You have to come here.“

“Daniela's ice cream is my absolute favorite, especially the Coffee Oreo and Peanut Butter Fudge! These are my top Scoops choices. They're not too sweet, made fresh, and you can taste the freshness in every spoon. The strawberry cheesecake is really good too, especially as a milkshake. The service is great too! Daniela's ice cream is my guilty pleasure ❤️? ❤️“

“Shoutout to the 2 young ladies behind the counter. A mass of people came to this shop after a comedy show at the Music Hall and they held it down! The Oreo Bomb & Lucky charm ice cream flavors were top notch! Looking forward to coming by as the weather gets warm. 10 out of 10!“

“Some of the best tacos I've had on the East coast. These are on par with California and Texas tacos. Most of the tacos in NYC and NY and terrible, but not Los Ferchos. This is a great family run deli, with the whole family helping to make super authentic tacos in the back. The staff is super friendly, and they even have a couple tables inside and outside for you to enjoy your food. They also make homemade ice pops and they have some very niche authentic Mexican food items too like Oaxaca cheese and Mexican desserts. Easily the best tacos in the Hudson Valley, and maybe NY too.“

“My hometown ice cream shop, amazing quality food and amazing workers. Everyone is very kind and the food is awesome. Even if you aren't in Piermont or from there, I highly recommend going to and trying out some of their ice cream and/or shakes. They both are equally amazing, they too are very quick with their work and it is ALL homemade ice cream and even their waffle cones (which are amazing too.) And yes the prices are a bit high, but that's because the ice cream is homemade.“

“The ice cream is awesome. I love going there because the people who work there are very nice. I finally got to meet Erin today. She and Pam are awesome.. it used to be a gas station then it was a flower shop and now a great ice cream place they even have outside seating. It's well lit, and I will keep supporting them..“

“We visit this family favorite ice cream shop every time we are in town! Love their death by chocolate, rum raisin, pistachio, toasted coconut, butter pecan, strawberry and cookie dough flavors! Haven’t tried the other flavors as we already love our picks and every time we go there we want to eat the same flavors! They have tons of flavors. Parking spots and also a nice area to sit and enjoy the ice creams!“

“I traveled 20 minutes to go to this place and I have mixed emotions, many people describe them as the best cookies but for me they are overpriced, they have good flavor and a reasonable size but not enough to pay a little more than $4 per unit. On this visit I bought a box with 6 units to try them all.“

“The few, the proud,.. Come on, folks! It's Carvel Ice Cream! This location has always been monumental in my life growing up and still today. It would get a biased 5 stars ? on that alone. The ice cream is second to none. Whether soft-serve, traditional, cake, or shake, it's great! Scoops or soft serve in your choice of cones or a bowl, floats, banana splits, a sleeve of flying saucers, and more are there for you to enjoy. They still make the ice cream cakes with the crunches, too. The service is pretty good, and they will allow you to customize your order with toppings, etc. Be mindful and patient of customer surges and the occasional understaffing.The dining space is limited to the two historic, small benches outside the building. Of course, you can sit in your car in the parking lot to indulge in a cool treat. This location in Elmsford is a great stop after shopping locally or passing through regardless of the weather or season. Ice cream is the reason!“

“Amazing staff/service. I loved the atmosphere, it is a fun place to go with some friends, a lot of options to choose from. There isn't even only ice cream! They have many goodies like sodas, candy, and various toppings that are very good! The store was kept very clean as I saw workers constantly keeping up on it. I recommend this to anyone looking for a sweet treat.“

“Delicious and healthy waffles! All sorts of toppings and add-ins are available for these sourdough type waffles, and they do not disappoint! The soup of the day today was beet soup. Delish! One of us had a waffle with chocolate as well, and one of us had frozen yogurt with toasted coconut. All so yummy! Great space, light and simple, great, friendly service! Go for a coffee, go for a meal or a snack! You will be glad you did!“

“Quick stop traveling through to Blaze. Parking on street residential area. Ice cream is excellent. Pumpkin cookie good. Service was fine. Small place limited space. Outside more tables. Two scoops of icecream and the cookie and tip $10. Worth it.“

“Can't beat a place that will make an egg sandwich all day. Grabbed a bacon, egg, and cheese and a muffin, both were very good. The muffin was fresh and not dry-always a concern and the BEC had a perfectly cooked egg. The woman at the counter was very pleasant and helpful. They have smoothies on the menu which not many places have available and they are reasonably priced. There are a few tables if you want to eat in the deli. Hopefully you can snag a spot in Main Street to try this at place out on your next trip into town.“

“My husband and I went there for the hot dogs. They are out of this world. Large size great taste. They are so good I ate mine with a little bit of mustard and nothing else. The fries are so good and compliment the hot dogs perfectly. Try not to miss the french fries if you are a fry lover like myself. You can see the food being cooked behind the counter which I personally like. The day we went there were 2 young ladies. One taking the orders and one cooking. They were so efficient and nice. We enjoyed our meal and definitely will go back again. ??“

“Great local ice cream place! Blows the bigger nearby chains like Carvel out of the water. I appreciate the fact it's a small business that hires local kids to make money for college. The prices are all fair and the ice cream/milk shakes are delicious!“

“DQ Old Tappan serves the best Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream, and their peanut butter milkshakes are simply divine. The ice cream is rich and creamy, offering a perfect balance of flavors, and the milkshakes are a peanut butter lover's dream. The service from the two young ladies were great. It was near closing so the place was clean and ready for lockdown. I recommend visiting this location for anyone craving late night cold treats.“

“Hands down, best ice cream in Westchester/Putnam Counties. All home made. Common favorites as well as innovative flavors. Friendly staff. Wonderful, community driven & supportive owners.Great flavors. My favorite is Coffee Kalua; it's so creamy and just the right amount of Kalua taste with bold, smooth coffee flavor. I will drive miles out of my way between family in Westchester to my home in Putnam, just to get a pint to take home and of course a scoop with hot fudge to sit at the tables on the side walk and enjoy. So dang, good! If you're an ice cream snob like me, you'll love it! Check them out.They also sell some old-fashioned candy in the inside shop and they make dessert Crepes. Faaaabulous!“

“Stumbled upon Hey Yogurt today while shopping around Ridgewood with the family. It's clean, had a spacious ambiance, and digital kiosks for easy ordering. We liked that each flavor is made with real fruit and no additives, offering a healthier, tastier alternative to traditional froyo. Even our 1-year-old was a fan. Had a great experience and liked that it caters to both health-conscious adults and little ones.“

“What a fun place for ice cream! Whether it be the 2 "Cowches " outside, the unmistakable paint job or the friendly (sorry for the choice of words) staff Ben & Jerry's in Mount Kisco is a winner. Both my grand daughters and I loved it.“

“Had one of our few yearly trips to Penny Lick today to treat our peanut allergic son. Ice cream was delicious as always. We got to sample a few flavors before deciding. The gentleman working the counter was amazing as always. He is such a delight and always chats with us. Knows all about the flavors available and helps with deciding what to get. We got to sit and enjoy chatting with him while eating our ice creams, and our son even get seconds after deciding he'd like to try a milkshake- something he doesn't get to do often due to his severe peanut allergy. We are so thankful for peanut free stores such as this, where our son can be comfortable and have a moment of normalcy. If we didn't like 1.5 hrs away, we would visit at least weekly. We normally bring a cooler with ice and ice packs to take pints home, but today we did not have that with us. Love their take home pints!! Will be back soon!! Thank you so much!!Dietary restrictions: Peanut free as well as other allergens.Kid-friendliness: Fun store with cool signs on the walls and in bathrooms. Lots of fun toppings for your treats!!“

“Yogybee in Northvale has become my new go-to spot for shakes and smoothies this spring and summer. The atmosphere was inviting, and the staff and the owner was very friendly and helpful. They offer a wide variety of frozen yogurt flavors and toppings, shakes, smoothies, and even wraps and salads! I tried the strawberry banana smoothie and my girlfriend got the “kill me with chocolate” shake (p.s. add Reese’s to the kill me with chocolate you won’t regret it). We were so focused on our drinks we even forgot to take pictures but now we have an excuse to come back again.The perfect choice for a beautiful day like today I’d give the spot 6/5 if I could!“

“I love this Carvel. We come from Montvale because we like it so much. Only disappointing thing happened when we ordered a cake for my daughter and birthday. The cake looked like a 10 year old decorated it. Very sparse with minimal crunchies when we ordered extra. The cake also looked smaller than it should have been. Very disappointing.“

“Delicious pizza! Cheesy, fresh and good crust. Love the different salads and wraps they offer too. Excellent fast service. Ordering on the Slice app makes ordering easy. Will definitely be a returning customer.Vegetarian options: Whole menu“

“Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery is a delightful spot for satisfying your sweet tooth cravings! I recently visited and was impressed by the variety of cupcake flavors available. While I initially planned to try their homemade ice cream, I was a bit put off by its appearance, as it was melting despite the moderate weather. However, the cupcakes more than made up for it! I indulged in the 420 deep-fried Oreo specialty cupcake and a classic red velvet, both of which were delicious. Although I found the cupcakes a tad less moist than I prefer, the frosting was just right - not overly sweet. The ambiance inside the bakery was cozy, and I noticed they host events, which adds to the appeal. Overall, Smallcakes offers a tasty treat experience, and I look forward to returning to explore more of their cupcake flavors and, hopefully, give their ice cream a try!“

“Nostalgic soft serve ice cream shop serving classic sundaes. They still have Wednesday buy one get one free sundaes. Takeout only, no indoor seating. A great place for grab and go dessert after a meal. There's always room for a Carvel sundae! <3“

“We got the gelato in chocolate & tiramisu flavors, mango smoothie, & chocolate-covered strawberries. All were fantastic! The gelato flavor & texture was perfect; the chocolate flavor had small dark chocolate chips mixed in. The smoothie was sweet without being too sweet. They use good quality ripe strawberries. Can’t recommend highly enough that everyone come out and support this great new small business.“

“This shop and it's employees have always been amazing!They take care of you in a timely manner even when it's swamped!!I've gotten so many cakes here for different holidays and events and I'm never disappointed Even if you have to drive a little farther, come here it's worth it!“

“Awesome spot!!! The best froyo around. Staff is so friendly and helpful. They let you try any flavor and are great at recommending different menu items based on what you like. Great outdoor seating area with a ton of parking and space for kids. The store is also SPOTLESS every time I go in you can tell this place is well taken care of. 10/10!!!!“

“Where do you go when your team wins their Sat game? For ICe Cream or Frozen Yougart!This cute shop was suggested to us by a teammate and the Frozen yougart was delicious. He had a cup of Cookies & cream and Coffee for mom. Service was fantastic and everything was explained from the menu to the self serve machines.“

“UPDATE 01/27/23: Looks like they finally got their act together. Clean and well stocked. Thanks!UPDATE 11/16/22: We just went because the website said they had sugar free strawberry. We went. Guess what? They haven’t updated the website in months, don’t plan to and they have no sugar free options.PLEASE SELL THIS LOCATION BACK TO THE ORIGINAL OWNERS. THEY HAD THE STORE RUNNING BEAUTIFUL. YOU GUYS ARE WRECKING IT.This place used to be incredible until they were sold to new owners that have very little idea how to run a 16 Handles. We just wasted a good 45 minutes running around picking people up, only to find out that there was no sugar-free yogurt which every 16 Handles has at least one of. There are certain standards that 16 Handles has in their franchise agreement and these guys are clueless. Please sell the store back to the old owners and restore the great frozen yogurt experience that used to be here. The one extra star is here because the one guy behind the counter is genuinely nice.“

“I visited a new franchise in New Rochelle and I saw the organization and well-maintained facility in the store. With the Pink Cup I ordered, I was satisfied with the Pistachio flavored ice cream with my favorite toppings. The lovely cashiers welcomed me to the store and made me feel valued in the place. The Pistachio was delicious, and the bubble toppings with the strawberry slices were both nutritious and delicious. With a few people lounging in the peaceful environment, I enjoyed my stay, catching up with my organization discussing our logo to be used in New York City.“

“Fell in love with their setup. Old school carvel vibes. Ice cream tasted like my childhood. Very clean. The employees were very friendly and had no problem letting my young son use their personal restroom. We'll definitely visit again soon.“

“Obviously ice cream is ice cream but the guy is genuinly amazing. He works super fast and is completely generous with what he gives to you, he is a very hardworking person because every time I walk past this place all I see is him doing is cleaning or taking peoples orderes while the other guy sits there doing nothing.“

“I love coming here it is always a great experience with great food and I come here with friends a lot. The burgers are so good and I like coming here every weekend.Parking: It is very easy and quickKid-friendliness: I feel like this is a great place to come with kids“

“Thank you so much for hosting such a great tea party for our little princess. The staff and Frank are amazing and went above and beyond to make sure our party was memorable. The girls had so much fun and everything was delicious .. we will definitely be back .. thank you ..�����“

“Cool and fun place! First time we tried a ice cream/ yogurt place. Lots and lots of choices and a large selection of toppings. The employees were very friendly, helpful and explained the process to us in a pleasant manner. Just a local hang out for the teenagers in the area, which is okay but does get rather loud.“

“Louie's Ice Cream in Blauvelt, New York is close to Tarrytown, and driving there at nighttime is trickier with meh lighting in a solidly residential area but Louie's delectable ice creams, full of the best quality ingredients, is worth the never smooth journey while driving there! I love their premium Black Raspberry Chip - always double scooped and preferably garnished with whipped cream, drizzled with assorted chocolate or caramel sauces, and dusted with rainbow sprinkles, and Bordeaux Cherry Sundae, ridiculously rich, velvety, creamy, and giving off classic nostalgic vibes, keeping things simple but always fresh. Louie's is more than ice cream, and they also have a marvelous and refreshing Pineapple Dole Whip- once only found at Disneyland and Walt Disney World, whipped frosty pineapple soft serve that is vegan, fat-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, fruity, and a tasty, tangy frozen treat that Dole Food Technologist Kathy Westphal, trailblazer for women in the food technology sector, created in California, just one year after she graduated from college in 1984.“

“I am actually confused by their low-carb pizzas. For years they were listed as 130 cal five net carbs then a change to 205 calories And now this morning it changed to 400 cal in 16 g of protein and 5 net carbs and they said that it’s 98% fat free. But if you do the math it doesn’t make sense it would mean that there’s 35 g of fat per pizza which is terrible. I would love to know the specific nutrients in these pizzas and unless I do I’m going to have to stop shopping there.“

“What a wonderful place to have brunch on the weekend or any time. Great food and drinks enjoy!It's also the site of many movies ? And commercials that were made there. You will see on t v Occasionally.Parking: The location is on 9W where it is. An old gas station turned into a restaurant. It's very cute.“

“Definitely excellent customer service, the delicious ice cream, the presentation and design that dedicate the maximum to the cake... I recommend this place the best... and not to mention the cleanliness, always taking care of the customers' health. ...highly recommended....“

“This is my go to spot for milk tea and frozen yogurt. i’ve been going here for the past 2 years and never had a problem with my drink. customer service is always amazing and it’s always clean. if i could remember the workers’ name , i would put them here. ??“

“Shoutout to Kayasia. Apologies if I spelt that wrong but she said you pronounce her name Kay-Asia. Not only did she cut up strawberries when they were out but she went above and beyond and recommended an absolutely scrumptious combination of froyo flavors and toppings. Amazing!“