50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sleepy Hollow

“Best pizza I've ever had in New York. Visited last October from West Virginia. We talk about how good the pizza was all the time. Wish we could get it shipped here lol. Will definitely be stopping in our next trip .Everyone was very kind as well...“

“Who’da thought a tavern would have terrific pizza and lots of great toppings and pizza options! We were pleasantly surprised after hiking to find this gem. Not to mention meeting a like minded couple at the bar and becoming friends!!! The salads, the prices and the portions along with back yard space, this is our new hotspot!“

“Tonight I dine like a king! Thanks to the good people over at Casaletto Pizza. I had placed an order online for pick up before 9pm. Unfortunately this evening, so much happened (car accident on the route I took for pick up. Then I caught a flat less than 2 miles away) 😂😩. hungry and feeling defeated I decided to call the restaurant to plead my case. Luckily the gentleman on the phone advised me “food is here waiting on you” and that he will stay until I arrive “no worries”. 9:15 I finally arrived. “Yes” I thought to myself as I climbed out my work truck excited to finally get my food. The gentleman greeted me with a smile and said “your orders right here waiting, and here, try one of these cookies.” What a gesture. This was my first time at this establishment, and it won’t be my last. Food and atmosphere are excellent! I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for the same experience.“

“Delicious!!“

“5 Stars - Highly recommend.“

“If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience, Chazz Palminteri is the place to be. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for an amazing meal.

The service is exceptional—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The staff goes above and beyond to make sure you feel welcome and well taken care of.

Now, let’s talk about the food. Every dish is crafted with precision and bursting with flavor. Whether you’re trying their signature entrée or a simple appetizer, the quality is undeniable. The ingredients taste fresh, and the presentation is flawless.

One of the standout dishes is the lobster ravioli—perfectly balanced , cooked to perfection, and served with a delicious side that complements it beautifully. And don’t even get me started on dessert—the cannolis are to die for.

Overall, Chazz Palminteri delivers a top-tier dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving a fantastic meal, this restaurant is well worth a visit. 10/10 would recommend!“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“Relaxed atmosphere with dog friendly outdoor seating!!!! Fresh ingredients are used and it shows. Great food and service!! What a wonderful find in this quaint town!!!! If you are in this town, this is a must stop!!!!!“

“Love Rocks Kitchen- good and healthy food! Smoothies are out of this world!!“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“

“Delicious Margarita pizza! All ingredients are fresh. We use to drive over the bridge to Cassis’s in Orangburg, NY for pizza, but no more. We met the owner yesterday and he really takes pride in his business. Venice Pizza is now our go to place when we want delicious pies.“

“We stopped here while traveling from RI to PA and WOW are we glad we did. We needed a place to accommodate our small pup so we stopped to ask if they had outdoor seating. They didn’t but they created it by carrying a table and chairs outside for us - talk about customer service! Nick was such a fantastic host - setting us up, providing exceptional service and great conversation! I also can’t forget to mention how incredible the pizza and chicken roll were! This place is a 10/10 and we will definitely find a reason to stop back again!“

“Yesterday 1st time had the ribs to die for .loved it all except the mac and cheese was a little to dry and wasnt a fan of the shell macaroni.but i did see a pizza pie go by and man it looks real good.im coming back my family and turn them on.“

“Excellent! Food was so fresh and fabulous and so was the service. Pizza crust was delicious and light. Everyone was so very nice and accommodating. Great atmosphere and concept of Pizza by the foot. So good that weekends are packed, so make a reservation or try a weeknight. You will not be disappointed!“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“I just started working in Orangeburg and I've tried a lot of local restaurants/pizzerias but this one is by far the best. I've ordered lunch so many times in the last two weeks I might need a VIP pass =P Grilled chicken cesar salad is my go to, delicious. Pizza, amazing. Atmosphere is very nostalgic, love it because of the traditional old school pizzeria decor. Service is wonderful - thank you!!“

“The grandma slice and the broccoli white are my go-to items, and this place makes rather good salads too.

Isaac is very friendly and the hours are as good as any in Hastings.

Overall, a rock solid place to grab a slice.“

“Excellent pizza. In my opinion, much better than any of the other places around. They use an actual brick oven, wood fired. Pizzas and sauce are well seasoned, fresh ingredients, excellent dough, similar to a wood fired you’d find in the city.“

“I went in today to get a slice of pizza. The food look very appealing so I actually ended up getting a slice of pizza and a Sicilian. I sat down to eat the slice. It was amazing grape flavor crust just the way I like it. The cheese had a good flavor as well. It was a good quality cheese, I recommend this to anybody. I’m from the Bronx and I’ve had a lot of good pizza and also have Brooklyn and Manhattan pizza spots and this definitely ranks up there with them. Staff was very friendly. They even brought the pizza to where I was standing at and I’ve never experienced that before .“

“A big thank you to Tim and Charly for their exceptional customer service! Your kindness, professionalism and attentiveness made the experience truly enjoyable. It's rare to meet people so dedicated to providing such a level of service. Thank you for everything!“

“Love Deanna’s! Great pizza and great people. They always help out out PTA and Girl Scout Troop parties with delicious, on time, discounted pies! Love a business that gives back to the community!“

“We had lunch there today, first visit and the pizza is really good. Our waitress Melony was the perfect waitress. We really enjoyed our meal and will be sure to make it back on a Friday when Melony is there.“

“This place has an amazing Detroit pizza!! So worth going there! I see seen some stupid reviews about workers touching pizza with their hands. Have you ever tried to kneed dough with gloves on. Ain’t happening !! Disregard that silly comment and go the this place! I found the Pizza Excellent !! The stars ⭐️speak for themselves !“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Never tried the tomato pie until here and fell in love with it.“

“awesome food,great portions and prices wonderful owners go there you wont regret it“

“Great pizza,great service friendly staff👍“

“The best“

“Randomly saw this truck parked on the side of the road and figured I’d stop by and give it a try. I really wasn’t expecting much considering it’s literally a truck on the side of the road randomly in the industrial part of Yonkers but I was absolutely blown away. I picked up a pizza on the way back to my job and when I opened it all of my coworkers were taken by how delicious it smelled. It tasted even better if that’s possible.The pizza is better than most of the pizza places around and crazy fair priced for the gourmet food quality. I’m really so shocked at how good this pizza is! It just doesn’t seem possible for pizza to be that good! Do not sleep on this pizza truck. If you see it, pull over and get yourself a pizza! 🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“We grew up in NY. We moved to Lancaster, Pennsylvania. We have never found pizza that we could eat here and enjoy. (I've had pizza at Frank Pepe's in CT- I'm spoiled.) We were visiting family in Mount Kisco and stopped in for a pie to take back home with us. Best decision EVER! Wood fired- crunchy crust that held up to our toppings- sausage and mushrooms. Pizza was tangy, good cheese cover, and the crust just snapped when eaten. You made us very happy and we will come back again when we are in the area. I only wish that I could transport a clone to our area. Thanks for the fine food and the memories. #5!!“

“It has become a staple in my household after having recently moved to the near by area. Every other weekend has become the "Familia Weekend" . Never a bad experience after a year of ordering/taking out, family and I usually have a variety of menu selections and their tomato sauce is untouchable. Match that to their service behind the counter and fair prices, they can't be beat.“

“Authentic Utica food. Feels like home...Delicious! Cant wait to try the rest of the menu!“

“Rocco’s has terrific food and a great atmosphere. To top it all off, service is wonderful and they do so much to help the community. I highly recommend this family run, delicious restaurant!“

“For over 25 years, I have frequented this establishment for both lunch and dinner. Recently, with the introduction of new owners Naomi and Cesar at Mezzaluna, I have experienced exceptional improvements in both the quality of food and service. Their dedication to excellence has significantly enhanced my dining experience, making it a pleasure to continue patronizing their establishment.“

“I was visiting a friend at Westchester Med. She was in the mood for pizza. I know nothing about restaurants up here. Google maps to the rescue. What a gem of a place! The food is fresh and the owner could not be friendlier! The only negative is that it's not on Long Island.“

“The ONLY time I can ever be bothered to write a review is when something is either really good or really bad. Now the food I ate tonight. PERFECT. I thought I’d found my “favorite pizzeria” until tonight. I decided to try something new so I ordered the Grandma Pie, Garlic Knots, and my boyfriend wanted Zeppoles. First off, seeing my pizza - and the small. Omg it looked so good! I loved how it didn’t flop, it was firm and had a very nice crust. Deep dish but not too doughy. The crushed tomato’s were incredible, the sauce, everything taste absolutely amazing. The garlic knots were great! Not overly oily like practically everywhere else… It all tasted fresh, especially the tomato’s. I usually don’t like tomato’s but wow. I’m in love. My boyfriend loved the his dessert as well. It was delivered quickly, ate quickly I had to write this. I can’t wait to try some of the other foods this restaurant has to offer! Thank you so much.“

“Excellent pizza, Excellent service, Excellent communication. Our lacrosse team traveled from LI to play a game, after placing my order that morning Joe called to confirm the details, the delivery was on time, the girls loved the pizza & garlic knots, thank you for making this an easy team dinner.“

“My family visited from New Mexico for vacation and decided to stop by a pizza place. We happened to locate Sinapi’s and I am glad we did. It’s the best pizza we have ever had. If we are ever in the area again we will definitely be back.“

“So glad our neighbors insisted we try this neighborhood staple! The Sicilian slice was wonderful! Though, I should have gotten a middle slice. 😆 My daughter loved the salad slice! Thanks for the friendly service! We'll see you soon!“

“Thank you to W&F for your amazing customer service. We ordered family style take out for my birthday last night. there was a small issue with the main course. After speaking with manager she not only was empathetic but addressed the issue quickly and effectively. Will happily order another wonderful meal again. Thank you!“

“Was a pleasant time. Getting to have NY pizza is so great because upstate pizza just doesn't hit the spot. So thank you. Love it. Loved the smell of the pizzeria. All staff were nice or quiet. Everyone works great together. Good work chemistry.“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“excelente atención! muy rica la comida! volveremos 😃“

“the entire staff is terrific“

“First met Danny & his family at their restaurant in Upper Nyack, Casa del Mare. It was our hometown favorite & sad when they closed. THEN we found him here, in Irvington! No place better for pizza, garlic knots & many other favorites. They treat you like family & are always happy to see their Rockland families. It’s worth the trip over the TZ Bridge!! Go & see for yourself! 5 stars for sure!!“

“I found this place after going to Mt. Hope AME Zion Church, down the block. Now I go here at least once a week. Michael makes a Chicken Pizza with Vodka Sauce, Basil and Fresh Mozzarella. It's so good. The guys are are always so nice too.“

“Giuseppe makes THEE BEST THIN CRUST.."" BRONX!!"" PIZZA. ChrispyLight a delicious.. and the gentlemen ..who work their are friendly n very courteous..My Mom loves ❤️ the mushrooms pizza w a drizzle of mozzarella!! I enjoy chicken roll too..I bring my family..and We love it..

Dietary restrictions: I have dietary restrictions n the menu accomodates“

“Just had chicken parmigiana And Ziti! Always the Best! EZ“

“Pizza is good, I've been there a few times. Most of the people are pretty nice in there. Last week on Thursday, a man behind the counter was angry and slamming stuff, I turned around and walked out, guess he was overwhelmed about how many people came in.“

“Primavera Pizzería is more than just amazing pizza. They have a fantastic menu of all the Italian classics the home country is known for! Done in or take out, you will never be disappointed. The staff, from the openers to the waiters, are so sweet and attentive. You don’t just feel like a guest. You feel like “famiglia”. And the food?!?! To die for. I travel 20 minutes past many a restaurant to eat here. It’s a must visit!“

“Love their chicken wings Always order two trays for family gatherings Everyone loves them and says they are the BEST Peggy“