50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pleasantville

“I've had pizza all over, and in my opinion no one makes a more delicious plain cheese pie than Pleasantville Pizza.“

“Owners are amazing people. They truly care about their customers and make them feel welcome. Best wraps and pizza around, everything is so fresh and always delicious. Thank you guys for being the best neighbors !“

“Absolutely the best pizza any place around always go out of my way to go there. Love it.“

“As A local DJ Entertainer I was performing up the street at another venue wanted to change it up so came here for a Great meal and a Drink , what’s not to like ! We were greeted from the entrance asked where we wanted to be seated & we were seen immediately and were served food and drinks in under 14mins which was great , WILL DEFINITELY be back to CRAFT 🙌🏽“

“Thank you to W&F for your amazing customer service. We ordered family style take out for my birthday last night. there was a small issue with the main course. After speaking with manager she not only was empathetic but addressed the issue quickly and effectively. Will happily order another wonderful meal again. Thank you!“

“Fantastic local place with the best wings around!“

“We had a wonderful dinner celebrating my daughter's 21st birthday! The meal and atmosphere were amazing! Most , the service was phenomenal! Our server, Miranda was wonderful! We were well taken care of for this celebration! It's our 1st time here but won't be our last! Thank you for an amazing evening to celebrate my daughter's 21st birthday!“

“Amazing service and delicious pizza! Thanks for the quick delivery of 13 pizzas to the Philipsburg parking lot last Wednesday!!! Sweet treat from Posh Pretzels coming your way in appreciation!!!“

“By far the best pizza in Nyack and really my favorite pizza place possibly ever! Consistently 10/10 Pies and wings. I have yet to order anything that hasn’t been great. To top it all off they are always super friendly in the shop! I’ve never ordered pizza from the same place consistently until I found Village. Haven’t ordered elsewhere since.“

“We stopped here while traveling from RI to PA and WOW are we glad we did. We needed a place to accommodate our small pup so we stopped to ask if they had outdoor seating. They didn’t but they created it by carrying a table and chairs outside for us - talk about customer service! Nick was such a fantastic host - setting us up, providing exceptional service and great conversation! I also can’t forget to mention how incredible the pizza and chicken roll were! This place is a 10/10 and we will definitely find a reason to stop back again!“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“One of the best pizzerias around. Great place“

“Absolute gassssssssss Keep killing it“

“Absolutely fantastic experience! We started with the mozzarella sticks, which were perfectly crispy and came with honey for dipping—a unique touch that was surprisingly delicious. The Caesar salad was fresh and flavorful.

For pizza, we tried the Killer Bee and the Chicken Vodka, and both were outstanding. The flavors were incredible, and you can tell they use quality ingredients.

The real surprise was the cheesesteak—it was out of this world! The bread is made from their pizza dough, which takes it to another level.

On top of the amazing food, the owner and everyone working there were so friendly, welcoming, and genuinely appreciative of their customers. Great food, great people, and a great atmosphere. This place is definitely a must-try!“

“Absolutely delicious- catered a work lunch and was loved by all“

“Love Riko’s! Nice Atmosphere, Delicious Food The Best Thin Crust Pizza, Outstanding Appetizers, Full Bar With Specialties Drinks & Healthy Salads! Desserts Straight From Italy!“

“Nice little place. Pizza and Calzone both were very good“

“I ate the pizza and wings so fast that I didn't even get a chance to take a picture.

We ordered the Beekman Ave specialty pizza, a regular pepperoni, and the eggplant pizza. The eggplant pizza was absolutely incredible—easily one of the best pizzas I've had in Westchester.

The style is a thin, bar-style pie similar to what you'd find in New Jersey, with a vibe like Colony Grill. The wings were excellent too. If you're a fan of thin-crust, bar-style pizza, this place is a must-visit. Highly recommended.“

“This is a hidden gem. I've been to Sally's Apizza in New Haven, Connecticut. This place is better. I have it in a tie with John's of Bleecker Street in Manhattan. It may be even better than John's. The pizza has been cooked perfectly both times I have gone. This guy knows what he's doing.“

“My go to spot fresh delish and hot“

“Silvio’s did a wonderful job feeding my wife’s family for her 80th birthday. Thank you for everything. All her cousins, sisters, brother, son, granddaughter and spouses had plenty to say about the food - All pleased. The servers were great. Everyone was so responsive to our needs. The cake from Artuso was great and we had plenty for the next day. I’ve been sweating this birthday for the last year snd you did not let me down!“

“I am from Staten Island and although pizza there is vaunted and valued, Casaletto pizza is outstanding and outshines even some of the best there. The young man at the counter was personable, and very customer oriented. Prizes were incredibly affordable especially when you use the quality ingredients. The place was also spotless. Has not changed since we left Ossining almost fifteen years ago. Kudos to Casaletto.“

“Absolutely delicious…. We loved everything we ordered. The Angry Pie takes pizza to the next level.“

“Food is really good and deserves 5 stars,but i do have a small complaint with my last order. My mom came recently from Serbia and i wanted to order a really good chicken parm with vodka sauce that i had a few weeks ago,but yesterday i received a chicken parm that was pretty dry and almost no vodka sauce. Pretty disappointed with last order overall,but its still a good place. I just hope you dont be stingy with sauces again.“

“The cheesesteaks blew my mind . The steak and the chicken wow just wow. Everything was flavorful and fresh and seasoned to the gods and cheesy. Best cheesesteaks in Westchester. The pizza was so good. I had Hawaiian and pepperoni and cheese. Yummy.“

“First met Danny & his family at their restaurant in Upper Nyack, Casa del Mare. It was our hometown favorite & sad when they closed. THEN we found him here, in Irvington! No place better for pizza, garlic knots & many other favorites. They treat you like family & are always happy to see their Rockland families. It’s worth the trip over the TZ Bridge!! Go & see for yourself! 5 stars for sure!!“

“the food is so amazing. this place never disappoints.“

“One of the best pizzerias in all of Westchester County you will not be disappointed all of the flavors of every item on the menu will melt in your mouth. Great job guys. I would recommend seeing this place.“

“Mario's restaurant is a true Gem in Mt Kisco. Not only the best pizza anywhere but suprising dishes from ribs to seafood specials. Not only is the food great, the man, Mario is one of the kindest, welcoming and humble human beings you will ever meet. love this place and love Mario. 40 yrs in Mt. Kisco. it's like having a brother in the pizzaria!“

“I have to start with they have the Manhattan Special Espresso Soda! One of my favs and makes it worth the trip in and of itself.
That said, I got the eggplant dinner with a salad and garlic knots. I didn't specify a dressing and got a creamy balsamic that was really good. The knots were great with just a little burnt cheese on the top. Not burnt in a bad way, maybe crispy is a better term. But delicious and buttery. The eggplant was also spot on, perfect amount of sauce and nice tender eggplant with the thinnest layer of breading that was crispy along the edges. I'll definitely be back.“

“Stopped in on the way back to PA, service was great as was the food and pricing. DEFINITELY RECOMMEND TO ALL!!!!!!👌👌👌“

“Delicious Margarita pizza! All ingredients are fresh. We use to drive over the bridge to Cassis’s in Orangburg, NY for pizza, but no more. We met the owner yesterday and he really takes pride in his business. Venice Pizza is now our go to place when we want delicious pies.“

“incredible food, incredible staff. my best friend brought me here 9 years ago when I went home to visit. I came back to visit this week, ate here twice and brought rice balls home from vacation. awesome awesome awesome place!!! ♥️“

“Simply Great“

“I have been meaning to put this rating up for a long time!! My wife and I went to visit my parents in White Plains, NY last winter. My wife ordered pizza and wings from Michael's. We had no idea that the food would be THAT GOOD! Everytime I need Italian food from a pizzeria order in spot, it will be Michael's!!!! It was prompt, delivered hot, professionally, on time, and SO GOOD!! We are patrons as long as they are there! I will also give another review when we dine IN!!“

“We just got dinners from Gerard’s for the first time. Definitely will be going back! The food was excellent, large portions and reasonably priced. Very, very good!“

“Just had chicken parmigiana And Ziti! Always the Best! EZ“

“Su personal es Muy amable la pizza 🍕 es deliciosa!!!“

“I had a fantastic time visiting this spot in Sparkill. The atmosphere is cozy, with a beautiful brick wall backdrop that makes for a great dining environment.

The pizza was absolutely delicious with perfectly melted cheese and generous pepperoni. I also really enjoyed the fresh salad topped with crunchy croutons. Everything was served promptly and looked wonderful. I will definitely be coming back again soon.“

“I had such a fantastic experience at Victor's. The variety here is truly impressive.

I was especially excited to try the walking tacos, which are served right in the bags of Doritos and Fritos. Everything tasted incredibly fresh. If you are in the area, you absolutely have to stop by and check out their creative menu. I will definitely be back soon.“

“I love Yorktown Pizza and Pasta not just because the food is delicious, but because the family owned business treats you as their own. I recently ordered Stromboli to bring to a party- everyone loved them and there wasn’t a bite left. Their pizza is excellent as well as their catered food. No need to worry when you get your food from them.“

“Great friendly staff. Panini was awesome“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“Italian Pavilion Pizzeria is the best place in White Plains for a sausage calzone. The calzone was tender, savory, meaty, and perfectly spiced. The Italian sausage was cooked to perfection, the mozzarella had the ideal gooey stretch, and the crust was crispy with just the right bake time. The marinara sauce added great flavor. The staff were clean, orderly, and very helpful. Also an excellent spot for pizza and pasta. Spacious restaurant with plenty of room for large parties and conveniently located near stores.“

“The food is absolutely amazing. I had a hard time deciding what to eat there was so many choices. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. They easily accommodated our party of 13. We will happily return.“

“I’ve loved Slices for years now. Typically go with the chicken parm sub - always enough for two meals! Tonight I tried the new PINWHEELS - I think this is a new invention of Isaac’s. Basically it’s a pizza dough roll with cheese and a pizza topping - I had one spinach pinwheel and one pepperoni. And each pinwheel comes with a generous side car of tomato sauce. The bottom of the pinwheel is really crispy - somewhat akin to a deep dish pizza. Hard to describe! Highly recommend. Chef’s kiss!“

“I Highly Recommend Amore's Staff & Cuisine ☆☆☆☆☆ !!!“

“My family visited from New Mexico for vacation and decided to stop by a pizza place. We happened to locate Sinapi’s and I am glad we did. It’s the best pizza we have ever had. If we are ever in the area again we will definitely be back.“

“If you’re craving the most mouthwatering pizza in town, this place delivers in every way. The crust comes out perfectly crisp, the toppings taste unbelievably fresh, and every slice feels like it was made with genuine care. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you pause mid‑bite because it’s that good. What really sets this spot apart is the friendly staff. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted like a neighbor, not just a customer. They remember faces, ask how you’re doing, and make you feel like you’re part of their little community. And that’s the magic — the small‑town feeling. It’s cozy, welcoming, and full of charm. You can sit back, enjoy incredible food, and feel right at home. A true local gem worth every visit.“