Paul's Italian American Restaurant
CLOSED$$ •
About Paul's Italian American Restaurant
Recent Reviews
161 ratings
Paul,
First off I'm slightly confused, I ordered some pies from David. I seem to have ended up with a box of sloppy pizza from yourself.
One that's kinda good because I got the pizza.
On a second note I did need to eat the Margherita over the hedge and did spill some tomato juice on the decking and the exterior carpet and gas powered fire pit (that was my colleague). As you can understand I'm sure there will be eccentric cleaning fees.
Is there anyway...read full review
First off I'm slightly confused, I ordered some pies from David. I seem to have ended up with a box of sloppy pizza from yourself.
One that's kinda good because I got the pizza.
On a second note I did need to eat the Margherita over the hedge and did spill some tomato juice on the decking and the exterior carpet and gas powered fire pit (that was my colleague). As you can understand I'm sure there will be eccentric cleaning fees.
Is there anyway...read full review
????
Zero flop!
Paul's Italian American Restaurant is a beloved Southampton institution that offers affordable traditional Italian cuisine and delicious pizza. Known for their Grandma Pie, it has recently added Turkish cuisine to the menu, featuring Lamb and chicken Adana, Gyro, and more. This is a great spot for a unique dining experience. The pizza remains a must-try, with one reviewer calling it the best slice from Wainscott to Hampton Bays. Although some diners have mentioned that the restaurant can feel outdated and that service may be inconsistent due to rotating staff, the recent management change has received positive feedback. The new manager, Kenny, has been praised for providing excellent service and making customers feel welcome. For a tasty slice or a Turkish dish, Paul's is definitely worth a visit.