19 Best American Restaurants near Tannersville

1 Deer Mountain Inn

4.8 Superb 238 Reviews

790 Co Rd 25, Tannersville

“If you look up “cozy” in the dictionary, I’m certain there would be a photo of Deer Mountain Inn. We haven’t stayed there, but have enjoyed two stellar dinners. The sourdough focaccia is an all time best bread and an absolute must order. The straciatella , burnt carrots, chicken liver pate, and butter were all among with the bread. Honestly, you can’t go wrong with any of the dips so order a bunch. The cheeseburger is special ( well seasoned, juicy, and the cheddar cheese and caramelized onions work perfectly) and the fries are some of the best. Deer Mountain does seasonal vegetables about as well as anyone can, the kabocha squash and heirloom tomatoes were outstanding. The smoked half chicken and Wagyu Bavette were both delicious. And don’t skip on the sundae, they have a mini version if you’re too full. But the s’mores are also wonderful. I don’t know, get both! Overall, just a gem in the Catskills everyone should have on their list.”

2 Last Chance Antiques & Cheese Café

4.4 Superb 380 Reviews

6009 Main Street, Tannersville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent Strip Steak with broccoli, and mashed potatoes. Peach Margarita. Dave in the market area was kind and helpful. All of the staff was fabulous. Beautiful and interesting atmosphere.”

3 The Perch Hotel

4.8 Superb 207 Reviews

7604 NY-23, East Windham · 9.93 miles

“Super cool spot! Amazing views, nice rooms, recently updated. It’s a gem of a place. Would definitely go back.”

4 Julia's Local

4.8 Superb 199 Reviews

1507 Hearts Content Road, Round Top · 7.32 miles

“The dinner parties are amazing but I'm obsessed with the vibe of Sunday service. I truly was not interested in eating anything else after visiting this place. Inspiring!!”

5 Prospect at Scribner's

3.9 Good 270 Reviews

13 Scribner Hollow Road, Hunter · 3.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service and suggestions from Roberto at the bar ... my dinner was wonderful .. the sunset a gift from spirit”

6 See & Be Kitchen

4.8 Superb 114 Reviews

466 Main Street, Cairo · 9.96 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love their breads (the croissant bread is amazing as French toast or grilled cheese) and their pastries. Haven’t had a bad choice at all.”

7 Zack's Place

4.7 Superb 120 Reviews

383 NY-296, Hensonville · 7.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“drive by all the time when we are in town and it was finally open. we are usually here on the weekends. nice and comfortable atmosphere. Casual dining. well worth the money.”

8 Rip Van Winkle Country Club

4.7 Superb 84 Reviews

3200 NY-23A, Palenville · 6.19 miles

• Take-Out

“We had our wedding at rip van winkle on 10/26, and it was amazing!! Sara was absolutely wonderful with planning everything and making sure everything went perfect! The staff was fantastic and the food was absolutely incredible! Thank you all so much!”

9 Trotwood Restaurant

4.5 Superb 34 Reviews

230 Winter Clove Road, Round Top · 6.82 miles

• Delivery

“What a vibe. We came in the winter and felt soooo cozy! The food, cocktails and wine were excellent! I am so pleased with our meal.Service is relaxed, no kids menu. Kid-friendliness: No kids menu, current menu has a real adult focus. However, there was lots of things to look at and explore, so my kids had a good time.”

10 Lynch's Pot O' Gold

4.6 Superb 61 Reviews

373 Old Rte 23, Cairo · 9.02 miles

• Take-Out

“me and my fiancee stayed one night the rv was beautiful comfortable the hospitality awesome food honey wings best honey around and they sell it too our dinner steak delicious drinks sex on the beach delicious and 4 games of pool we swam for 30 minutes we enjoyed the company we will be back!!!”

11 Red Rooster Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 175 Reviews

845 Main Street, Cairo · 9.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Taryn and Dan are absolutely amazing people who care about their staff and their customers! Accommodating to last minute requests and shuffling their own lives to help people in a last minute pinch, they are top notch! Great food, great service, great customer care!”

12 Red Rooster Bar & Grill

4.7 Superb 31 Reviews

845 Main Street, Cairo · 9.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This place is underrated. Good reasonably priced local spot with great drinks as well.”

13 Union + Post

4.0 Good 92 Reviews

5098 NY-23, Windham · 9.33 miles

• Take-Out

“The food was amazing. The wings, rib eye, ricotta appetizer 😍 the service was just as good. The Tesla charger outside was a huge plus. Lindsey our waitress was so helpful and I can’t wait to go back next time I visit. 10/10.”

14 The Clubhouse at Windham Mountain Club

4.2 Good 10 Reviews

36 South Street, Windham · 9.05 miles

• Take-Out

“The course was absolutely stunning and was in great shape will be back for more.”

15 Van Winkles Restaurant

3.8 Good 84 Reviews

62 Liftside Drive, Hunter · 4.27 miles

• Delivery

“Nice restaurant at the Resort. Opens at 4:00 which is fine. Has Salmon & salad - very good. Next night we sat at bar & served by the bartender. He was on top of our drinks & food. Ribeye came out at the right moment as I finished my wine & ordered a glass of Cabernet with my meal. Large portion, done a bit much but flavorful. A good experience”

16 WINDHAM DINER

4.3 Superb 250 Reviews

5339 NY-23, Windham · 9.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Dont let the name mislead you. They do serve diner food but it is, imo, the best diner food I have ever had. I prepare my own meals. I dont like to go to restaurants because most dont prepare food I am satisfied with, taste or freshnessof ingredients. This place sets the bar higher for the other local restaurants. The food is very good, and Ive tried almost everything. The prices are reasonable. This is my favorite place to eat beside my own cooking. The owners, the staff all very nice people. Makes me feel like Im visiting family not a diner”

17 Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House

4.3 Superb 275 Reviews

5639 NY-23, Windham · 10.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came here while driving through town on a whim with my husband and dog and ate outside. Servers were welcoming & friendly. Food was great. We ordered the wings, a chicken sandwich and a burger. (Bonus was the free popcorn 😉) would come again if we're ever in the area”

18 Ronni MacGregor's Pub

4.1 Good 128 Reviews

7740 NY-23A, Hunter · 3.89 miles

• Take-Out

“I love going to Macgregors always fun people to talk to good food good atmosphere highly recommends.”

19 Tap House Grille

3.9 Good 110 Reviews

5359 NY-23, Windham · 9.78 miles

• Take-Out

“We were going somewhere else until we saw the movement through the window, we decided to stop and to our surprise, live music started, by a phenomenal duo of women. The fast food, despite the limited menu after 8 am, was enough for us. We had the best wine of the trip, the Mark West Pinot noir, from California, I highly recommend it. Parking: Easy parking on the street”