13 Best Steakhouses near Tarrytown

“I've been to this location a handful of times. I was waiting for a friend so I sat at the bar for about 25 minutes and was served by Scarlett. She was super friendly and made me a couple of tasty cocktails. It wasn't super busy so I was able to get serviced fast and efficiently. When my friend arrived, we migrated to the dining area to eat. I believe our servers name was Mike. A young man that I recognized from my previous times at the restaurant. He was super knowledgeable of the menu and was a pleasure to have. Overall a great experience. The only thing I felt different from the previous times I dined at the restaurant was it felt like the employees were speaking more script like, like the company told them to say xyz to the customers. Felt fake and forced. These employees are good without being told what to say.“

“Great service food is excellent.“

“Great addition to our community! Haven’t had a bad meal yet!! Love going during the week for a drink and quick snack! And bringing friends and family for a multi course meal!! The cacio Pepe is sooooo good, as are the oysters, steak heck everything is good!! You can’t go wrong. The service is second to none. Can’t wait to dine again asap!“

“I went here with my wife for Valentine’s Day for a lunch date and it was excellent. To start we got the barata which was fresh and paired nicely with the bread they gave us. Then we got a Filet Mignon, Lamb, baked potato, Mac and Cheese, and Asparagus. All of it was fantastic. My wife is pregnant so they made her a mocktail and I got an old fashioned. They nailed both drinks. Overall these guys delivered and made our final Valentine as a family of two special. Thank you guys. I highly recommend this spot and we will be back.“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“Phenomenal experience. Top notch food, atmosphere, and wait staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all around. The food is always superb and the bar is amazing. Definitely a lifetime customer!“

“Best lunch ever at One Pier Steakhouse in Yonkers!

French onion soup, truffle fries, branzino (insanely good—perfectly cut fillets),

calamari, oysters, spicy shrimp—all spot-on. draft Modelo hit the spot too. Killer service, clean bathrooms, cozy vibe. Highly recommend—especially the branzino!“

“I know when I go there and Erica is on I’m going have a great time. She is the best. So friendly but above all professional. Def going back for the good food and my waitress!“

“muy buen ambiente, personal muy cordial y muy experimentado, la comida muy buena recomiendo el carajillo“

“If you want to experience the finest steakhouse dining in NY look no further!! From food Quality, ambience, to exceptional service Benjamins steakhouse has it all. It’s an absolute must! Cannot recommended highly enough.“

“First time here, food was tasty and attentive service! The Caesar salad was crunchy and favorable. The shrimp Fra Diavlo was flavor able with just enough spice. We split the porterhouse, it was cooked to perfection and well seasoned! The only complaint is that the bread for the table has nuts, I'm extremely allergic to nuts, the waiter thought the bread only contained seeds but I immediately had a reaction, fortunately I spat out the piece bc I would have needed my epi pen and a trip to the ER!“

“You can always enjoy a great dinner here.“

“Had a amazing 1st time there! Our server was beyond wonderful, very attentive. Rashid thank you, the bartender Liz was great for after dinner drinks and meant the owner who was so down to earth and was so nice! The decor and atmosphere just topped it off! Love it so much I might just have to go back this week! Thank you all for making me feel right at home, Definitely a must! 🫶🫶 the crab cake was great and my steak was cooked perfectly!“