50 Best Italian Restaurants near Valley Cottage

“Yesterday 1st time had the ribs to die for .loved it all except the mac and cheese was a little to dry and wasnt a fan of the shell macaroni.but i did see a pizza pie go by and man it looks real good.im coming back my family and turn them on.“

“I’ve finally tried their white pie and I have to say it’s the The Best white pie I have EVER had. Finally a white pie that’s got the perfect amount of garlic! Worth Every Penny! And don’t forget to grab a Sweet&Salty’s cookie too!“

“Excellent! Food was so fresh and fabulous and so was the service. Pizza crust was delicious and light. Everyone was so very nice and accommodating. Great atmosphere and concept of Pizza by the foot. So good that weekends are packed, so make a reservation or try a weeknight. You will not be disappointed!“

“Mambo Italiano was such a great find...Awesome, authentic food. Everything is made from pastas to desserts. They also have a secret ingredient and warm and welcoming staff who clearly love what they do. Thank you.“

“We have been going to Bosfa Restaurant since it opened . The food is terrific. The seafood is so fresh. I can’t say enough about it. The service great. What more can I say.“

“We had an amazing dining experience at Verana. The atmosphere was elegant and welcoming, making it a perfect place for a special night out. The food was outstanding—every dish was beautifully presented and full of flavor. The house-made pasta was fresh and delicious, and the service was attentive and friendly throughout the evening. We will definitely be coming back and highly recommend Verana to anyone looking for an exceptional Italian restaurant in the area!“

“Vegan Friendly ❤️🩷 Great place.“

“Everything is always delicious“

“Simply Great“

“Giulo’s is the best restaurant in Rockland County. Very comfortable seating. Large cocktails. Great food. Excellent desserts. Top-notch service. Benny, the owner, is on top of things. Have a great lunch or dinner and go to Guilo’s. I highly recommend Guilo’s“

“I have never had a bad experience here and I mean that, I’ve never even had a slightly bad experience in a slightly negative way. The food is incredible, the service is wonderful, the setting is perfect, I love how small and intimate it is, and I love the fact that’s family owned. I go to this restaurant once a week and God bless you to the owners and the staff for not only a job excellently done; but I hope there are many more years in the future, of us having the privilege of tasting the deliciousness that comes out of your kitchen.“

“Great service and incredibly tasty food !!!!! If you haven’t been you’re missing out!!!!💯 Food and service was outstanding, thank you for an enjoyable afternoon 😊“

“We had a wonderful experience at this pizza place! The brick oven calzone and pizza were absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared.
What made it even more special was enjoying the meal with our grandchildren. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, making it a great spot for family time. Everyone loved the food, and every bite was truly tasty.
We’ll definitely be coming back again!“

“Great little spot. The food has been spot on. Wait staff is friendly. Will go again. And will recommend“

“Very family oriented and wonderful owners thank you“

“I order pretty frequently from Dom’s in Nanuet since I work nearby. Yesterday, when we got our order to Sloatsburg, there was an omission in the order ( we really should have checked before we left). As always, Dom’s went above and beyond to make this right. They drove my order to Sloatsburg and included several delicious extras! Their catering always makes our events delicious, but yesterday they made it extra delicious. Dom’s has amazing food and even better service.“

“Excellent !!!! The food was fabulous !!! Service was incredible !!! Spectacular atmosphere !!! Highly recommend !!!!“

“I highly recommend this place. We had a party of 38 who needed a last minute place for our Xmas party and they took us without hesitation. Food good, drinks good and the staff was amazing, kind and just overall really nice place!!“

“staff is very friendly and accommodating and the additional food we had in addition to the delicious pizza was excellent and plentiful“

“Food and Staff is over the top amazing. 2 Thumbs up. We love this place. One of Best Italian restaurants in Rockland County.“

“Just finished Sunday Brunch at La Terrazza, and we cannot say enough good things about this restaurant. Brett and his crew never disappoint. The food is delicious, the ambiance is amazing and the service is the absolute best! The staff is friendly, attentive and makes us feel like family. Our server today was Lee, and she was absolutely fantastic! We have also had excellent experiences with Leslie, Maryanne, Margaret and Jeanie. If we could give more than 5 stars, we would.“

“BEEN COMING HERE FOR 25-30 YRS, NEVER A BAD MEAL, BAD SERVICE, EXCEL IN EVERYTHING !!“

“We held our 63rd reunion here and it was perfect. Food and service perfect. Those who live in the area will be back. Grazie Frank!!!“

“Great food and service was excellent“

“Great food at family owned restaurant“

“On December 12th my law office had their holiday luncheon at this wonderful restaurant. I also ordered a tray of meat lasagna for Christmas. If you have never had the pleasure of eating at this restaurant, I suggest you run - do not pass go - and get your butt there and eat the most delicous food on this planet. The chef created the meat lasagna - a simple dish - and elevated to something that just melts in your mouth with deliciousness. LOVE LOVE LOVE this restaurant!!“

“My wife and I have been there 4 times in a row and each time have had a fantastic experience! The food , drinks, service , and the staff are excellent. It’s a very affordable place to Dine out. We highly recommend this restaurant! It really is a hidden Gem in New City. Go and invite your friends, you will all be pleasantly surprised!!! Reservation is definitely recommended…it get busy! Enjoyyyy😎“

“Every single thing I get from here fabulous , delicious! So thank you guys so much!“

“Absolutely delicious chicken francese , cavatelli with broccoli and caesar salad we had tonight from you guys . Thank you 😊“

“Outstanding service and everything we ordered was excellent and delicious.“

“My granddaughter and I came to visit the famous Sleepy Hollow from Texas mid-July. The pizza and bread were delicious, the service exceptional. I would definitely recommend and we will be back.“

“Iliana and her staff went above and beyond for our Retirement Reception. Everything was perfect from start to finish! Can’t wait to host our next event with them!!!!“

“Love this place. The food is delicious. The staff is wonderful!!!“

“Really great Italian food! Can't wait to go back,“

“LOVE THIS PLACE FEEDS MY FAMILY OF 6 Every week with their family Dinner special. Friendly and affordable!“

“great food help is great well managed owner is hands on“

“Outstanding, delicious Italian food, the best pizza- we love this place.“

“Pizza was good and the garlic knots were even better! $12 for a slice, garlic knots and a soda so a bit pricey.

Staff weren’t the friendliest and the back area to eat was dark and a little dingy.

Good for a quick slice in the neighborhood but would take it to go and eat near the water“

“I am a registered nurse and after a long day I was on my way home from work to buy something they recognized my profession during this pandemic and thanked me and gave me something free of charge it was touching thank you kind people That made my day!!!!“

“Great food. First time visiting and didn't disappoint. I had the truffle and mushroom and the four cheese risotto balls. Both were great. The Fig and Cheese sandwich was also delicious. Next i want to try the lasagna and the breakfast muffins.“

“The best everything Italian. Sandwiches deli salads hot food and fresh ravioli on Friday and Saturday. Sauce gravy and Pizza simply the best thin crust you can not compare until you have had it from their oven!“

“Had my moms surprise 70th bday here this weekend and it was amazing. The party package is perfectly priced and affordable. The wait staff and owner accommodated us with any and every need. All the party guests and especially my mom had a great time! The cake was also beyond amazing! Have had parties here in the past, but was never the organizer. Alfio took all the stress out and it went perfect! Thank you guys at San Martino’s for making my mom’s bday extra special!“

“Absolutely delicious. Will be back!“

“For a lovely taste of Italy go here“

“I have been coming here for years. I consider myself a good cook but when I need good food that I don't have to prepare, this is my go-to place. The staff and owner are great! Try the stuffed peppers, Chicken Milanese and Lasagna. OMG!“

“We had a wedding rehearsal party in the grand ballroom. From the planning stages to the end of the event Bacari’s Banquet Director Kara did everything in her power to make it a perfect experience. The food and the service were exceptional. What a great place to have an occasion and what a great person in Kara to help run it.“

“Amazing service and delicious pizza! Thanks for the quick delivery of 13 pizzas to the Philipsburg parking lot last Wednesday!!! Sweet treat from Posh Pretzels coming your way in appreciation!!!“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“This place is the best there is! Delicious food, great atmosphere.“

“My husband and I had a most delightful dinner. Michel the owner welcomed us like into his home. Excellent wine recommendation with our dinner. All staff efficient and attentive to our needs. Octopus appetizer, Pasta Bolonase delicious and generous. The venue itself is charming, with Michels own artwork as decor. We were visiting from out of town, otherwise this would be a favorite to frequent.“