13 Best American Restaurants in Watkins Glen

“That had to be the best egg sandwich I ever had. Randomly picked this place from a google search. It was a great choice.“

“The staff was professional. First time dining here on 10-11-2025 very relaxing and quiet! People were respectful and it was quiet. We loved it! Usually you go out and it’s loud and rowdy but this place is Exceptional! The food was very delicious! I’ve never had strawberry champagne vinaigrette on my salad which went great with the cheese! 😋“

“We stopped here for morning donuts before going to the park. I consider myself quite the donut connoisseur and boy oh boy these babies did not disappoint! Some of the best around! We are from Ohio and we will definitely be back the next time we come to New York.❤❤❤🍩🍩🍩“

“Our second year staying in the cabins. Lovely accommodations, wonderful staff. View of the lake is gorgeous! Highly recommend!“

“The best wings in the area! a great local watering hole with a lot of small town charm. friendly patrons and staff make for a comfy atmosphere. highly recommend“

“Visited this restaurant on a whim based on reviews last night after hiking Watkins Glen State Park. IT WAS PHENOMENAL!!!! My husband had the duck and I had the trout. We split the mussels and green salad. The wine the beer everything was fantastic and the staff is very attentive. Definitely going back again!!!!“

“Los desayunos 🍳 están súper con más de 65 años me aprecio súper bien contando los años que tiene este lugar wow fenomenal pedí jamón con huevo y queso y pan tostado súper rico“

“Stopped by here this past Sunday after looking for a place to eat and so far it turned out to be awesome!Service was amazing and she was super helpful and sweet.The food was great and so were the drinks. They have an outdoor section as well. It had nothing but beautiful views there of the lake.“

“We had an impromptu stay in Watkins Glen on our way home to NC. We absolutely loved the hospitality of the staff at Seneca Lodge. The room was quaint and clean. The food at the Lodge restaurant was amazing, both for supper and breakfast. Can't recommend the cinnamon raisin French toast enough! Our server, Joyce, was attentive and friendly. We will definitely be back!“

“We had an impromptu stay in Watkins Glen on our way home to NC. We absolutely loved the hospitality of the staff at Seneca Lodge. The room was quaint and clean. The food at the Lodge restaurant was amazing, both for supper and breakfast. Can't recommend the cinnamon raisin French toast enough! Our server, Joyce, was attentive and friendly. We will definitely be back!“

“this guy Steven at Kookalaroc makes the best Philly I've ever had and its not even close! I will not be needing to look at the menu ever again. you could start a Cult with this Philly. get the philly“

“Great food and great service“

“We had fun! Drinks were good and reasonably priced. Owner and bartender were very friendly. We will definitely be back next time we're in town!“