18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Webster

jojo Bistro & Wine Bar - Webster Pizza • $$
42 E Main St, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Cajun Chicken with Frites
Steak Frites Medium Rare
Pepperoni & Bacon Pizza
Pita Chips and Hummus
Jojo Burger and Fries
Risotto with Shrimp
Wild Mushroom Za
Blackened Salmon
Mussels Frites
French Fries

“Great food, drinks, and atmosphere.“

4.2 Good64 Reviews
Proietti's Italian Restaurant & Catering Italian • $$
980 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Mozzarella Romano and Garlic
Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
White Pizza with Italian Sausage
Chicken Riggies Utica Inspired
Gluten Free Chicken Parmesan
Cream of Broccoli Soup
Linguine Gabrielle
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken French

“Proietti’s has been one of my favorite restaurants since I moved to Webster in 2013! Great food, and amazing staff:)“

4.7 Superb71 Reviews
Rhino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
85 Donovan St, Webster

Customers` Favorites

World Famous Dill Pickle Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Wing Pizza
Dill Pickle Pizza Rhino's
Turkey Submarine Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Pizza

“Great Subs & nice ppl. Have ordered several times from here & humbolt and often get Italian sub w/ double meat toasted/warmed and loaded with veggies....its been perfect everytime and pleasant ppl on phone and in person. Bit of a hole-in-wall, but you can tell they are trying to improve - good food, people, and price. Also, their Buff Chicken Wing Pizza is V-good! Older lady at Humbolt location is one of the most passionate pizza makers you will find!“

4.1 Good59 Reviews
PONTILLO`S WEBSTER The Original Recipe! Pizza • $
Woods Plaza, 807 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Classic Margarita Pizza
Three Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella Sticks 5
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Cheese Pizza
Meatball Sub
Fried Dough
Sheet Pizza
Wings

“To preface my review, I'm. a food snob, having said that I could not be more impressed with Jerry and his staff. I walked into his location with a 4 hour window to order pizza for a family that lost a loved one suddenly. Jerry was empathetic and patient. The pizza and wings were fabulous and they earned several fans for sure well done“

4.1 Good51 Reviews
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Pizza • $
195 North Ave, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashion Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Charlie Pizza
Peanut Butter Pie
Pasta & Meatballs
Italian Burger
Favorite Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Garlic Bread
Meat Pizza
Large Pizza

“Definitely my favorite place in Webster to get pizza and wings. This Salvatore’s location is always generous with their pizza toppings! I have never ordered from here and been disappointed. I’m always impressed with the quality and quantity of what they put on their pizzas! The chicken wings here are also very good. Never small in size. They are always cooked perfectly!“

4 Good49 Reviews
Mark's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1201 Bay Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom Sausage and Onion Pizza

“Beyond impressed! This pizza was the only pizza my family would order when I was a kid. We moved to Florida and over the years people have started away from them and we were always disappointed. We tried it twice and we're so impressed I had to review! Wings are cooked to perfection and the pizza is on point! ESPECIALLY the GLUTEN FREE!!! It actually looks, feels and chews like a pizza, not just a glorified tortilla. We will always order from Marks when we come to visit!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

4.2 Good19 Reviews
Pub 235 Pubs • $$
235 North Ave, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Crunch Rolls
Corned Beef Reuben Sandwich
Grandpa Hank's Roast Beef
Spicy Fried Cheese Curds
Pesto Burrata Bruschetta
Pub 235 Classic Burger
The Bugsy Malone Pizza
Pub Cuban Sandwich
Smokehouse Burger
Seafood Bisque

“The price of a well vodka martini was ridiculous $14 You can buy a liter of Recipe 21 for $13.49 We can't afford to go there anymore and it has been our favorite since they opened!!! This is price gouging!!!!!“

4.3 Superb108 Reviews
Marvin Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $
27 W Main St, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Sloppy Plate Fries
Gluten Free Pizza
Steak
Wings
Blue

“You are our new #1 go to now for pizza and more! Thanks for such an amazing experience. Staff ROCKS! Hot and fresh delivery!! Saved to my phone contacts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.7 Good26 Reviews
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Pizza • $$
1217 Bay Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Super Slice Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Thin Thin Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Favorite Pizza
Buffalo Wing
Meat Pizza
Fries
Salad
More

“It is my opinion that writing a review is a tricky thing to do! Often times, the tendency is to respond, based on an emotional experience,.. something that recently occurred, initial gut instinct, etc. Sometimes, that's good, ...honest, raw,.. but sometimes, that's not so good.

I'm glad I took my time in writing this review because I feel that the reader of this review will get a better understanding as to why I'm giving this establishment a 5-star rating, and hopefully help them during their next pizza purchase.

Some would argue that pizza is pizza,.. nothing too complicated to make. And while I would agree with this statement, I would also express my shock that some establishments manage to stay in business, based on a crappy product! At some 'other' pizza establishments,... one week, I'll have a phenomenal pizza experience, only to be utterly disappointed the next week, only to discover "Bob" wasn't working the day I had my less-than-stellar pie.

I recently lost my "Pizza Guy", and have spent the last 6 months in finding my replacement pizza establishment. I have tried all the pizza establishments in my immediate area, and even ventured out to a few select places. I've relied of other people's suggestions. Never quite finding a place to land at.

A few months ago, and on a whim, I decided to try Salvatores,.. I passed it every day I went to Weg's,.. so I figured I had nothing to lose! I've never been into 'corporate chain' type of places because I feel that they lack authenticity, and are simply massed produced.

Well, I have to say,... although that might be true for some chains,.. I do NOT think its true at Salvatores! This is what you can expect at Salvatores:
* Consistent, great tasting pizza with plenty of sauce/cheese/pepperoni.
* Professional and courteous staff,....service with a smile!
* Safe, clean, and family-oriented atmosphere!
* Weekly if not daily coupon specials.
* Affordable pricing!

In a world that is consistently Inconsistent, and changing, the last thing I need to deal with is inconsistency in my pizza! If you also enjoy some sort of consistency in life, ...then I highly recommend you give Salvatores a try!“

3.6 Good51 Reviews
Mark's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1210 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Meatball Hot Sub
Turkey Breast Cold Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Medium Pizza

“Best pizza since papa johns.
But Webster Location NEEDS to increase their open hours, it is the one location in town that closes 2 hours earlier than any other nearby marks :(

shouldnt be forced to use doordash or uber eats to get marks from another location.

PLEASE EXTEND UR HOURS, Especially on Fri/Sat“

3.5 Good33 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
1075 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Medium Spinach Pan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Tater Tots
Pretzel

“Just picked up two medium pizzas tonight ; not unusual for us on a weekday . But was especially awesome tonight and had to call the restaurant and compliment them on the pizzas. They were a 10 on scale of 1-10. Turns out a new manager and assistant manager were making them and are training also. Keep up the great job could even eat the whole crust; will be back next week 💗“

3.5 Good35 Reviews
Coliseum Pizza Roma Pizza • $
696 Ridge Rd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wing Pizza
Large 16 Pizza
Chicken Wings
Onion Rings
Steak Sub
Toppings
Cold
Hot

“A calzone with 1 topping is 9 bucks so I can't really complain about the size. It came with marinara sauce and ranch included. The inside is a mess but the staff were friendly. I think that they're the only place in the entire city that is open until 4am which is pretty cool.“

3.5 Good44 Reviews
Pizza Hut Express Pizza • $
1050 Ridge Rd, Webster

“Really good classic Pizza Hut pizza. Definitely one of the PH’s that remembers how to make their signature pizza. I’ve been to other PH over the last few years that seemed to forget the marvel that they were back in the 80-90’s. Glad to find a good local Pizza Hut again.“

3 Average1 Reviews
Coach Sports Bar Bar • $
19 W Main St, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings and blt Sandwich
The Coach Cheeseburger
The Coach House Salad
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Chicken Bacon Melt
Cheese Quesadilla
Boneless Wings
Bone-In Wings
Patty Melt
Fish Fry

“Delicious salads- Penny makes a fantastic salad! I’ve been getting them every Wednesday for the last year… never disappointed.“

4.2 Good38 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1900 Empire Blvd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Triple Chocolate Brownie
Breaded Boneless Wings
Pepperoni Pan Pizza
Personal Pan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Supreme Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Stuffed Crust
Breadsticks

“From 2023: New melts are delicious!
Today, August 6, 2024, I got a Hut Box with fries and a personal pan. This was the first time I had their fries, and they were some of the best I've ever had. The service was excellent, courteous, and prompt. The lower rating for Atmosphere was just because their dine-in area was closed, so I had to eat in my car, which wasn't awful, but not what I planned or desired.“

3.4 Good51 Reviews
Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Webster Pizza • $
1778 Empire Blvd, Webster

Customers` Favorites

18 Large Brooklyn Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
1 2 Rack with 1 BBQ Sauce
Spinach Bacon & Garlic
BBQ Pulled Pork Pizza
2 Large Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Lover
Meatballs
Wings

“The pizza was SO good! The man who answered the phone & greeted me upon entering (I'm assuming the owner) was incredibly welcoming and down to earth. The food was ready exactly when it said it would be. Can't wait to come back and try the other specials!“

3.3 Good46 Reviews
Tuscan 2 Go Italian • $
2231 Empire Blvd, Webster

“We are obsessed and plan to be regulars!! We love the cortona, like a margarita and it’s super thin crust, and the Lucca pepperoni with a little bit thicker but still NY style thin, NO FLOP! The owners and staff are always so kind, they smile while they work so you know they love what they do and that’s a vibe! Tiramisu was so good I love that they put it in a cup, and the cannoli with the chocolate and vanilla coating on the shell was genius because the shell didn’t collapse as fast as a plain cannoli would. 10/10 will be back!!!“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
Guida's Pizzeria Inc Pizza • $
160 W Main St, Webster

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
The Italian Stallion
Chicken Fingers
Homemade Chips
Sheet Pizza
24 Wings

“I grew up in Irondequoit and have always had Guida’s pizza and wings at the table from time to time. The “Dave’s special” was always one of MY go to’s as a kid/teen. I visited the shop in Irondequoit coming from Greece now. The quality and taste are better than I remember. I ordered the Dave special and my wife got Mr.B’s beef and cheddar steak sub minus the jalapeños. The pizza chef (who has helpful and friendly) warned her it was a little spicy with the jalapeños and the homemade horseradish bistro sauce. Even let us try the sauce to make sure it wasn’t to spicy before ordering it. Sauce was delicious. Not only was my sub cooked perfectly just as remembered with the crusty bread cooked just right but the Mr B’s was not greasy and dripping all over the table. The cheese was melted just right to hold all the ingredients together. ANOTHER go to if your looking for a Rochester steak sub. Both STILL absolute 5 STARS!! We ate in and were served warm homemade chips and pickles with our subs. Great touch to compliment the meal. Thanks for staying excellent after all these years Guidas WOW!!!!“

3.2 Average33 Reviews

You May Also Like