17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Webster

“Great food, drinks, and atmosphere.“

“Pizza and sub were fantastic, and it was Monday so we.got a free large cheese pizza along with the other pie. Atmosphere is irrelevant because you're picking up takeout there most of the time. Immediately goes on my favorites list!!! Much cheaper than other name.pizzerias in the area and the quality better.“

“Proietti’s has been one of my favorite restaurants since I moved to Webster in 2013! Great food, and amazing staff:)“

“To preface my review, I'm. a food snob, having said that I could not be more impressed with Jerry and his staff. I walked into his location with a 4 hour window to order pizza for a family that lost a loved one suddenly. Jerry was empathetic and patient. The pizza and wings were fabulous and they earned several fans for sure well done“

“The price of a well vodka martini was ridiculous $14 You can buy a liter of Recipe 21 for $13.49 We can't afford to go there anymore and it has been our favorite since they opened!!! This is price gouging!!!!!“

“We love the pizza here and order it often. I won’t be ordering the fish dinner again. Very disappointed! The batter on the fish was like rubber. The proportion of batter to fish was way too little fish. I ordered pickup and the meal was just thrown haphazardly into a box. I liked the coleslaw.“

“Beyond impressed! This pizza was the only pizza my family would order when I was a kid. We moved to Florida and over the years people have started away from them and we were always disappointed. We tried it twice and we're so impressed I had to review! Wings are cooked to perfection and the pizza is on point! ESPECIALLY the GLUTEN FREE!!! It actually looks, feels and chews like a pizza, not just a glorified tortilla. We will always order from Marks when we come to visit!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

“Six of us dined in West Webster location on Monday night. Amy was excellent!! Great drink specials and $10 medium pizza special (hot right out of oven and delicious). Buffalo chicken sandwich was also yummy. Will be back on Monday night when Amy working as she was great, very welcoming!“

“Mark's provides a very good and large slice of pizza. The crust is thick and chewy. The dough is pliable and can easily be folded like a slice of NY pie should be. If I had time, I would have ordered a whole pie instead of a take away slice that had been in the warmer for unknown time.

Ordered a big salad and wow, it was really big. Easily feeds 2+ people and has an excellent price of around $11.

We didn't get to eat inside. We arrived around 7pm and they close at 8. The tables were already up and they were cleaning the restaurant.“

“You are our new #1 go to now for pizza and more! Thanks for such an amazing experience. Staff ROCKS! Hot and fresh delivery!! Saved to my phone contacts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“A calzone with 1 topping is 9 bucks so I can't really complain about the size. It came with marinara sauce and ranch included. The inside is a mess but the staff were friendly. I think that they're the only place in the entire city that is open until 4am which is pretty cool.“

“Just picked up two medium pizzas tonight ; not unusual for us on a weekday . But was especially awesome tonight and had to call the restaurant and compliment them on the pizzas. They were a 10 on scale of 1-10. Turns out a new manager and assistant manager were making them and are training also. Keep up the great job could even eat the whole crust; will be back next week 💗“

“I grew up in Irondequoit and have always had Guida’s pizza and wings at the table from time to time. The “Dave’s special” was always one of MY go to’s as a kid/teen. I visited the shop in Irondequoit coming from Greece now. The quality and taste are better than I remember. I ordered the Dave special and my wife got Mr.B’s beef and cheddar steak sub minus the jalapeños. The pizza chef (who has helpful and friendly) warned her it was a little spicy with the jalapeños and the homemade horseradish bistro sauce. Even let us try the sauce to make sure it wasn’t to spicy before ordering it. Sauce was delicious. Not only was my sub cooked perfectly just as remembered with the crusty bread cooked just right but the Mr B’s was not greasy and dripping all over the table. The cheese was melted just right to hold all the ingredients together. ANOTHER go to if your looking for a Rochester steak sub. Both STILL absolute 5 STARS!! We ate in and were served warm homemade chips and pickles with our subs. Great touch to compliment the meal. Thanks for staying excellent after all these years Guidas WOW!!!!“

“Really good classic Pizza Hut pizza. Definitely one of the PH’s that remembers how to make their signature pizza. I’ve been to other PH over the last few years that seemed to forget the marvel that they were back in the 80-90’s. Glad to find a good local Pizza Hut again.“

“The pizza was SO good! The man who answered the phone & greeted me upon entering (I'm assuming the owner) was incredibly welcoming and down to earth. The food was ready exactly when it said it would be. Can't wait to come back and try the other specials!“

“From 2023: New melts are delicious!
Today, August 6, 2024, I got a Hut Box with fries and a personal pan. This was the first time I had their fries, and they were some of the best I've ever had. The service was excellent, courteous, and prompt. The lower rating for Atmosphere was just because their dine-in area was closed, so I had to eat in my car, which wasn't awful, but not what I planned or desired.“

“We are obsessed and plan to be regulars!! We love the cortona, like a margarita and it’s super thin crust, and the Lucca pepperoni with a little bit thicker but still NY style thin, NO FLOP! The owners and staff are always so kind, they smile while they work so you know they love what they do and that’s a vibe! Tiramisu was so good I love that they put it in a cup, and the cannoli with the chocolate and vanilla coating on the shell was genius because the shell didn’t collapse as fast as a plain cannoli would. 10/10 will be back!!!“