35 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bay Village

“I have ordered two custom cakes within the last two weeks. First one was an edible image cake and the order was taken very last minute but they were very accommodating and very kind, great service. Second cake I ordered was a design I sent of inspiration for the cake and it was executed to perfection. The second cake was absolutely amazing, and couldn’t ask for anything better. Cake decorator is amazing!! Staff are all so kind, polite, and the atmosphere is great every time I come in and every time I call!“

“My daughter took me last week for the first time, we bought delicious cinnamon scones.
I went back today for a coffee. I must say it was absolutely the best cup I have had in a while. They have other items and ice cream too. Very cozy atmosphere and plenty of seating and good parking area.
This will be my new coffee shop! Friendly staff, excellent service and prices.“

“We popped into Tutti-Frutti-Mix completely by accident but will return because we LOVE it ♥️“

“Awesome Ice cream!! Great Atmosphere, great service and delicious ice cream with so many tasty flavors to choose from. Mitchell’s is exclusively unique to Cleveland so if in town for any reason I highly recommend checking them out. I will definitely be visiting again!! ?“

“We love Mitchell's ice cream, so we decided to use their catering service for our wedding dessert (perfect for the August heat!). We worked with Tiara, who was the absolute best. She helped us customize our order and answered all of our questions very promptly. We chose the pre-scooped option for convenience, and those were some generous scoops! We ordered the cookies & cream, campfire s'mores, and lemon sorbet flavors, and they were all delicious. All of our guests loved the ice cream, and it was really fun to introduce our out-of-state friends to Mitchell's.“

“We visited and had a smoothie and a brownie Sundae. My daughter said she was still thinking about how good the smoothie was 24 hours later. My sundae was also delicious. The staff was super friendly. Definitely will visit again if we are in Cleveland

Vegetarian options: They offered several vegan ice cream flavors“

“Mitchell's has garnered a cult following in the Cleveland area, and visiting their Avon location showed that off well. My wife and I stopped on a Sunday night while on a mini vacation and staying at the Wyndham hotel that is within walking distance. Even though we arrived in the 9 o'clock hour, the location was jam packed, both with customers in line and those sitting both inside the contemporary dining area and outside on the plesant porch area. But even though it was very busy the entire time we were there, the staff was super swift and friendly, making the wait times negligible.

I ordered the seasonal Campfire S'mores flavor and found it to be very good, with nice sized chunks of classic s'mores toppings and creamy and smooth ice cream that was rich and flavorful, but pleasantly not as heavy as other premium ice cream. My wife got the lavender and honey flavor, and really enjoyed the strong flavors of each part. Overall, there's a a reason Mitchell's has the kind of area support it does, and why thus particular location is such a community hotbed, especially on warm summer nights.“

“I had an amazing experience with this ice cream shop! The ice cream was delicious, and the customer service was excellent. The menu had a wide variety of flavors to choose from.“

“Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by a smiling staff member who guided me to the counter. However, I noticed a worker that during busy times, impatience can sometimes manifest in short responses to customers or a hurried demeanor. While she strives to maintain efficiency, her impatience can sometimes overshadow the friendly atmosphere that Fenik prides itself on.“

“Everything is delicious, and the people serving are super friendly. Highly recommend.“

“LOVE dairy grove!!! Our go-to spot for sweet treats in the summer! My kids love the play ground and I love the options of both hard scoop (my favorite brand btw) or soft serve. I’m not usually a fan of soft serve in general, but definitely like their version and find myself getting their awesome specialty sundaes! Strawberry pretzel crunch is so good!! I also love their slushie and their creative team making lots of fun treats!! I’m going to have to stock up on their hard scoop ice cream for the winter!!“

“Vintage flavors of ice cream!!!“

“Amazing experience!! We heard from some friends that this was the best ice cream in town and we were not disappointed! The employees were super helpful and kind and super friendly! The prices were also really good for the amount of ice cream we got?“

“An excellent place, staff are friendly and helpful. One of the best places around, and we’ll keep going back.“

“Fast, friendly service and some really darn good soft serve icecream. I love the blueberry flavored twist.“

“Very good, healthy ingredients for all types of needs. A little pricey but totally worth the money!“

“This was our first dinner at Mooyah and it did not disappoint. The staff was professional, kind, and super helpful in making recommendations. The food was cooked to order and the fries were a family favorite with the recommended cheese sauce! We will definitely be returning.“

“Thank you so much for giving me a good door dash review today for that late order. Unfortunately it started out as 19.50 and they changed it to $6. So waste of my time but I found your gem of a place. Make sure you delete this lol!! I’ll contact DoorDash tomorrow good thing they have access to my messages with customers because I had a bunch back and forth with them. They definitely got it, they were at a wedding“

“So good ? the staff was so friendly and accommodating. I requested a lot and it was close to closing time.

Very bright and clean atmosphere. Love the color and space.

The ice cream is rich and creamy. I expected to be more expensive but it was very affordable.“

“BEST. ICE CREAM. EVER! My current favorite is chocolate cake batter.“

“My daughter placed an online order and picked them up. We had a taste test of 6 and I've been hooked! Had them prior but it was one donut-looking sugar cookie. Good but not like what's in those boxes I've posted!! A must try at least once! Like..insomnia who? Crumbl is THAT cookie bakery!“

“I love coming to this place! The yogurt is really good and there's always at least one non-dairy option, which I really appreciate. The toppings bar is fantastic, with so many choices. The place is super clean and everything is always fresh. Also, the woman here is always so nice and welcoming. It's such a great spot and I highly recommend it to everyone!“

“This ice cream is so creamy and delicious. I love how they have their own little logo chocolate pieces. They put on all the cones like the cherry on top. Definitely recommend the cookie monster ice cream. You can never go wrong with something that will put a smile on your face when you see the eyes ? they put on. 10/10

Parking: Huge shopping center parking lot.

Kid-friendliness: It's one of the only places where Cookie Monster's ice cream comes alive!! Instant smiles every time.“

“One of the best for ice cream in Cleveland!!! Various flavors of chocolate chip are amazing, along with the seasonal selections!!!“

“Cake, cupcakes, and brownies are all delicious with a fun variety of flavors. Super nice and helpful staff too! Stopped in and got a cake, and they decorated it for the eclipse right then.“

“These are the best cookies I have ever had“

“we all loved the ice cream. Love the look of the place. Service was great!“

“I love it here!! There’s many different flavors to choose from and a great selection of toppings as well!! The custard cannot be beat anywhere else. It’s such a cute spot with really friendly employees and the manager Ashley was very nice. Definitely bringing my family up here soon!!“

“It’s not bad for a cookie shop. I’m glad that they finally added one in Lakewood, I don’t have to travel to Westgate now. What I like about this place is how they seem to switch up their menu every week. Regardless of what the offerings may be, the cookies always taste great, no complaints there. Friendly staff, clean store, not much else you can ask for

Parking: There’s parking on the street, but those spots might be taken. If they are taken, you can always park in the back parking lot, or on a side road“

“Just had my visit there for a breakfast sandwich and coffee! Great first impression. I'll be back during November to check out the grand piano!“

“Was there last Tuesday the employee cathy was very kind and helpful I had a broken hand she helped me out alot I was watching her work as I was waiting on my clothes she is a asset to this company hard worker and was greeting everyone thanks cathy“

“Usually go through the drive-thru. Today we decided to go inside for some ice cream and hot dogs. The happy hour and daily specials are great. We ordered a few items which were delicious. The store was nice, clean and inviting. The cashier was nice and patient during deciding what we wanted. The bathroom was a bit untidy but not filthy. We would definitely come back.“

“Stopped in for some ice cream and we had prompt service! The ice cream was exceptionally delicious!! Lots of other goodies to browse and purchase as well. The carrousel turns very slowly and was a fun way to look around the store while we sat and enjoyed our sundaes.“

“There’s no doubt that Malley’s Chocolate is the best tasting, but they are ripping off their consumers. Instead of just reducing product OR raising prices, they did both!!! For example, nut mallow is not only over $25 now, but they rounded the edges of the container so we get less. Pick one or the other, Malley’s, & stop cheating your customers!!!“

“The staff is always super friendly and sweet and kind. I love that they employ teenagers and teach them how to start in the workforce. They always have a line out the door but do such a great job handling all of the orders .

Kid-friendliness: Kids can play golf

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy drive up to store and outside dining .“