35 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bay Village

“The service was amazing, there was quite a long line but everything was still moving very quickly and, Rebecca who was the woman who took my order was very kind and made one of the best blizzards I've had! I definitely recommend coming to this location!“

“I biked 20 miles here and it was well worth it! The line was long but went quickly. The employee I interacted with was super friendly and gave me great suggestions. I ended up getting a trio “sampler” of chocolate fudge brownie, chocolate peanut butter cup and pralines & cream. All three were phenomenal and super high quality ice cream. There is plenty of seating inside and outside as well as bike racks. The building has tons of natural light and clean bathrooms. I will return!“

“One day I met a woman who was housebound. She was donating to our charity and we went to her home.
She said she dreamed of Mitchell's.
Mitchell's? What is this?
So we went and got her ice cream.
Skip forward 10 years and I chase the taste. It's like legal crack. The dark chocolate used in all of the chunk flavors is indescribable good. It melts in your mouth.
Pair the raspberry and coffee chocolate chunk for an experience.
Just be prepared for those late night cravings. It's at least a 30 minute drive for us. And it happens frequently. 🦄🍨🍦“

“The ice cream was amazing 🤩“

“In 1985 Prince wrote the song “Nothing compares 2 U.” In 1990, Sinéad O'Connor traveled to the future to party like its 1999. While visiting she tried Mitchell’s ice cream. She was so impressed that when she returned to 1990 she remade the song in Mitchell’s honor. Thank God for time travel. Jolly good show!

P.S. You should always get sprinkles“

“Vintage flavors of ice cream!!!“

“Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by a smiling staff member who guided me to the counter. However, I noticed a worker that during busy times, impatience can sometimes manifest in short responses to customers or a hurried demeanor. While she strives to maintain efficiency, her impatience can sometimes overshadow the friendly atmosphere that Fenik prides itself on.“

“I had an amazing experience with this ice cream shop! The ice cream was delicious, and the customer service was excellent. The menu had a wide variety of flavors to choose from.“

“best ice cream stand in the state of Ohio.“

“Everything is delicious, and the people serving are super friendly. Highly recommend.“

“An incident that occurred on 7/24 was greatly taken care of by Claire and her other coworker (don’t remember her name). They were both very sweet and helpful! The ice cream is also very good :) 5 stars 10/10 recommend!“

“I wish I could say I recommend this place because it was a tradition to go here at Easter time and grab chocolate crosses and bunnies. After leaving the store this weekend with such a small amount of different chocolates for 33.00 dollars I was so disappointed. I shared the photo and price with a couple friends and even they were shocked. It's really sad how extremely high a small amount is. I just wish the customer was kept in mind a little more when these prices get so hicked up. There was a second pretzel candy bar of no charge (BOGO) not pictured.“

“Very good, healthy ingredients for all types of needs. A little pricey but totally worth the money!“

“I took my kids after soccer practice and the young girls working were very polite, fast and had a smile on their face as they served us. Great customer service!“

“we all loved the ice cream. Love the look of the place. Service was great!“

“Great ice cream! Great staff!“

“Absolutely worth it! The treats are delicious and the staff are friendly, helpful, and engaging. Best addition to the neighborhood by far.“

“I love coming to this place! The yogurt is really good and there's always at least one non-dairy option, which I really appreciate. The toppings bar is fantastic, with so many choices. The place is super clean and everything is always fresh. Also, the woman here is always so nice and welcoming. It's such a great spot and I highly recommend it to everyone!“

“Mac and cheese cones with meatballs, great addition to the menu, not only ice cream cones now.“

“We had our intimate wedding ceremony and lunch at Gourmet Java Bistro 2 weeks ago. The place is very charming and the owner, Carlitta, is the nices, sweetest lady with mad cooking skills! She made our special day beautiful and really special!! ❤️“

“An excellent place, staff are friendly and helpful. One of the best places around, and we’ll keep going back.“

“BEST. ICE CREAM. EVER! My current favorite is chocolate cake batter.“

“One of the best for ice cream in Cleveland!!! Various flavors of chocolate chip are amazing, along with the seasonal selections!!!“

“Holy cow what a place!!!! The burger was soooo good, the fries were incredible, that queso they give you is so good, just incredible tasting!! The only con is the price, for a burger and then if you want to combo it for fries and a drink is almost 20 dollars 🤯!!! That was a little too much for me, but I spent it anyway cause it looked very good, and it was very good. Probably wouldn't combo it again cause it was way too expensive to combo it, but if you want to spend the big bucks you can do that.“

“love the chocolate or vanilla custard. you can see it being made while standing in line“

“First time visiting this place. Went with a friend who raved about it. Everything was good, employees were polite, no complaints from me. It's just a little pricey, but that's just my opinion. Im not mad, if you're able to have a successful business by getting people to pay $20 for 2 cookies and 2 brownies, I'm all for it. I just don't see myself going back. Again, it's not because there's any things I would say that would make someone not go, just not my kind of place. But if you're looking for a decent size cookie that's tasty and warm but don't want to bake it yourself then I'd recommend enjoying a 5 cookie lol“

“I went today and she had cherry cherry cake and it was delicious, make sure you go and get a piece.“

“These are the best cookies I have ever had“

“Was there last Tuesday the employee cathy was very kind and helpful I had a broken hand she helped me out alot I was watching her work as I was waiting on my clothes she is a asset to this company hard worker and was greeting everyone thanks cathy“

“Our five children grew up going to Dairy Treat. When they come to town, the first place they want to go is Dairy Treat. Now their children always want to go there too. Great ice cream, reasonable prices, and friendly service.“

“Tried a few pastries and a blue raspberry mojito today and everything was absolutely delicious. I will definitely be back.“

“Shout out to the staff at this DQ - these kids are awesome! Always with a smile, super patient with kids and speedy making the orders. Always a pleasure, keep up the good work!“

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.“

“Very welcoming atmosphere. They smile and greet you upon entering. You can tell that the food has more of a homemade feel to it, rather than feeling “chainy”. I waited about 10 mins, but my food came out sizzling. I would take that wait any day of the week for the food to turn out the way that it did. 10/10 experience.“

“Best chocolate in Ohio hands down. Their marshmallows are my favorite.“