17 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sheffield Lake

“Very nice owner and the ice cream was fantastic. Very clean and staff very friendly. I highly recommend.“

“I love this place!!!!!!!!“

“Best ice cream and service for miles and miles!“

“I love this place!!!!!!!!“

“Mitchell's has garnered a cult following in the Cleveland area, and visiting their Avon location showed that off well. My wife and I stopped on a Sunday night while on a mini vacation and staying at the Wyndham hotel that is within walking distance. Even though we arrived in the 9 o'clock hour, the location was jam packed, both with customers in line and those sitting both inside the contemporary dining area and outside on the plesant porch area. But even though it was very busy the entire time we were there, the staff was super swift and friendly, making the wait times negligible.

I ordered the seasonal Campfire S'mores flavor and found it to be very good, with nice sized chunks of classic s'mores toppings and creamy and smooth ice cream that was rich and flavorful, but pleasantly not as heavy as other premium ice cream. My wife got the lavender and honey flavor, and really enjoyed the strong flavors of each part. Overall, there's a a reason Mitchell's has the kind of area support it does, and why thus particular location is such a community hotbed, especially on warm summer nights.“

“Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by a smiling staff member who guided me to the counter. However, I noticed a worker that during busy times, impatience can sometimes manifest in short responses to customers or a hurried demeanor. While she strives to maintain efficiency, her impatience can sometimes overshadow the friendly atmosphere that Fenik prides itself on.“

“LOVE dairy grove!!! Our go-to spot for sweet treats in the summer! My kids love the play ground and I love the options of both hard scoop (my favorite brand btw) or soft serve. I’m not usually a fan of soft serve in general, but definitely like their version and find myself getting their awesome specialty sundaes! Strawberry pretzel crunch is so good!! I also love their slushie and their creative team making lots of fun treats!! I’m going to have to stock up on their hard scoop ice cream for the winter!!“

“I took my son here and he loved it. He ordered a 3 mini pack which included a lemon, chocolate strawberry, & chocolate chip cookie (his choice from their selection). They have a spot where you can walk up and order or a self serve machine right inside the door.
He loved the lemon the most and is his personal recommendation.
The employees appeared very happy to be there which is always pleasant.
The atmosphere was cute and my goodness it smelled phenomenal <3

Kid-friendliness: They were so sweet and showed him his cookies before boxing them up to ensure he loved them.“

“BEST. ICE CREAM. EVER! My current favorite is chocolate cake batter.“

“So worth it, twist n shake is absolutely delicious. 10/10 would recommend“

“This ice-cream is one that I'll always scream for! It tastes delicious, it's near the schools so parents and kids can grab some ice cream, and it's right across from Hot Dog Heaven, just in case it's closed, which it usually is during the winter. (Hot Dog Heaven serves ice-cream, don't worry)

Parking: The parking is small, I'll be the first to admit that, but it's usually not that full unless it's a busy day, which it usually isn't.“

“These are the best cookies I have ever had“

“Big V's Ice Cream is an absolute delight! From the first taste to the last lick, every scoop is a burst of flavor and nostalgia. The atmosphere is cheerful, the service is top-notch, and the ice cream? Simply divine. Whether you're indulging in a classic cone or a towering sundae, Big V's never fails to deliver a sweet escape from reality. A must-visit destination for any ice cream enthusiast!“

“Great food. Great atmosphere. Great service. This place is hard to beat. Family dining atmosphere but the food is really great! Awesome menu with things you won't find anywhere else. Attached ice cream parlor is also a big hit with the kids!“

“Our five children grew up going to Dairy Treat. When they come to town, the first place they want to go is Dairy Treat. Now their children always want to go there too. Great ice cream, reasonable prices, and friendly service.“

“The Dairy Queen in Avon Lake has the best workers and ice cream treats. Thanks for helping me out Addy and Melanie!“

“Might just be one of the best burgers from a fast food joint that I have ever eaten. The Pretzel Bits were almost as good as the burger. I could eat those all day long. Service was very good and the tables were clean.
I highly recommend Culver's for my overall positive experience and a sublime burger! Will definitely be back.
5 Stars.“