50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“A salted bottom pizza?!?! Whaaat? I was not expecting that and I could maybe best describe it as tasting like a soft pretzel. Which is def the highlight of the order. The jalapeno bread I wouldn't get again.. thick white bread sticks with nacho cheese pales to, or heightens perhaps, the pizza experience. We'd come back and tell our friends, it's worth the uniqueness and ooak bite, thanks Cassano!“

“5 Stars is not enough. Hubby and I stopped in for our first visit and he grew up Italian ~ homemade everything. Sub was filled with meats, mozzarella sticks were perfect and the pizza was awesome. The dough is fabulous, so much taste. Husband felt like he was back home. Cannoli was so tasty. We will definitely be back. Great food, priced fairly and the owners service exceeded our expectations! Thank you for a great meal!!!“

“Wonder pizza very polite and knowledgeable. Staff felt like at home environment will definitely be coming back.“

“Always yummy pizza and great service! 🍕“

“Very good, crispy crust, those awesome pepperoni that curl up with grease in the middle, plus the sauce and cheese! We will be back! Thank you Clown for the recommendation!!“

“I live out of town, now in NC. I grew up in Germantown OH and was brought up on Don and Ron's Pizza. Hands down it's the best place to gather with old friends and family, great atmosphere, fabulous food and attentive service. Not only is the pizza the best, their hot Italian sub and mushroom steak sandwich is great too and don't get me started on their Reuben!! Oh did I forget to mention salads, yeah they exceed at that too. Huge salads, big enough to share (if you want, that is.) Yes, Don's is A #1 in this gal book. I take a family size pizza, a steak sandwich and sub frozen home with me every time I'm in for a visit. That way later when the mood strikes I have a little take of home when I want it. You won't regret stopping by and eating there.“

“Hubby & I just had lunch here a bit ago. We've never eaten here before. We shared a steak hoagie with onions, mushrooms, pickles and cheese. We got the parmesan bites and an order of fries. Absolutely delicious food! We had water to drink so our bill was only $21. Delicious food at a reasonable price! I highly recommend Richards“

“My food is always hot & delicious“

“Love this place! Food is great and the service is even better. Our pizza was caught in the oven making a few slices damaged, the manager brought out the pizza so we didn’t have to wait longer to eat but also made a smaller pizza to compensate for the damage. The service is top level here!“

“Great people with creative and delicious eats. 100% would recommend the Spicy Honey Pepperoni pizza spicy yet sweet. Or the unique and rare Cincinnati Style Chili pizza, a delicious balance of cheddar cheese, chili, and onions.“

“Friendly staff, nice environment, pizza, sandwiches, pasta, salads, spirits + gluten free options. This post is from a west coaster who would visit this establishment again. 5 pizza's & two salads fed 12 adults, Marion Deluxe and Marions Super Cheese were great choices with the normal pepperoni pizza & Cheese pizza - 4 kids, only $108.00

Vegetarian options: Limited with vegetarian pizza and salads, but I'm sure make your own vegetarian pizza and or salad would work“

“Saturday was my first experience at A&G. The pizza was freaking amazing. Crisp, light and just done right delicious. I will definitely be coming back. And I will also be recommending to everyone I know.“

“Hunter's Pizza is the best around! Sad to see this place closed! Going to miss the guys that work there! We ate here almost every Sunday after church! You guys were our favorite place to go! Skylar is going to miss her peperoni pizza! Praying for you guys!“

“Best pizza ? ever Best Italian food ever“

“The best place in the world. My local favorite.My favorite is probably the wings and the pasta, but I liked all of it. from Hadley, 10 years old“

“Guys let me just say this place is legit hands down one of the best restaurants I have been to in a very long time, the food was on point very large portions reasonable prices the staff was amazing very friendly and pleasant atmosphere I most definitely will be back for a different item off the menu (I had a delicious deluxe calzone) brought 1/2 home 🤤🤤🤤“

“Last month, Shaddocks enter the MIDDLETOWN’s FOPA PIZZA SHOWDOWN. We want to share just some of the judge’s notes on the competition. QUALITY: Genuinely good ingredients, textured to tease the tongue and sooth the appetite. APPEARANCE: Hidden within, is a tasty, hardy portion of deliciousness. Looks like a pie, but tastes like an amazing pizza. SAUCE: A mixture of savory and sweet. A uniquely flavored twist. TASTE: Sweet N’ Savory, hardy and delightfully flavorful. A burst of tantalizing goodness you can’t get enough of.“

“loved the old style pepperoni thin crust pizza“

“I absolutely love Miamisburg Pizza Hut. I eat food from this location several days throughout the week on my lunch breaks. The General Manager, Adrianna and staff members Timmy and Matt, are always very friendly to me and treat me like royalty every time I call, place an order and carry-out from the Miamisburg location. All of the staff members at the Miamisburg Pizza Hut are fantastic at their job as well, even when they are extremely busy. Thanks Miamisburg Pizza Hut for delivering great customer service and for being one of the best in the business!“

“Best pizza store ever. Not only do you have a very awesome staff, you guys always seem to deliver HOT food each time.“

“My friend and I stopped in about 8p. The place was fairly busy which is a good sign to me. The gal at the counter was quietly efficient as she took our order. Our breadsticks were delivered in just a few minutes. They were really good. Accompanied by both cheese and pizza sauce they were soft and delicious. The pizza came out in about 10 minutes. It’s been 30 years since I’ve had Godfathers pizza. I can say it really was delicious. I wish I lived closer so I could enjoy this pizza more often.“

“Love the newly remodeled Verity Pkwy location. It looks much more inviting and clean inside. The bathroom was clean as well. The food was delish! I love the Vic's Big Cheese with green olives. It is the best! The staff was super nice and helpful, which made our visit more pleasant. I do also like the new drive thru. It is so convenient.

Parking: Parking is limited and a bit awkward.“

“What a great find! We went for the first time because I was craving spaghetti. It was nice out, so we sat at one of the tables outside. The owner came out to check on us. Super nice guy! Everything we had was delicious. Next time we’ll be ordering pizza!“

“We had the best pizza tonight from you guys. It was hot, delicious and perfectly prepared. Thanks for making a quality pizza❤️🍕“

“crust was awesome! a little salty lime Cassanos“

“Rapid Fires Pizza on Miamisburg Centerville Rd. is a must-try for any pizza lover! The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, and they were happy to answer all of my questions about the menu. I opted for the Hog Heaven pizza, and it was absolutely amazing. It was like a meat lover’s pizza on steroids, loaded with all of my favorite toppings. The crust was perfectly cooked, and the sauce was flavorful and delicious. I will definitely be back to try more of their pizzas soon! #pizza #pizzalover #pizzalovers“

“We've never been here, and we called in our order. They have amazing customer service. The deep dish pizza is delicious! The cheese, sauce and crust is perfect! Most pizza places have to much sugar in the sauce this place is just right! We will definitely make this place #1 at our home. Thank you ❤️“

“open late. friendly and good food. 😋“

“We've gotten pizza here before and it was delicious and substantial. This pizza was just simply okay. We ordered some cheesy bread and it was just like a pizza without the sauce. It was kind of odd. It tasted good but it didn't have much substance. I was disappointed in the pizza but I will try it again since it's been so good in the past. I gave the atmosphere 4 stars because it's nothing fancy to eat in - not much environment. It feels like just a carry out place.“

“I am a wedding officiant so I am the only person at a wedding that is legally required to know what is going on. Do you know how many weddings I go to and the bread is cold???? Seriously, people pay a ton of money for catered weddings with cold bread. With these guys, the food is always hot and fresh. And I LOVE their grilled veggies. They are one of the few caterers I will stick around after the ceremony for.“

“ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.“

“Best pizza ever hell yeah woooo, i loved how saucy and cheesy my pizza was, it was perfect, and they have a super hot little brunette who helped me at the counter, i mean smokin. But she knew Web i was thirsty and asked if i wanted a coke. Yes please furture bm“

“The pizza is good but every time I order extra cheese there’s hardly ever any cheese on there and there are dry bubbles on top I hate that“

“The gentleman working told me that they are undergoing a name change.. While they do still serve pizza there’s much more being cooked here.. I had 2 gyros with Mediterranean style fries my niece had three pieces of pizza.. Needless to say we left with nothing on our plate!!! Impeccable taste, fast and friendly service by an experienced cook and server in one… I recommend this place y’all“

“For the average person who the stuff below this paragraph may make no sense to, it's actually a really good place and they're trying hard to do good they just need a little love.

4* only because product quality could have been a little better. Placement of toppings looked like they could have just been drop and go on one pizza and the other was a bit dump and go as well. A little product training could go a long way at this store. That being said I got carside and the employee was friendly and I could see it looked like the hustle was there with the whole crew in store.“

“Wow! Froggy's really stepped it up with the new menu. We had the
Bourbon Salmon and the Pork Ragu Lasagna. They both were to die for. Please check it out and tell your friends. Also Chef makes sure you are taking care of as well as the staff. Good job Froggy's!“

“This evening around 7:00 my wife and I dined at your establishment. Everything was outstanding! My reason for this review is additionally thank someone I may never know. My wife and I shared a booth, she is an Alzheimer’s patient and also has a broken wrist. I sat on the same side of the booth as her and fed her as we engaged in conversation and enjoyed our meal. I removed her hair from her face and wiped her mouth as we dined. When it was time to go we were informed that another patron had paid for our meal and wished us a wonderful evening. To this wonderful, generous soul I want to extend our gratitude and pray that you receive the love, support and graciousness that you afford us. You will never know how heartfelt and appreciated you are. Yes, tears were flowing from my eyes- but I can only hope somehow someone else knows how kind, giving and loving you are to people you don’t even know! God bless and send you tenfold the love and kindness you have shown?To all the staff, blessings to you all!“

“This has become a regular place to go. Large selection of draft craft beers. Great pizza.

Update: still love this place. The guy providing the music tonight had stolen my playlist. Queen, Prince, Tom Petty, CCR and Stevie Wonder. Very cool.“

“The past couple times weve got pizza there at the Miamisburg location on Central, it has been really good! way better than in the past. Keep it up!😘🍕❤“

“Edi Mae approved ✅ Only complaint is the cashier was very rude and acted like we were stupid because we had questions. Can’t remember her name but she had short blonde hair.“

“The owners of this place have regular jobs on-top of running the store, it has came along way since the opened it, the bad reviews folks posted were that they had limited stock, they will order your brand of beer or smokes if you ask, remember they are not Walmart and they pay for all the merchandise in advance, if you haven't stopped by for a while check it out now.“

“We occasionally stop by after our fraternity meetings. We’ve always enjoyed excellent food and service. Nice calm atmosphere anytime we’ve visited.

Parking: Street parking. Farmersville is a safe rural community.

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp.“

“The Santa Fe pizza was great, however it took a considerable longer time at this location to get our order. Also observed an employee who was answering the phone and making pizzas without wearing gloves or sanitizing hands in between 😞.“

“My husband swears this is the best pizza. He is from Ohio and worked there as a teen. I ordered these for our 26th anniversary! To say he was shocked is an understatement! They were delicious!“

“We have had one of the best pizza nights in a long time! Great friendly staff and pizza! Good job guys!“

“To the lady that delivered my pizza with the mario hat... thank you so much! You really made my day. She was the sweetest person I've had the honor of meeting from this location. Give that girl a raise!!“

“awesome pizza, great food and great ice cream too!! highly recommended“

“Honest review. I had both my grandkids birthday party there tonight. The kids had a blast and that was my main goal however it could have been way better organized or better yet I coulda bought a smaller package . The kids had unlimited play for 2 hours now in that 2 hours you also do the pizza , cake and singing with Chuck Ev. It was very crowded and live with Chuck E was about half way through the party and they let you know 6 minutes before he comes out. Trying to round up kids in an arcade full of kids in 5 minutes ain’t easy. So he comes out and danced for about 5 minutes then they rush him away with kids in back never getting to hug him. Then he comes back out a little later this was a 3 minute count down. So my grandson didn’t get to her his name announced in the birthdays because he didn’t get back across the room in time. The cake was brought out around 7 at 7:15 we were told we had 15 minutes to move ( 15 minutes after she cut the cake. ) ice cream for kids was to be included but we never received. Most employees didn’t seem like working with children was their favorite thing to do. So I recommend the place as a great place for kids to have fun safety ( the stamps on the hands was nice feeling) but I wouldn’t recommend party area . Buy a hour unlimited pass or longer and have cake and ice cream and presents at home. You don’t get everything promised, the scheduling of everything makes it stressful and they only get about a hour play time in all anyway. I don’t see no stars to give but it would be 0 for party 3 for friendly ( lost 2 because most staff seemed to hate the job)“

“IF YOU HAVEN'T BEEN YOUR MISSING OUT I GOT THE STEAK POTATO BOWL AND NACHOS DELICIOUS WHEN YOU HOME AND ORDERED OUT BUT YOU CAN'T TELL HOME COOKED FOOD IJS IT'S DELICIOUS SUGGEST HEAD THAT WAY. 😋😊🥔 THANKS!“