26 Best Sandwich Shops near Carlisle

“I’ve had some really good ordering experiences here. They are located down the road from me and the service is exceptional. I got a salad today that was chicken teriyaki. It was 9.99. The salad is a good size and the overall taste was great! I definitely recommend this place to friends and family in my life!“

“Ordered a gluten free sub and watched them wipe down the area, switch gloves and knifes, before they even started making the sub! It really made my day to have the employees take the extra steps without me even asking, to help make my food safely!“

“First time being at Jersey Mike’s and I got the chipotle Philly steak sub I believe I’m saying it right it was absolutely amazingly delicious 😋 I would definitely recommend to anyone the best sub around. The best sub I’ve ever had.“

“Just want to say that I go to several different jersey mikes religiously throughout the month, and this location is the best one by far. My food was made accordingly, and deliciously. The bread was so soft. And the staff were so polite. This location specifically is my favorite now. So thank you to all of the staff there!“

“Fantastic Reuben's. Great sides!“

“I love the food at Jersey Mike's. No matter the location food is always top quality. The store itself is clean and well-maintained. My wait wasn't too long so that was great. The two problems with this specific location are: the staff and handling of foods with allergies. I'm giving grace on these things because most of the workers were young and it seems liked the one guy was new. They were very loudly talking about various places they vacationed while also helping customers. Not a huge issue for me, but you could tell they were distracted by trying to carry the conversation on and help customers. As for my allergy, they handled it like every other shop - wiped down the machine and the areas around the line, they also put my bread on a different paper, and changed gloves. Where the issue happened was that the newer guy used the mayo that was on the line, which the knife was on non-gluten bread so cross contamination happened. This is just a good relearning moment on allergies for your staff. Every other Jersey Mike's uses the squeeze bottles for allergies. Not sure if this was just a new person who didn't know, but nobody else guided him to do anything differently.“

“This was the best Jersey Mike’s I have ever been. From Michigan and here for a soccer tournament. Super clean. Everything was so fresh. The employees were great. The manager was training some new employees and talked to them with such respect. When the restaurant wasn’t busy everyone had tasks to do to get ready for the next rush. No one seen standing around on their phones. I even commented on it before leaving. Sometimes we all need to hear the good things and not just complain. Keep up the good work!“

“I love the Godfather’s sub cold but today it fell short of the standard. I ordered as usual with light mayo and oil. It came with mustard and no oil, also quantity of lettuce and tomato were light. Disappointed mustard ruined it!“

“Service is always great at this location. I rarely eat Penn Station because everytime I do, I'm disappointed. Only ate here today because We was kind of in a rush (quick lunch break). I swear Penn Station puts the least amount of Meat on Their Cheesesteaks out of everyone. And always so dry.
Service was great, Food was average I guess and atmosphere is ok. It was $11.09 for a regular cheese steak and a water. And like I said, the Regular Cheese Steak is VERY VERY light on the meat😞“

“Fantastic Reuben's. Great sides!“

“I felt the desperate need to come on here and make a comment about my food. It was PHENOMENAL. I have never tasted any sandwich in my life as delectable as this one; hot ham swiss and cheese with mayo. It was juicy, fresh, hot, and don't get me started on the fries, fresh as always and seasoned perfectly. When I took my first bite o was in shambles, hitting the table and tapping my toe in delight. Continue to keep this place busy and open cuz it was absolutely breathtaking.?“

“whoevers running this place clearly knows what they're doing. the people who served me tonight were all friendly and (who i'm assuming was) the manager was so efficient and positive throughout the entire busy rush. keep slaying penn station“

“This is the Subway located in downtown Franklin, OH. Everyone is always friendly and work hard to meet the demand of midsize and even large groups. The only drawback for these type groups is lack of available parking. The crew does a great job, though and the food is always good.“

“The staff at this location are the BEST!! Work up the street so we do lunch here often, I live in Kettering area around 3 other Subways but I come to Miamisburg store because I know customer service and food will be great!! Keep it up, ladies!!“

“Stopped here for lunch today. Everyone working was friendly. My food came quick and the restaurant was clean. One of the workers even went out of their way to make sure our family was taken care of. The bathrooms were clean as well. I will definitely be back to this location.“

“I absolutely love Super Subby's and this location has quickly become my favorite. Real nice and polite employees. Conveniently located on the way to a Flyers game. Looking forward to many more subs with kids eat free before seeing great basketball 🏀;)“

“This location made my sandwiche great. I came hear for lunch I called my order in and it took a Lil longer but they were busy with the lunch rush that's why I called it in. I love the chicken cordon bleu an the Philly steak with pizza sauce“

“The Springboro, OH Jimmy John's is 'Deaf Friendly.' I ordered lunch using paper and pencil and the cashier gestured to an item on the menu to clarify. He communicated everything (i.e. credit card, where to pick up) with gestures. I love it when I meet people who 'go with it' and try their best to communicate even if they don't know sign. You make the world a better place. :)“

“This is either a hit or miss, no in between. They absolutely never give me my double chocolate chip cookies, and they never call me to tell me they ran out. The give me some nasty oatmeal crap substitute and that's just not acceptable.“

“I love this place! They have high class dishes, their menu is nice, The cook in that restaurant is very trained, I like a lot eating all their dishes. The food is always tasty, the attitude towards the guests is friendly. I often eat in this place and I not even once was disappointed. Highly recommended.“

“I was at your Germamtown Pike location at 5:30.this evening 11/11/25. The two young employees were absolutely fabulous. They greeted me with tremendous respect and kindness. This is the third time I have had the pleasure of these two serving me. I appreciate how they carried themselves.“

“Subby’s in Springboro has the best subs! Amazing food all around. I also want to give a very big thank you to one of the employees, I did not catch her name though. I spilled my drink on the table as I was leaving and she came out helped me clean up, and was so kind and sweet about it. I will be a returning customer for the food and the service.“

“We love having delicious place in Monroe. Yum!! I never get enough Jimmy John's!“

“Gas was about 10 cents more expensive at the station than other nearby locations, but that's the price you have to pay for getting a Subway sub.Service was fast, and the associate was friendly.Place was clean overall.Meatball sub sandwich was tasty.Go into the gas station next door for a much better drink selection (like a blue raspberry slush).Recommended.“

“My Sub Artist Rico was amazing he remembered what I ordered last time and he has only built my sub one other visit. Rico was very nice and washed hands before and after and after my cash transaction. Definitely management material with just a little grooming on technical business practices. Thank You for a great dinner“

“We have come to love Penn station subs this is our closest location so obviously our most visited. Never have we been disappointed, maybe wondered why this time the mayo is in excess or is there hardly any lettuce etc.. consistency could be worked in. Sammich are always good and craveable enough to be back. Like that we can order in a salad to help with keto meals when that’s our goal.
They are always busy and perhaps that’s the why consistency lacks from time to time.“