48 Best American Restaurants near Carroll

“Fillin' Station in Carroll is the kind of place you walk into as a stranger and leave feeling like family. Burgers and steaks? Absolutely fantastic and priced just right. The beer is always cold, the staff is fun and accommodating, and their nightly entertainment—like Cowboy Karaoke and Music Bingo—always keeps things lively. We host an annual wing night on our patio and always order wings from Fillin’ Station—they’re always cooked to perfection and get rave reviews from everyone. This is the ultimate neighborhood spot. Can’t recommend it enough!“

“The Fish & Chips are amazing, and some of the best Cole Slaw in the business! Also really great breakfast offerings!“

“First time I was actually served hot food in a restaurant. Will be back!!!“

“A wonderful experience last night for my 40th birthday. There is something for everyone with ton of flavor and the staff is top notice!! I recommend the Mac and cheese appetizer and of course their 3 sliders with KILLER🔥 fries. We will definitely be back soon!“

“These girls have done an awesome job! The food service and atmosphere is amazing!! We will be back“

“Great service, food was delicious. My new favorite jerk restaurant.“

“My family and I got a pep and cheese pizza and the sausage potato soup. The food was really good ! I drove about 20 mins home and the food was still hot. As soon as I walked over to the bar I was assisted. The wait for the food wasn’t long at all. . The lady that helped me was nice. Very clean.“

“I had the honor of being a participant at the Fall Health Fest today, proudly representing Sunrise Recovery, put on by the health department at the Lancaster Camp Grounds. It was an amazing day with perfect weather. I only wish the turn out would have been better!“

“Wonderful service- good food!“

“The food was delicious and the staff where on it Way better food than roosters 🐔“

“went to Harvest Moon Craft Kitchen expecting a good meal and left wondering if I should start a fan club.

Everything was fantastic… from the food to the atmosphere to the service. Every bite was one of those “you have to try this” moments that turns into everyone at the table stealing food from each other’s plates. The drinks were great“

“We had a rehearsal dinner at El Parian Steaks & Tequila. They have a back room that seats up to 60 people. They were absolutely wonderful to work with, reasonable in price, and very accommodating. They gave us the option to pick 4 menu items off the menu for our guests to choose from or the options of - taco, fajita, or nacho bar. We chose the fajita and nacho bar. The food was hot and ready when we arrived. The guacamole here tastes so good! They even packed up the leftover food for us! Their staff were very attentive and kind. We will definitely recommend them to others. Wonderful job! 👏👏👏“

“The food is beautifully presented, delicious, helpings are plentiful! Service was excellent! Atmosphere: cozy-warm relaxed, neighborly , friendly, and pleasant! Decor: Fun, historically accurate photos… etc. A must on your list of restaurant pubs…“

“I have celiac disease and have hard a time finding food that isn’t contaminated, especially pizza. The staff reassured me that they checked with kitchen multiple times to make sure nothing was being contaminated. It was by far the most delicious gluten free pizza I’ve had so far !“

“Had a family Christmas get together (party of 8) Tuesday Dec 23 at Max and Ermas Lancaster. I want to say my food was great as were the kids meals and my wife seemed to enjoy her Great American Burger! The complaints I had were less about the food but rather the attentiveness in the service. We left what was over $20 tip on a $102 ticket so the waitress was more than compensated. My mom was a waitress most of her life and so our family has always tipped. Service would have to be nonexistent for us to no tip but many would have said the kind of service received during this visit was no where near a $20 tip. At no point were we ever preemptively asked for drink refills. Max and Ermas now has fry refills much like Red Robin but again at no time were we ever asked for such. We did get asked when the food was brought out if we needed anything else but at NO point did a manager or staff member ask how the food was or check in from a customer service perspective. The ticket could have easily earned another $15-$20 higher even with suggestions of ice cream for the kids or appetizers. I wanted to share this because as stated while from a food taste perspective most of our food was terrific (The Larado Steak was way too tough) the quality of service would probably make me think about a visit again soon!“

“Who knew O'Chsrley was cajun..lol, had shrimp and grits!! It was cajun restaurant delicious, and apple pie with a gallop of vanilla ice cream-- once I took off the sugar laden crust, sooo glad I had room for 🍨--my waitress brought me some pecans because apple pie MUST have walnuts..lol..but they only had pecans-- situation was sooo sweet of her. I can't remember when visited an O'Charley's..I think it was the one on the Nirthside which is now clised--i will definitely return to this Reynoldsburg location“

“Alyssa was our server and she was great! Atmosphere was also nice. We ordered cocktails, the french onion soup, a side salad with blue cheese dressing, Prime Rib with creamy horseradish sauce, and Chicken Varenna. The cocktails were great. The soup was delicious and by far the best thing we had. I would go here again just for the soup if nothing else! Yes, it was that good. The blue cheese dressing on the side salad was also homemade and excellent. Not all blue cheese dressings are created equal. The prime rib was fine but not good enough when you consider the cost. The creamy horseradish was wonderful, but overall we would not order that meal again. The chicken varenna tasted ok, but was extremely dry and the pasta was overcooked. To be fair, unless I get homemade pasta served al dente, it is hard to please me when it comes to pasta taste/texture. I am a pasta snob, admittedly. I was very disappointed with the chicken varenna because I had seen several reviews raving about the meal online (which is why I ordered it). We ended with 2 Ale House coffees (also very good). Other meals coming out on trays around us looked much better than what we ordered. There was definitely enough good here to go and give it another shot. Maybe we just ordered the wrong dinners.“

“Food is always delicious, staff is friendly and quick and the atmosphere is relaxing…and let’s not forget those biscuits 😍“

“tried this today! a PERFECT way to end a birthday trip! so good. we'll definitely be coming back“

“Ribs were hot and delicious, smothered chicken was cold and dry. peighton the waitress wasn't impressive. She didn't bring our appetizer until after our meal arrived. She checked on the table next to ours 3 times and refilled their drinks before she got to ours. No veterans discount even though I wore a vet hat and Army polo shirt. poor. just poor this time. usually very good.“

“Do not miss this hidden gem! The food is so good and they’re very accommodating to vegetarians. The staff was so nice and sweet too! Soooo excited to finally find omurice in Ohio!!“

“A great place with good food and good people. I try to swing through anytime I'm in the area for work. The staff and locals all make you feel like one of them. Highly recommend!“

“One of my favorite spots!“

“Great lunch spot- really reasonably priced, friendly service and great food! I’m glad we stopped in to try it“

“JUST AMAZING SERVICE ALL AROUND ❣️❣️❣️HEATHER WAS AMAZING ❣️❣️❣️🔥🔥🔥“

“I got fried shrimp..fried oysters s and coleslaw..everything was awesome..“

“Wait staff was phenomenal! Food was excellent for price point. Ordered BLT, wings, dumpster fries, nachos, white pizza... it was all good! The only thing that brought the experience down a notch was the ungodly noise level. It is so noisy in there you can barely hear your dining partner(s) speak.“

“great divee bar. server was friendly and taking care of everyone all by herself in the front if the house. great wings. but I had the nachos and they were the best I ever had. seriously they fry their own tortilla chips and they are awesome.“

“Went there for the first time today the biscuits and gravy was very delicious and our waitress was very nice and good super friendly place I’ll go back there“

“My boyfriend and I went up over the weekend and they were packed! We had to wait for them to clean a table but we didn’t mind. Food came out so fast we couldn’t believe it since they were so busy. We will definitely be back! Sad it took us so long to find this hidden gem.“

“Had a wonderful experience at LongHorn Steakhouse! Our server, Lauren V., was exceptional—kind, attentive, and very professional. I was amazed to learn it was her first day on the floor. She did an outstanding job! My daughter and I truly appreciated her service and made sure to tip her well. Five stars all the way!“

“Always great service and friendly. Mark, Brandi, Diane, Eric, Heather are my wonderful food friends and are the best servers and bussers, appreciate you all! 5 STARS AND,,, please try the Hash and Eggs with a English muffin!! The sausage links are the best in the nation!!! Keep up the fantastic service!!!“

“David was the best person there“

“Visiting a friend in Baltimore, she recommended Farmhouse and I’m so glad she did! Everything was absolutely delicious. The salad was fresh and flavorful, and the fries were hands down the best I’ve ever had. What made it even better was the people working there were so kind and welcoming, which made the whole experience even more special. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!“

“great service great food. Atmosphere is all good. went for Lunch today With my best friend she said This place was good and I needed to try. so my Friend Michelle of M&M Diner Of Logan, Ohio. Took me here today. and she was Right. it was great Sandwich grilled chicken with lettuce Tomato and Onion and pickles. it was fresh and delicious and the Fries was made with fresh potatoes cut into fries. I Highly recommend This Place. had a Great Time. also special Thanks to the 2 girls who served us, you made it very pleasant. we enjoyed your Hospitality. and friendly Service and Smiles.“

“We ventured here tonight for the first time. Wanted a quick bite before going to the Pickerington North band competition to watch our son. Food was excellent! Our server was Steph and she was friendly, diligent, and did everything very well. I loved the ambiance of the place!! I’ve always heard of people going to this place, super happy I got to try it out!“

“One negative I have is when a customer orders something and it’s not done and when you say something to the employee they just the eyes they should make it right who wants to eat cold food“

“Extremely funny waitress Christiana. You can't train her personality. Very pleasing and enjoyable. Will visit again.“

“This place is a true hidden gem! The atmosphere was cozy but casual. We were in the mood for this kind of cuisine and they didn’t disappoint! Service was friendly, food was plenty and came out fast hot and exactly as described on the menu. For two people we had plenty and brought some home and we are big eaters. The pricing is fantastic too. Go, you won’t be disappointed!!“

“Omgoodness! I totally recommend this location! Server and manager were amazing! We got our food quick and it was so delicious! Not one complaint amongst us 4 people. Hard to find great service and high quality food at a restaurant these days! We are usually disappointed, but this experience gave me hope that there's still good quality workers out there that take pride in what they do! They also sang, Happy Birthday to our daughter who just turned 7.“

“The visit to this location was Absolutely Amazing today. Angela the server was so sweet and took such good care of us at the table. This was actually the best food I've ever eaten from a Bob Evans! We had to meet the cook! Her name was Jackie and this sweet girl can cook!!! Seriously give these ladies a raise before someone else snatches them up. Just an amazing experience. Thank you both tremendously!!“

“The quality of our local steak and shakes have significantly improved along with the staff. Much cleaner, tastes better, and even seems more filling than it used to. On top of that the new company policies like banning microwaves, beef tallow for their fried goods, and grass fed beef for the burgers. It went downhill a while ago but I can definitely say it has done a complete 360 and has honestly been one of our families favorite quick fast food locations now. Definitely better than McDonald's.“

“I recommend the waitress Monica Barrera at the IHOP in Panorama City Calif as she gives such great and wonderful service. She asks if everything is ok and always comes back to give refills. This is much appreciated. Best wishes from the original Johnny Blaze, and "may the Blaze be with you."“

“Service and food was outstanding.“

“The quality of our local steak and shakes have significantly improved along with the staff. Much cleaner, tastes better, and even seems more filling than it used to. On top of that the new company policies like banning microwaves, beef tallow for their fried goods, and grass fed beef for the burgers. It went downhill a while ago but I can definitely say it has done a complete 360 and has honestly been one of our families favorite quick fast food locations now. Definitely better than McDonald's.“

“Great waitresses n very friendly. Always on top of ur orders n asking if there’s anything u need.“

“Always look forward to the nice people with great food & service“

“we entered the bob Evans and approached the host and requested a table of three the young man was very polite and clearly had some type of a disability and needed help at the podium multiple times he went and spoke with his manager and all he would tell him is people needed to wait instead of overwhelming this young man with frustrated customers the manager should have stepped in to help assist I was very disappointed with the management and staff leaving the poor host out to dry and had we got any attention at all from anyone besides the host I would have let them know how disgusting I thought it was needless to say after about 20 minutes and a waiting room full of people we decided to head to another place to eat as a crowded room and a rowdy toddler don't mesh well only certain tables are open to be seated in and staff seems like they are falling apart it's disappointing and not at all what it used to be“