7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Circleville

“great, affordable pizza. Chillicothe needed a new place the ones we have now have been underperforming.“

“Great pizza great staff great owners!!! Love this place!!“

“Love the BLT always, Just recently discovered the Hawaiian pizza is just as good!!“

“Listen, the pizza is very good, so I can’t give lower than 4 stars. And I know why some pizza places do this but they put the pepperoni UNDER the cheese. Yes, it’s supposed to make the sauce taste better but the difference is hardly noticeable and nobody appreciates the subtle difference because it’s…. Subtle… and we are just hungry, not pizza sauce connoisseurs.I bought a pepperoni pizza because one person likes pepperoni but the three including me who normally pick it off couldn’t. So they ate something else.I won’t be going back for this one reason.I’d also like to add… the crispy edges of the pepperoni that is put on top of the cheese is 10000x better than any advantage cooking it under the cheese gives. Not a good trade off if you ask me.At the very least if you’re going to run a pizza place and go with the bad and unpopular decision to place the pepperoni under the cheese, put a note/warning so people who are expecting to pick off the pepperoni aren’t screwed when the food gets home.“

“I ordered two pizzas from the Circleville, Ohio location because my husband and I have 4 kids- when the pizza is delivered the cheese pizza has been dropped and half of it is missing from the box and the other pizza is soggy and tastes awful. I usually love Donatos but this is ridiculous..I called for a refund, the manager said they don't do refunds and offered to trade out the dropped pizza- that I didn't even realize yet was half missing- within half an hour. We decided on an account credit, but again, this is before I realized we were missing literally half of a pizza. Getting him to agree to the credit was almost like pulling teeth. I tried to salvage the cheese pizza for my kids and that's when I realized we were missing half of it, so I called back to give the manager a heads up that someone is dropping pizzas and removing half of them. He said "I've never heard of that before," I said "Well I've never seen it before." I'm not ordering from this Donatos anymore - I was happy with the credit until I realized I'm not going to be able to use it.“

“I love this location. I usually pick up pizzas early in the morning since I work the third shift. The presumed manager remembers frequent customers, and my pizzas are always perfect, I place my orders online, and he knows it's mine as I pull up. Never had an issue here, amazing service and great quality.“

“This is our sister church on our district. This church held our NMI (Missions) and NYI (Youth) Convention. A large church w school program. Congregation is warm n giving. The parking lot is huge, handicapped parking n wheelchair accessibility.“