23 Best American Restaurants in Hilliard

“We had a large event of more than 40 people on Saturday 8/16/25 and couldn’t have been happier. The kitchen manager came out when we arrived and clarified everything with us, they were careful to label the gluten free products and our servers, Ashley and Chloe were so attentive. The food was incredible, as it always is! They went above and beyond to make our event perfect! Thank you and we’re looking forward to hosting there again next year!“

“What a wonderful way to start our day - breakfast here as first time visitors from out of town. A few interesting breakfast dishes (I had the Greek omelet), efficiently prepared by courteous & professional staff. The place was packed, but the waitress served us with aplomb.“

“My husband and I went there on a whim because it was near our hotel. We are so glad we did! I had the bbq wings (which were done perfectly, which can be hard because I am very picky about my wings), and my husband said it was one of the best burgers he has ever had! Our bartender Danielle was very personable and helpful with everything! We will be going back the next time we are in town!“

“Bartender and drinks were great, some games were broken which sucks but it happens. However what was the worse was the hour wait for food when the place wasn’t even busy. First time here slightly disappointed thankfully the bartender was great. Don’t come here for food or you’ll wait for forever. This is only gonna be a drinks and games place for me. Won’t get food again, food was good but not worth the hour wait“

“First time here. Food was really good and waiter santi was present and took real good care of of us. Place was really clean. A lot quieter than I expected.but over all a10/10“

“My first time there :) Great food and Awesome service! The hostess is super friendly and wow!“

“The wings lived up to the hype!! Food was great but the service was even better. Our bartender Makella and I believe the guy's name was Nathan (could be wrong😬) were super cool and checked on us a lot and kept everything clean as we ate. 10/10“

“I m a lms cancer pt stage 4 going thru chemo. I found that chia pudding and kale drink only thing I can eat.love there product. wish I could afford more often than just on Friday all day treatment. be amazing if you do a deal for us chemo patients at osu mill run gynecology infusion maybe we connect and do a non profit write off for your business for ones like myself fighting for the next day.thank you for amazing healthy options“

“Amy was very attentive and fast shewas yelled at by some white trash blonde with two teenage trolls she told the manager that we were served first which we were there first .she ended up getting everything paid for like she was trying to do and Amy was in trouble. the white trash was two tables away and heard out load everything she was saying. Amy our server was busting her butt 5 stars to Amy 3 stars to scramblersfor good food negative 20 stars to the white trash I hope never to see white trash again“

“Great place to sit outside and watch the game!!“

“Food was good, but they need to clean.“

“The bartender Brandon is an amazing! Very attentive and great customer service!“

“I wanted to do a Google review and could not figure out why I couldn’t. So I will do it here. Jayla was our server. She was pleasant, attentive, and even helped my friend figure out where the Target store was from there. We both enjoyed our time at your establishment. My friend had gotten the coney dog (she said she got 1 the day before when she went) and I got a chicken wrap. We also got some waffle fries? I got the strawberry cheesecake too. All of our food was fine. Thank you for a pleasant time, Jayla!“

“dining in here feels so calm and relaxing, like it's morning all day. the service for dine-in and take-away are excellent, consistently. the food is always fresh and delicious, and a myriad of options allow for exact preparation...and it's always coming out of the kitchen as soon as I arrive when I order take-away. this is our default breakfast option.

Dietary restrictions: their menu offers several options to customize your order. if you advise of your dietary restrictions, they will go the extra mile adhere to them. they are extremely accommodating.

Parking: it's in a plaza, so there is plenty of parking available in the lot, and it's close to the door.

Kid-friendliness: the laid-back atmosphere, lighting, space, and staff make this a wonderful option for the kids. they also have a robust selection available in the kids menu.“

“We had our 6 year olds birthday party at Ten Pin today. From setting up the event all the way to leaving, the entire experience was easy and great. The event manager and server were both so accommodating and friendly. Even our party guests commented on how much they enjoyed it.“

“They serve a chipotle sauce with their chicken quesadillas that I swear is literal liquid crack. Freaking amazing!“

“We've been waiting for Yabos to open up and they are fantastic. Super chill staff, great menu, fantastic bar! It's family-friendly with a sports bar vibe.“

“We threw a surprise party for 2 of our favorite people at Oties, in their Event Room. It was absolutely AMAZING! The room was so lovey and the food was great and came out quickly from the kitchen. We had such a wonderful time and the staff was very nice and helpful. Truly a great experience! We still have friends talking about what a wonderful time it was.“

“Ten Pin is a phenomenal venue. Even before the massive renovation, they were great for bowling. Now, the bowling is bigger and better. The arcade is nice, but could use a few more classic arcade games (in my opinion). The big shocker with Ten Pin is the food. Do not think this is bar or bowling alley food; I keep being wowed when I try different items each time. Talking to the staff, they said everything is scratch-made. It's all great!“

“Like most Red Robin restaurants, the food was excellent. The variety of burgers and sandwiches are awesome. This particular location was full of upbeat and welcoming workers. Our server was attentive and accommodating. With some Red Robin restaurants, they don't come by much, expecting you to use the little ordering tablet on the table, but we have the best of both worlds (attentive service and technology). This made for a great lunch date.“

“Great food and great service“

“Great. Food great service the ribs are the best get your order in for July 4th that’s e what I recommend“

“All you care to eat chicken tenders, shrimp and riblets do not disappoint! The fries were not the freshest and the coleslaw was not the best I've had. But we did have excellent service so that made up for it. They were playing a lot of Mexican music very loudly at 6:30pm on a Monday but I double checked and I was at Applebee's and not the Mexican restaurant. Other than the weird music choice the atmosphere was ok I guess.“