50 Best Bakeries near Mayfield Heights

“My daughter and I went into Crumbl this week and we were so excited to try a new flavor this week! I had the confetti cake cookie and it was a confetti in my mouth of flavors! It was amazing. My daughter grabbed the strawberry cheesecake cake and it looked amazing she took two bites and said it was too sweet for her...insert sad face. Overall it was a good visit outside of the young people that work in the evenings, they never speak when you come in and you have to get their attention for them to help you on top of they act like it's a hassle to help or work at work...the irony in that is insane. Luckily they have multiple locations so we will visit another one in the future.“

“I would like to give a big shout out to Devin Who works at the Mayfield giant eagle he really deserves to be employee of the month and get a big fat raise he is the kindest caring person every time I am there he greets hello good morning how are you can I help you with your bags to your car have a great day I would say he should be employee of the month every month and he really does deserve a big shout out thank you Devin for your kindness“

“their Sammie's, their quiche, their baked yummies all are amazaballz! I'm so happy they are in Larchmere & pray they are a smashing success & stay a part of our community.“

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!“

“I placed a last minute order and it didn't effect the pick up time or quality of our order. Our order was ready when we arrived. The store was clean. The staff was friendly! This was our first time ordering from this location, we had a positive experience and we'll surely choose this location in the future!“

“I worked across the street from them and eat there all most every day and love their food and everyone that works there great people“

“My boyfriend and I were strolling along downtown Willoughby around 10am, nothing was really open except Michael’s. We stopped in, were greeted by a kind man and saw not much was left except some Cinnamon Rolls. Figured that meant they must’ve been good, tried one of them and it was amazing! Wishing lots of success for Michael! Great spot for people who come to town in the early hours.“

“Second time here after a couple of years and am so glad to see it have expanded to more options for savoury/ nutritious foods as well as their delicious pastries. It’s giving “Luna” but with a more modern and minimalist style! Happy to have brought my mum since the pastries are always great.

The only qualm I had was how the manager or owner responded to my mum requesting more milk in her cappuccino, as if we don’t have any knowledge in coffee. The foam was not foamy or thick with a ton of bubbles inside the foam. As if they didn’t tap it before pouring it in. He explained the drink to her and had a perplexed judgment look on his face. I almost wanted to intervene and ask if he wanted to try the drink himself. I don’t have an issue with people informing us how the drink is supposed to be made, but the assumption that the customer is not informed rather than, “hey maybe the barista had a faulty drink this one time” or adjusting to my mum’s preference, came off strange. The coffee was bitter, which is why she asked for more milk. I wish they had been kinder in responding to an older foreign lady or ask what was wrong while explaining their reasonings“

“Absolutely 100% Yes 100 PERCENT …the BEST French bakery outside of Paris! THE FRESH BREADS And breakfast croissant sandwiches are amazing! Along with pai au raisen… apple tart, cinnamon raisin bread beyond belief! AND I GUESS I’M NOT THE ONLY ONE BECAUSE WHEN I WENT IN ON SUNDAY AFTER MASS IT WAS STRIPPED CLEAN OF ALL BREAD AND PASTRIES… LOL I GUESS THE WORD GETS OUT! It’s not only the bread that are fresh and wonderful including sourdough and baguettes beyond compare… It is the friendliness and wonderful staff who make it a great place to enjoy a visit whether it’s breakfast lunch or more !!!!✨💕✨✨☀️☀️☀️✨ thank you ! Thank you Brian Evans and On the Rise Artisan Bread staff✨💕✨“

“Good cookies everyone should go and buy them“

“Great service and amazing cupcakes 🤩“

“Banana Fosters Cheesecake was the best dessert I’ve eaten in a long time. It might become my birthday cake, it’s that good! Everything else we picked out for NYE was excellent too: oatmeal cream pies and a small decorated cake was so cute for the holiday.“

“Bought 2 jumbo cupcakes just before closing and the staff was just as friendly as if I walked in right after they opened. The pineapple upside down cupcake was creative decadent and delicious! I gave the cookies and cream cupcak3 to a friend who doesn't usually go for sweets but he raved about that cupcake for days! Definitely will be back :)“

“Old school donut and pastry shop. Everything I've tried has been amazing!!“

“My husband and I got married earlier this month and were referred to White Flower Cake Shoppe for our wedding cake! They made it extremely easy- we sent inspiration pictures and they made it come to life! Absolutely beautiful and tasted even better! Thank you!“

“word cannot even describe how heavenly these cookies and baked treats are. The smores bars instantly transport me back to my grandma's house, in front of the wood stove putting together that messy concoction, yet all you need is a napkin. I found them at UH farmers market but will definitely be ordering more.“

“Two and Company has amazing, made from scratch, healthy food and the customer service is great! Not to mention you are helping a non-profit with a mission of full integration into the workplace for individuals who have cognitive disabilities. It's a real win for our community!“

“I go there every week to buy food and/or baked goods. They have catered parties for me! Highly recommended!“

“Thank you Sweeter than honeycomb for the beautiful cookies and smash cake for my granddaughters first birthday party. The cookies were amazing in how they looked and tasted. The smash cake was perfect and that also must have been delicious because my granddaughter dug right in! We definitely will be back!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“Thank you for supporting the Greater Cleveland Food Bank and CHANGING MY LIFE with your sweet potato cheesecake!“

“I will NEVER order from this business again. They messed up our cake order with 3 different mistakes. then when I called I heard one of the people on the phone in the background talking badly about me. wildly unprofessional! saying i left with the cake so its not their problem.(my husband picked it up and when he brought it home I realized all the mistakes made) so I called immediately like 10 mins later and the baker left for the day so we had to just have a cake that was incorrect. Tues I spoke to the baker who made the cake and explained to her the mistakes that were made. she just kept trying to shift blame onto me. saying oh well you left with the cake so its not our problem once you leave with it. I expressed my husband picked it up cause I was getting ready for the party and as soon as he opened it I saw immediately it was wrong and called you within minutes. didnt matter she wasnt willing to help us out. no discount. no refund, no nothing. she kept blaming her mistakes on the photo I sent her being "too old to see" but the mistakes had nothing to do with the picture. it was a HER mistake not a picture mistake. 1: there was to be no writing on the cake because we have a topper. and they wrote on the cake. 2.I asked them to write a message on the cake board instead. which they didnt. 3. I asked for light pale pink flowers and they were bright fuschia pink. but somehow those mistakes are because of an "old photo?" ok. **eye roll** she took zero ownership and gave no help toward finding a fair way to make the customer happy. I do not recommend this place. they are rude, don't follow instructions, overpriced, poor customer service, and take zero responsibility for their actions. absolutely blown away being treated this way by a buisness. 0/10 DO NOT RECOMMEND. below is will post photos of the cake and the notes stating what I wanted and didnt get.“

“Always stock up on rye bread when in town. It was still steaming when being sliced. SO DELICIOUS!Somehow several boxes of cookies, bags of assorted pastries, and some brown mustard made its way into my bag too!“

“The Prestis I remember is from 1987 it was known as Prestis Donuts. It was located further down, a corner shop that remained open 25/7, the reason being… the shop had no doors to lock. Yes, it was a donut shop (I think cannolis too) and not a sit down place. Best donuts in Cleveland, be it 2 AM or 2 PM.
Ah! Sweet memories come flooding…“

“Anita at Anita’s Sweet Treats was an absolute delight to work with! She provided the most beautiful and delicious desserts for our associate appreciation event, and they were a huge hit with everyone. You can really tell she puts love and care into everything she bakes. Anita was professional, prompt, and so easy to work with throughout the entire process. Highly recommend her for any event!“

“They the best poppyseed rolls I've ever had in my life ..“

“Everything they serve is amazing! Cassata cakes, cannoli, tiramisu, cookies… all the best. Staff is wonderful and welcoming.“

“Reminds me of my hometown bakery!!! Will definitely revisit“

“Absolutely delicious! 1st time customer, 10/10 will visit again“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“i recently went to bakery for first time. chocolate Babka is outstanding. worth the price. ❤️“

“Nadine did a Paw-Patrol themed cakes for my twin girls 4th birthday. She did a fabulous job!! My twins were sooo surprised and very happy!! Nadine was very helpful and kind from the minute we walked into her shop. I called first to make sure she could do a Paw- Patrol themed cakes, she had the declaration ready to show us. She also had great visions in her mind, she definitely executed her vision. The cakes were very fresh the icing was not too too sweet it was light and fluffy, the cake tasted great!! 😋 I will use her again when I need a cake. I would also definitely recommend her. The cake was done on time and also within a few days notice, which I greatly appreciated.“

“We were so impressed with the cookies that Jen created for our event. She absolutely beat out everyone for pricing. (Baby shower) Will definitely keep her in mind and recommend to others for events!!“

“I took my mom to the Giant Eagle in Chesterland for her Covid vaccine.!she received the second shot. I told the folks there but I’d like to just tell everyone, that they did a great job. Very organized, very minimal wait time. Very knowledgeable of the whole process. Very very courteous. I can’t say enough good about the pharmaceutical staff as a Chesterland giant eagle.“

“Always stock up on rye bread when in town. It was still steaming when being sliced. SO DELICIOUS!Somehow several boxes of cookies, bags of assorted pastries, and some brown mustard made its way into my bag too!“

“I highly recommend them. We came through on our way to vacation and it was wonderful!“

“One of my best customers we done a large transaction like $10,000, the owner Mike is a great customer, pay on time. when I purchase equipment from him he palletize it correctly and load it into the truck and I got it the next day in Chicago to my location. I strongly suggest him for all and large businesses commercial business to any other busyness. Thank you so much for your business. I’m looking forward to do more business with you in the future. Great job!.
Dorel, Champion Restaurant and Bakery Equipment title president.“

“It was my Mom’s first birthday being gluten free and she about cried eating her birthday cake! She said she finally felt “normal” eating a gluten free cake that tasted like actual cake. 10/10 experience and Jen was lovely to work with!“

“We have ordered before and always get yummy things. Today, she saved the day. We have our big FUNraising event this evening. Problem elsewhere with a photo cake. She helped us at the last minute to make it all work out. A pleasure to work with and sooo wanting a happy customer. Will definitely order again. Thanks again for your kindness and help❤️❤️❤️“

“The challah made by Meghann is wonderful! So many options for flavors and toppings, and the plain/traditional challah is great on its own. She is prompt with her communications and orders, friendly to deal with, and the prices are reasonable.“

“Absolutely beautiful and delicious cakes! Shae made a beautiful cake for my son’s first communion. She is very professional and prompt. She delivered the cake on time and made sure to give us instructions and a box to transport once the event was over. The cake was a great hit and made our special day complete. This was my first time ordering and tasting her cakes and I’m so happy I chose her to make our cake. I will definitely be ordering more cakes from her.“

“Need to step it up at the Delli way too slow all the time when you're in there Other than that great store“

“Heard about this place from a coworker. Not easy to find - the owner runs her business out of her house. Asian bakeries/patisseries are hard to come by in the Cleveland area so naturally I was excited to try and was not disappointed. Ordered a box of pastries as well as their green tea roll cake. Croissants are the best I’ve had in Cleveland. So many flaky layers, perfect texture, just the right amount of sweetness. Green tea roll cake was also phenomenal. Had bits of red bean and the cream was light and airy. The cake itself was soft and moist. Will be coming back. Highly recommend“

“Ordered a gluten-free strawberry casada cake for my 33 year old nieces birthday...she never had casada despite being a pastry chef! It was awesome! She loved it too because it wasn't overly sweet! Great job 0:-)“

“Michele made a delicious cake for my Mother In Law’s retirement party! She was very accommodating to a nut allergy and the cake was phenomenal!“

“I ordered cake pops for my engagement party last year and cupcakes and cake pops for my bridal shower last weekend. Everything turned out great, exactly as I expected. Everything was delicious. Dana was friendly, professional, and easy to work with. Absolutely recommend!“

“Stopped into Unger's for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. It looks like they’re doing some renovations, so parts of it have that old-school charm while other areas are getting a bit of a refresh. Other spots look like they need scrubbing. The donuts were excellent—fresh, flavorful. Self-serve. You can tell this place has been around a while. Some unique candy options I have not seen before. A payphone too!? No longer in service, I checked.“

“I love Giant Eagle close to home always my go to“

“Totally agreed with Candise Bivens‘s comment from below. The ladies at Payne avenue are rude and not friendly at all. I like the service at Cleveland heights location wayyyy better.“