9 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

“Great News to report. I graduated in 1991. Eagles Pizza was our hangout spot. I have lived away from Eagles Pizza for many. Dennis the owner is a great man. He is coming near where I live. And bringing the famous Taco Pizza. Try one!!! U rock Dennis and Eagles Pizza!!!“

“Great meatballs!!!! Love the pizza.“

“I wanted to try a new pizza joint and Brenz had good reviews on Uber Eats so I tried it and the reviewers did not steer me wrong! Except they forgot some of my order. The pizza was great, the bread sides were ok. The Heritage Hot Honey- a MUST try!!!! Top 3 pizza's I ever tasted. I was worried it would be too spicy because I am a whoosie but it was not. Portion sizes are great also. Just wish my full order arrived.“

“I have celiac disease and am very limited in places that I can go where I feel safe. I stumbled across someone raving about mellow mushroom and decided to look into it. Not only do they have a gluten free menu but they are well educated in cross contamination and but they also have a dedicated area for toppings and take proper precautions to make sure that no other people touch your food . Jamie, our waitress was amazing and was able to answer all of our questions and knew when and how to ask others for help. My husband and I will definitely be back.“

“Traveling through from Michigan where we have very few Sbarro locations outside of malls. Delicious food, very clean restaurant, and an employee with a wonderfully positive and friendly demeanor. Kudos to him (and whoever hired him). This young man deserves a raise. Talked about their freshly shredded cheese and the freshness of the entire process. He sold me on an old favorite! A+ visit, thanks for having us!“

“Love the lunch special! Great food and fast & friendly delivery! My office orders lunch from here at least once a week!“

“Went in recently for a couple drinks before doing lunch at Firebirds. Brooklyn was VERY friendly, and attentive. Also, she made the BEST Bloody Mary I have ever tasted!! My husband ordered it and I had a couple sips and LOVED it and I don't even like Bloody Mary!! We enjoyed ourselves so much that we also ended our evening at Beerhead with a couple drinks and some food! Will definitely be back for happy hour sometime soon!“

“Always hot! Always cooked to perfection! Our household favorite!! :)“

“08/15/2025 - First time visiting this Roosters with family and friends. It was very busy and the wait was about 30 minutes. I ordered their seasonal Blue Margarita that was very savory. I also ordered my favorite pizza of theirs which is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which is always delicious. Great service from the hosts and our server. Nice size outdoor patio that you may also dine at (weather permitting). Standard franchise Roosters decor. Spacious parking with tight parking (usually in the evening). Decent prices. Enjoy.“