39 Best Sandwich Shops near New Albany

“This Jersey Mikes is fantastic! The people are friendly, prompt, and the food is great!“

“Ok so rn i am absolutely CRAVING a warmed BLT, so I looked up when y'all open (it's 2 am mind you ) anyway then I looked at the reviews and firstly you guys always make my sandwich so good, the store is clean, the service is nice, and yeah. the negative petty reviews are ridiculous. lol i'm still hungry“

“Subway hadn’t been on my go to list for some time, but this young couple have put the franchise back at the top. I, with my very old mother in tow, now stop by this particular Subway every chance we get. They are friendly and fun, the establishment is clean, the bread and ingredients are fresh, and the finished product is delicious! Very highly recommended! And now, of course, I am starving!“

“You made me a superfan after my visit yesterday. From the sandwiches to the sides, you are doing something special there in Bexley.“

“This my first time visiting this spot! I’m new to the East side area and as soon as I walked in the door I felt the warmth!

Once you’ve ordered and the food is ready they are able to bring it to your car or you can’t wait inside (which is a huge plus)! The woman at the front counter was so sweet! The chef was amazing as well! I got a warm turkey sub with fries and a drink and it hit the spot!!

I willl be returning again and bring friends 🤗“

“Had a great lunch with my hubby - enjoyed EVERYTHING we ordered. Decided to make them my “Graduation Party Catering Menu Provider”. Lots of variety in flavors at a very reasonable cost! Staff was very accommodating and helpful with suggestions. Give them a try! I’m writing this about 5 hours after my visit, and NOW wishing I had brought home another serving of the Kickin’ Kay Lynne chicken salad I had at lunch!“

“Great sandwiches, fresh veggies and fresh fries. Coca cola fountain drinks . Offered hit subs with a variety of meats as well as cold subs . Worth trying out.“

“Im a regular at this location so much that when I walk in the door, "Its Hi Bryan". Its like your part of their family. All the people there are awesome to deal with. I've been to a couple other stores in town, and no one compares to the North store on Hamilton Rd in the Meijers parking lot.“

“This subway is seriously one of the good ones. Most of the subways I’ve seen were dirty, underemployed and unprofessional. I always go out of my way to get subway from this location because of how clean and awesome the employees are here. Just be nice to them and they will give you exactly what you want!!“

“I had a fantastic experience at the Subway on Main Street in Reynoldsburg! The staff was incredibly friendly and efficient, ensuring my order was prepared exactly the way I wanted. The ingredients were fresh, and the bread was perfectly baked, making for a delicious sandwich. The restaurant was clean, well-maintained, and had a welcoming atmosphere. I also appreciated how quickly they handled the lunch rush without compromising quality. This location stands out as one of the best Subways I’ve visited. Highly recommend for a quick, satisfying meal!“

“Great. Food and service. Staff is always friendly and great.“

“My husband and I go to Jersey Mike’s pretty regularly, and he had the best famous Philly with onions he’s had in his life from the young woman who was working the grill earlier today when we came in. My Italian was great as well. Thoughtful service and clean bathroom! Will be back next time we’re in the area. Very positive experience.“

“This place is a Columbus staple and childhood favorite, I stopped by this location after many years and it honestly hasn't changed a bit. The service was quick but they were a bit short staffed with the order taker having to run both drive through and the front counter. The food came out quick, hot and fresh. The restaurant itself could use some TLC and updates but it is also a classic spot. Overall, great food and friendly staff.“

“Great location! The service was good.They loaded the salad a little weird - I had to deconstruct it to heat the chicken.The dressings were plentiful and prepackaged- overall the quality of the produce was really good.

Vegetarian options: Lots of options for fresh veggies!

Dietary restrictions: Loads of options for most diets

Parking: Make sure to lock your vehicle- this area has had some break ins.

Kid-friendliness: Kids meals and seating available

Wheelchair accessibility: Standard accessibility“

“Good food, friendly staff, and a nice new location. We love the subs, and it is usually a quick experience for lunch or dinner.

On the downside, parking lot is small with too many high traffic businesses in one spot. A little pricey for sandwiches and they could clean the tables more often in between customers.“

“Although it was Superbowl Sunday (busy, busy, busy), the staff was extremely accommodating. Of course, the subs were delicious as usual! Although I normally order from their app which is excellent, I found ordering in the Sunbury Rd store location also extremely easy and pleasant.“

“The protein bowl and footlocker cookie are my new go-to! I've bought it at several different locations, so my experiences vary. Service was always friendly, but a couple of workers were noticeably stressed. They were working alone, part of my order was not available in the store.“

“Bomb asf ❤️❤️❤️ i love the food the chicken was good“

“I always get my hot sandwich as a wrap, the chicken bacon ranch. The last few times it wasn’t good because the kid who usually makes it isn’t there all the time. Well he was today. Laeric is an excellent sandwich maker, he takes the time to listen, and builds a great sub with a perfect ratio or meats and toppings. When he makes a wrap you actually eat the whole thing and don’t have to leave the ends in your bag due to no toppings. That kid deserves a raise!! I’ll only order a sandwich from now on when he’s there. He’s also a great team member and communicates well with his team and helped when they asked in the past!!“

“There was this kind lady, Daniel, I believe. I like my sub a certain way and she tried her best. Even asked some other blond lady she was with and the lady didn’t know either so daniel GOOGLED how to do it perfectly for me. I tried tipping her and she told me she wouldn’t accept it 10/10 this girl is awesome!“

“The store was very clean....... The food was great 10/10 and the service was amazing.. thanks to BRI for allowing me to try the multigrain bread. I'm not going back to White LOL.. I don't know what's changed since the last time I was there huge difference. Thanks so much ladies.“

“The staff is amazing and friendly up there, they remember your name, always prompt service, definitely one of the best Penn stations I like going to, also I am able to fit my bobtail semi truck on the side of building while I grab my food, and even with all the construction because of the traffic lights it’s easy to exit location and get back on the road. Keep up the great work you guys are awesome at this Penn station.

BTW
I always get my chicken teriyaki sub, and anyone that hasn’t tried their lemonade is missing out lol it’s delicious… 🤤

Parking: Very easy if you’re about to tell, semi truck to park on side of the building and grab your food, and easy to exit right onto the main street with traffic lights so you can get back on the road.“

“The food is delicious the staff is friendly and the food is delivered quickly to your table, my son loves the fries with cheese and bacon. I recommend this charleys“

“Stopped by to pick up dinner. I enjoyed the service I received. The two works were very friendly. Enjoyed the laughs while waiting for my order.“

“Jimmy John’s on Broad Street is quite the operation. A well oiled machine. Strong teamwork. Exceptional service. Fresh. Clean. Keeps me coming back. That bread draws me in. #freakyfast.“

“Placed a large order for 17 people today. They arrived early and everything was correct! Great Job Jimmy Johns!!!“

“We order from here frequently! Tonight they made a mistake and made my sandwich wrong (which was the first time they had ever done this!) ! I called and just wanted to let them know, didn’t expect much other than to make them aware they screwed up and the manager the sweetest lady, offered to remake my sandwich and deliver it to me or credit my account! They delivered a new sandwich quickly! Truly great customer service!! Happy girl!“

“I have been to this location several times and I am not sure if it was because of Zach or the multigrain bread, all I know for sure is it was the best Penn Station I have had in years. It was so good that I want more already and I just left.

Great staff (08/16/2026 @ 2:30 PM)
Wonderful food
Extremely clean dining area

Definitely recommend“

“I'm writing this review for the Subway in the StoneRidge Plaza. The service and food are great. The bread is so soft and fresh I can't believe it's a Subway but it is. I've enjoyed Subway my whole life honestly but this location is my favorite.“

“this short kid with glasses made the best sandwiches. good service, give the short kid with glasses a raise, (i think his name was collin i could be wrong) but yeah i reccomend this. only thing is one time i was here and a customer asked for more cucmbers and this random guy added one, so he said it in a scary voice and he added like 2 handfuls of cucmbers so that was weird but again overall great service and place.“

“The food is always great. The service is always friendly and accommodating to any food restrictions. The restrooms are always clean, neat, stocked and smelling fresh.

Dietary restrictions: Lactose intolerance. They never ask why so or why not and embarrase me, by having to divulge hippa laws. I truly appreciate that when so many places do. I will always return when I want a tasty sandwich ?.“

“Sandwiches and fries were very good, the employees were incredibly nice. The parking lot is a little small so you might have to park somewhere else and then walk. We were there at like 6 I believe and were able to find parking easily. The inside is cute with lots of table seating.“

“Turkey bacon club is the best“

“Simply leaving the 5 stars because of Elijah's outstanding customer service. 2:25pm, Friday, 4/21/23. There wasn't a line, yet the food was rushed. The Philly Chicken wasn't on the grill long enough to melt the Cheese. The entire Sandwich lacked flavor. The meat was unseasoned, extremely bland. Best part of my experience was Elijah's kindness, the french fries & cup of ice...“

“A little over $4 for a 6 inch veggie no veggies lolMy kiddo has a very specific way of eating at subway, he like marinara with light cheese toasted. He enjoys one from time to time.It's easy to make and easy to mess up, but they do a nice job.“

“My lunch was super fast! Thanks. Being in office has been a tad different. By the time I placed my order and received it, it was less than 20 minutes. #freakyfast!! 👌🏼👍🏼👊🏼“

“I always go to this Firehouse subs because of Alexis. She is a rockstar and always makes my husband and I feel so welcome! Not to mention she always goes above and beyond to make every experience excellent.“