50 Best Bakeries near Newburgh Heights

“our favorite local coffee shop here in our neighborhood!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼 it's been a long time since we've been here but we're looking forward to be back!! I super love them!! their quiche, pizza roll, and blueberry muffin is superb!!! 🫶🏼 their daughter is also friendly! she plays with my daughter whenever we go here! 🥰 you guys deserve all the love and support!! 🥹“

“We have a fabulous contractor on our property who has brought us treats from your amazing bakery…chocolate croissants and today, delicious cupcakes...almost too beautiful to bite into! We are new to the area but a visit in person is a must. A big thanks to John for his generosity and the best bake goods we have ever had. Baking from scratch with fresh ingredients and your skill produces the ultimate treat!“

“their Sammie's, their quiche, their baked yummies all are amazaballz! I'm so happy they are in Larchmere & pray they are a smashing success & stay a part of our community.“

“The quiche is unbelievable, the lemon chicken soup is light and perfect, the pastries drove my coworkers crazy! Despina's is literally unbeatable“

“We came in for the first time today and tried the apple and the cherry strudels. They were delicious and we will be back soon!“

“Ordered the Tiarmisu Cake for my parent’s Anniversary and it was absolutely gorgeous, right down to a beautiful red ribbon around the bottom . It was absolutely delicious . Thank you so much ! Highly recommend!“

“My cookies initially we're lacking the strawberry topping. I asked if they could be touched up some and the employee was so nice about it! I told her it's the best part and she agreed. I really appreciated her kindness. The cookies were perfect and absolutely delicious.“

“They did a last minute order for me after someone canceled , made beautiful and delicious cookies for my baby shower after I asked them on a Saturday afternoon about getting the cookies done by Sunday afternoon and they made it happen and the cookies were exactly what I had hoped for! Highly recommend👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼“

“I went today and she had cherry cherry cake and it was delicious, make sure you go and get a piece.“

“Amazingly delicious and fun custom flavors!“

“This bakery is OUTSTANDING. It's the best bakery ever. The selection is phenomenal and the quality exceptional. I have to drive from eastern Lake County and my mouth waters all the way there...“

“My family has shopped here for many years and so thankful to visit for excellent bakery.“

“The pasteles de cerdo are VERY GOOD!!! They have mostly meat in them. Wish they had chicken but they are still delicious.“

“The cinnamon raisin loaf I've been dreaming about my entire life. Fresh baked, it's beyond comprehension. The French loaf is equally delicious. A culinary treasure in our backyard.“

“Leslie is my literal hero! School starts back up tomorrow and I was late to the game securing a custom cookie for my daughter. I posted on a local Facebook page that I was in need and within five minutes she messaged me and had it waiting up at the shop. I’m going to have a happy Bluey loving first grader tomorrow morning!“

“If you want BAKED empanadas, this is the place! They are perfectly filled and flaky, and so delicious. Thank you so much! 😊“

“Second time here after a couple of years and am so glad to see it have expanded to more options for savoury/ nutritious foods as well as their delicious pastries. It’s giving “Luna” but with a more modern and minimalist style! Happy to have brought my mum since the pastries are always great.

The only qualm I had was how the manager or owner responded to my mum requesting more milk in her cappuccino, as if we don’t have any knowledge in coffee. The foam was not foamy or thick with a ton of bubbles inside the foam. As if they didn’t tap it before pouring it in. He explained the drink to her and had a perplexed judgment look on his face. I almost wanted to intervene and ask if he wanted to try the drink himself. I don’t have an issue with people informing us how the drink is supposed to be made, but the assumption that the customer is not informed rather than, “hey maybe the barista had a faulty drink this one time” or adjusting to my mum’s preference, came off strange. The coffee was bitter, which is why she asked for more milk. I wish they had been kinder in responding to an older foreign lady or ask what was wrong while explaining their reasonings“

“Boba tea in so many flavors! Chicken teriyaki is delicious, as is all the buns and treats.“

“Stosh's Kolaches in Parma is truly a hidden gem. A couple started this little business in 2022, and even though they’re only open on Saturdays, they somehow manage to bake around 4,000 cookies a week — and it shows in the quality.

There are so many flavors to choose from, and every single kolache looks perfectly baked. The ones I tried were soft, buttery, and literally melted in my mouth. Absolute perfection. Honestly, it’s a dangerous place to live near if you have a sweet tooth!

My only complaint? They’re only open one day a week — I would be there constantly if they weren’t! Their website says online ordering is coming soon, which will be amazing and make these delicious kolaches even easier to get.

Highly recommend supporting this small local business. You won’t regret it!“

“Sooooo Good!!!! Love this place“

“We just had the best experience at Michael's Bakery. The cheese and apricot folded croissants were delicious, the adorable flower cupcake moist and beautifully decorated, and the bread loaf perfect with our lunch. We went for our son's birthday and the clerk was incredibly kind and professional, and even gave him a cookie for the occasion. We will definitely be back!“

“Cannot get over what an amazing job KB Confections did with bringing my vision to life! Not only did it look pretty but tasted AMMAZING! 12/10 recommend! The cupcakes were just as delicious too 😍“

“Always very good service! Cookies always look great! Last week however, (not the workers fault though) online it said on Tuesday (very early like 3am) that they still had the biscoff Dubai brownie (sometimes they have them leftover from previous week) but I ordered it online for pick up in morning…. Mind you getting Dubai anything costs an extra $1.50… I ordered 3 & when I got there they told me that they didn’t have it bc it was for previous week. Every other store online didn’t have it online shown but they did. I ended up picking 2 cookies that weren’t anything I wanted but I never got refunded or anything. I spent an extra 4.50 for the Dubai brownie but was still owed $ for the other one I didn’t get. Super bummed“

“word cannot even describe how heavenly these cookies and baked treats are. The smores bars instantly transport me back to my grandma's house, in front of the wood stove putting together that messy concoction, yet all you need is a napkin. I found them at UH farmers market but will definitely be ordering more.“

“Great service and amazing cupcakes 🤩“

“Great cookies with unique flavors. Always love the ones with the pat of butter on top! These are the type of cookies you bring to a party and you buy their little cookie cutter and it cuts them in like six pieces I think. Then everyone gets to try a little wedge of all the different flavors and it's fantastic and fun!“

“I called early in the morning, last minute unfortunately because that’s just what happened. Slices was able to accommodate me, I ordered a praline cheesecake and it was SOOO GOOD! Thank you so much for taking my order last minute and making this amazing cake!“

“Old school donut and pastry shop. Everything I've tried has been amazing!!“

“We ordered cupcakes and a sheet size Cassata cake for our wedding and it was AMAZING!!! Best Cassata cake we’ve ever had. Everyone kept talking about how good the desserts were. Thank you so much Bakery 57 for making our special day even sweeter!!!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“Thank you for supporting the Greater Cleveland Food Bank and CHANGING MY LIFE with your sweet potato cheesecake!“

“Stopped by today,ham and cheese croissant that was great. Only problem was my dog was trying to intercept bites which created a dicey ,situation,but he got some and was quite happy.“

“I ordered mini sweet potato pies from Ms. Anita and they were very delicious. The crust was flaky and tasty and the sweetness of the filling was just right. These were the perfect treats for the Thanksgiving holiday. Ms. Anita is very professional and had the treats ready on time. I will be ordering again. If you’re reading this review- don’t delay, try Anita’s Sweet Treats today!“

“We moved from the area 7 years ago so we hadn't been in for a long time. We purchased a nut roll, 1 apricot Danish, a pound of nut kolachkis, 2 cupcakes, 1 chocolate bomb, 1 brownie and 2 dozen pierogies. Firs, the good....the apricot Danish was the best I have ever had. My son enjoyed the chocolate bomb.The cupcakes were average and we were definitely expecting more for $4.50 each. The kolachkis are very dry and disappointing. My husband tried 1 bite of the brownie and threw it away. 3 of the 4 sides were rock hard. We haven't tried the pierogies, but I'm hoping they are as good as in years past. Fingers crossed for the nut roll tomorrow morning as well. After spending over $77 we had hoped for a better experience.“

“My go-to spot for a cannoli and espresso! Presti’s is an absolute gem. There’s something here for everyone. Sometimes there’s a long wait if it’s busy but it’s always well staffed and the employees are clearly hustling. I always tip because they work so hard!“

“They the best poppyseed rolls I've ever had in my life ..“

“Everything they serve is amazing! Cassata cakes, cannoli, tiramisu, cookies… all the best. Staff is wonderful and welcoming.“

“I love this place! Parma has great employees that are always smiling and so cheerful. The cookies are heavenly!“

“I got my Haircut by Nito Who owns the barbershop connected to the bakery, and his wife made me a cake that I customized for my fiancé I cannot even tell you how beautiful it was presented, and the taste was beyond fantastic. I would highly recommend paradise cakes to anybody at all.“

“Loved this bakery and we were customers for years - even driving over from Fairview Park for their yummy bread, pizza and treats. Just found out they are open for holiday orders and we WILL be ordering from them because we haven't found any place that compares!“

“Best biscotti ever! We love them and will be ordering online. Discovered them at the Pittsburgh home show. Highly recommend you try these, you will be glad you did!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“It is a bit late but they made my wedding cake. When I say it was perfect I can't not even express how amazing of a job they did. They gave me a Husband and wife donuts topper, had nailed the very specific cake flavor I wanted and made it look so beautiful. I can not praise them enough for this. It made my wedding day even better.“

“Always such good cakes! I usually order their Cassata cake and it's always great, and have gotten the cupcakes and chocolate covered strawberries on occasion and they have always been amazing as well! This year I ordered the chocolate lovers cake and it was just as delish as the other items I've ordered! I deff reccomend them! 🍰🎂“

“Stopped in yesterday got bread, cupcakes and a snoodle all are delicious.“

“Great service, good price and wonderful customer service.“

“The challah made by Meghann is wonderful! So many options for flavors and toppings, and the plain/traditional challah is great on its own. She is prompt with her communications and orders, friendly to deal with, and the prices are reasonable.“

“First time here and will be back! Everyone is so friendly and welcoming! The prices are very competitive. The store was a little hard for me to find on google maps but well worth the visit once I made it in! Do your self a “flavor” and check this place out!“

“Absolutely beautiful and delicious cakes! Shae made a beautiful cake for my son’s first communion. She is very professional and prompt. She delivered the cake on time and made sure to give us instructions and a box to transport once the event was over. The cake was a great hit and made our special day complete. This was my first time ordering and tasting her cakes and I’m so happy I chose her to make our cake. I will definitely be ordering more cakes from her.“

“I LOVE this small discounted bread store with both day old & fresh items. Items vary by day. They also carry popcorn, snacks, pasta noodles, condiments, soup mixes, cookies, candy bars & candy, chips & and the list goes on. I only purchase my bread, buns & sweets here at these amazing prices. Schewebel's is worth the stop, even if a bit out the way with grocery store prices these days check them out.“