42 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newbury

“If you want good food Johnnys is the place to order from! Everything on the menu is amazing and so flavorful! Their employees are top-notch! Their delivery drivers always brings food fast the hot stuff is hot and the ice cream and deserts is cold which is highly recommended!!! Thank you for always providing excellent service and food!!“

“they have great food and always have it right 😋“

“Had my baby shower hosted at Mangia Mangia . I’ve come here for years as a kid , always knew the food was amazing . But let me tell you, was blown away by how helpful and friendly the staff were. They were on top of everything the entire time. You all made us feel so taken care of and welcome . Thank you Mangia team for making the day so special .“

“So, pizza pie is so authentic and good but an extra surprise was an amazing cocktail called a spicy jalapeno margarita! best!!!!!“

“Four of us went there after watching a performance at CVLT. Place was clean, fast service, everything we ordered was a 10 out of 10. Salad, cheesy bread, prosciutto and sausage pizzas. We will be back!“

“Guido’s is the best. The end.“

“So glad to have discovered this place! Mind you, I discovered it through installing the epoxy floors there, because I actually live an hour away. But I stopped there today and finally had a chance to try out his pizza.. And let me tell you! Some of the best pizza I've ever had! I got the New Yorker, and I've legitimately never seen a bigger pizza, not in person at least. I've gotten to know the owner, and he seems to really care about his business, and clearly cares about his pizza, because it for sure shows in the quality of it! All of the ingredients tasted super fresh, and super tasty. I got the New Yorker with Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, my personal favorite combination. And I only made it through 2 slices!! 2!! This pizza is worth every dime. It was not only tasty, but cooked to perfection. The toppings were plentiful, the dough was delicious, and the crust was so good(which many places fail at). Even though I'm rarely out in this area due to the distance, I'll surely be back to try more things on the menu! Glad to have met you! And glad to have finally tried the pizza! 😁🍕 Thanks Mike! BTW.. The pic of the two slices on the tray, are on a normal extra large pizza tray. The slices are really that big!“

“Ordered the trifecta. Knocked each pizza out of the park. My favorite was the pizza built to represent an Italian sub ! Keep up the great work !“

“The pizza was hot and fresh, the wings were nice and crispy and the fried dough was the perfect tasty treat to complete the meal“

“We ordered a pepperoni pizza and really enjoyed this pizza! It was fresh out of the oven, full of flavor, and had a deliciously fluffy, well-made crust that everyone loved. The pepperoni had a great crisp, and the sauce-to-cheese ratio was spot on. The only minor issue we had was that the cheese didn’t stretch—it came off in one piece with the toppings when my kids took a bite, which made it a little tricky for them to eat. But overall, a tasty and satisfying pizza that we’d happily order again!“

“Zeppe's in Chardon is wonderful. Their pizza and food are delicious and flavorful. Everything taste very fresh and yummy. They have many delicious vegetarian options as well. The front store and kitchen crew are very friendly and helpful. I look forward to visiting them again very soon.“

“I order some pizza for a party I was having and wow did Georgio's come through. Reasonably priced pizza and amazing taste. Everyone loved them! We are customers for life!! Also, you can't be $5 fresh and ready. Top notch customer service!“

“I am an out-of-towner visiting family. I am amazed at how good the pizza and calzones are! Huge portions, fantastic flavor, generous with toppings, and great service! I thought it was pricy until I got my food; WELL WORTH IT! Delivery was early, food was HOT. 10 out of 10 for me!“

“Great service. Delicious Pizza. Chicken Lollipops are the bomb! Relaxing atmosphere! 🍕“

“Lee Angelo’s helped us host our daughter’s birthday party very last minute and was extremely helpful and kind during the entire process. Maddie was helpful with planning and Briana was so helpful the day of and made sure everything was perfect. It was a big hit for the kids with create your own pizzas. Lee Angelo’s is so wonderful for the Aurora community.“

“This is the best pizza around, period. The sauce is delicious, and just wait till until you try the cheese. I don’t know how they do it, because they’re also the least expensive pizza! I’ve never had a bad experience here, you won’t be disappointed.
(Ordered: Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza / Large - $15 🤯)“

“my favorite pizza by far!“

“If you’ve never ordered from here Do not let the owner on the phone throw you off. He’s just short and to the point on the phone. In person he’s a really cool guy and makes really good pizza! Him and his wife started their pizza shop 46 years ago. All the ingredients are fresh and tasty. Give it a try!“

“We love ordering from Romeo’s….super quick….delish and always hot & made properly. We always request lightly baked and they have always followed thru. The variety of sauces available are also great for variety. Thank-you for cooking for us!“

“I ordered delivery at the edge of their range primetime on a Friday night, the food arrived in the stated time warm and correct. A great option for delivery with there not being much around. One of the best pizza companies around and will definitely be ordering again.“

“Home made pasta is supberb!“

“I’ve never had a bad experience at this store PJ this time did a wonderful job of helping me out and gave me a few tips for the next time i order because i always ask for uncut but most of the time i get it cut. PJ customer service was outstanding“

“The menu offers a great variety of appetizers, salads, and entrees. Service and staff are efficient, professional, courteous, and just plain on top of their roles. It is a great atmosphere and extremely well managed! Great job, all who participated in serving a party of 16 on Sunday!“

“Ordered pizza and subs. Food was great and ready on time. Staff was friendly. Will be back!“

“I order some pizza for a party I was having and wow did Georgio's come through. Reasonably priced pizza and amazing taste. Everyone loved them! We are customers for life!! Also, you can't be $5 fresh and ready. Top notch customer service!“

“Drove almost an hour to come try this place. And it did not disappoint! The food was absolutely delicious! We got 2 Impossible burgers that were great the onions and pickles were delicious on the burgers, 2 loaded fries which were incredible they were our favorite part of the meal, and 2 chocolate shakes which were also very good! Very friendly staff and the food came out quick. Would definitely recommend trying and will be back again!“

“Never disappointing ! Always something new to try off the menu. All very good.“

“Fast delivery! And even delivered during a storm. Thank you 🙏🏽 Chad & Staff!!! Greatly appreciate it!!!“

“One of the absolute best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life!!! 100000/10 recommend!! The fresh flavor pushed it over the top! Highly recommend. A new local favorite for us!“

“*Update: Due to Pizza Hut’s response, I have increased the rating to 4-Stars.Not a fan of this location. Despite the convenient late hours and amazing deals they offer, that’s about the only time it’s worth it (except maybe if you’re not a huge fan of pizza sauce).Their pizza is almost sauceless here, which accounts for most of the rating. I then began selecting “extra sauce” when ordering, but end up with a very small amount - only a slight smear…which for me, I don’t think tastes good. Even when ordering it well-done, the pizza just seems like it’s maybe cooked to a regular-bake, in my opinion.All of my orders have been ready on time nevertheless! I do always try to take care of the workers, and have given this location half a dozen tries too, but still have the same experience. I’ve ordered from both the app, and the website as well, to be sure before reviewing.All-in-all, the hand tossed pizza is pretty mediocre taste-wise I would say…but the value is certainly worth it - but only when using a coupon. Staff is friendly, no complaints there.*HOWEVER* The pan pizza, which I’ve just tried for the first time (believe it or not), is pretty amazing! Or could’ve been, but I digress. Their boneless wings are also good, sometimes.“

“Very nice resteraunt in the heart of Gates Mills. We had two very solid cocktails, the navy bean soup and Thai Lemengrass pot stickers to start. All solid. For mains, we ordered the blackened grouper special with mustard sauce and a center cut steak. Both were specials and came with string beans and mashed potatoes. Beans were cooked to perfection, mashed potatoes were really good, steak was super tender and tasty, and the Grouper filet was really big and broiled perfectly. We tried the lemon marcapone cake and it was also very good.“

“The service and food was wonderful! I had their sloppy Joe and it was delicious! Everyone at our table enjoyed their meals. My only comment is the noise level was high but fortunately we were away from the bar and first row of seating so we were able to carry on a conversation at normal voice level. We will return again!“

“SMASH BURGER ✅ CHICKEN FINGERS ✅ STEVE’s TACO✅ FRIES ✅ Great food, cute patio for a quick bite! Tasty, informal dining and friendly service!“

“I moved to town a year ago. This was the first pizza place I tried and I was more then surprised with the quality and price of the food. Everything is sooo delicious and priced so everything is affordable. The staff is lovely, polite , friendly and helpful with your order. The food is always cooked to perfection. I recommend Capps in Chardon to everyone.“

“So, pizza pie is so authentic and good but an extra surprise was an amazing cocktail called a spicy jalapeno margarita! best!!!!!“

“This is truly great place. We will be back soon.“

“Ashley SAVED my deployment party for my husband. We had a food truck that cancelled three hours before the event for 175 people. I frantically asked Master Pizza for help in any way they could provide. They went above and beyond and saved my party. I can’t thank them enough!“

“Ive been using this dominos for about 2 years and they have always been consistent! Recently there was a hiccup with my order, and the pizza I received was not up to par. After calling and stating my issue, Tyler was absolutely wonderful and did a phenomenal job helping me with the issue I had. A replacement pizza was sent, and it was absolutely wonderful! Tyler even followed up to ensure the pizza was up to par! Phenomenal staff here who always seek to make sure customers are happy!

-Thank you Tyler! You do an amazing job!!!“

“Chardon pizza hut is absolutely awesome! Great staff and friendly people.“

“Been here several times. Always great food, good selection of appetizers, cold drinks, and amazing dessert options. 10/10 would recommend.“

“pizza is amazing! 10/10 reccomend!“