4 Best Pizza Restaurants near Payne

“I would give ten stars if I could! My husband works in Payne and has brought me home quite a few things off the menu and it never disappoints. I've been to the physical location once and everyone is so friendly! Food is phenomenal! My favorite is the Cuban sandwich (called Hav-A-Tampa on the menu) soo good!“

“DELICIOUS PIZZA!!! The breadsticks were sooooo good! I recommend getting both the beer cheese AND the queso and you will NOT be sorry. The shop owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Be sure to take a moment to appreciate the beautiful photographs of the local community that the shop owner herself photographed. Thank you for a wonderful meal!“

“I'm in town visiting family--Picked up a large pepperoni with extra cheese Thanksgiving eve.Located right downtown in the metropolis of Antwerp next to the gun shop!Papa Oley's has a variety of sandwiches and Italian fare...pizza, strombolis, spaghetti, etc...giant cookies on the counter. The pizza had ample cheese and sauce...could have used a little more pepperoni, but wasn't bad. They use a conveyor oven and IMO the crust could have cooked a couple more minutes just to firm up. Still, the pizza was really good. Pizza was $14…a great deal and much better than most chain pizza shops. Stop in if passing through town.“

“Holy wow is all I have to say. My husband ordered carryout tonight from there and it was amazing. We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom thing crust. It was perfect. Sauce was best I've had on a pizza ever!! It was cooked perfectly. We also ordered a large Italian grinder and they added banana peppers for my side as well as Italian dressing. It was one of the best grinders I've had since Lexys. Hands down. Also had the Bosco sticks. Omg. The cheese sauce that comes with them is a delicious bonus. There are a few pizza joints closer to us, but none of them we have tried have the same quality or taste. Plus the prices are affordable and very reasonable. Will definitely be our first choice from now on. Keep doing the darn thing guys. Thank you for amazing foods“