36 Best American Restaurants near Plain City

“I’ve always enjoyed my experience at City BBQ. Their sandwiches are always top notch, and the cheese fries today were a great addition. I came in right before dinner rush, but I had very little wait time and the food was hot. With the prices and atmosphere, this is my favorite BBQ in the Dublin area.“

“Every time we have eaten here,the food is fantastic!! They have buffet or menu items all day. Breakfast & Lunch/Dinner. I love browsing the gift shop, the wall hangings for sell in the hallways and, of course, the goodies for enjoying at home. Baked goods, fresh butter, apple butter, on & on. We live close to an hour away, but make the drive a couple times thru the year, usually, to treat ourselves. There are also a couple shops along the way that I would like to stop by sometime if we would leave earlier in the afternoon.Wheelchair accessibility: There is plenty of space in the building for those in wheelchairs. The only area not accessible may be the upstairs portion of the gift shop, unless there is an elevator I didn't notice.“

“EDIT: Still a great joint, but there has to be a way to improve the seating process during busy times. There's nowhere to stand or sit, and they won't seat anyone at the round table in the back. I stood for 40 minutes with two others and half the time that table was empty. The whole counter up front should be removed to make room for customers waiting. It's truly an awful experience coming to Olympic Diner when it's busy.A rare bird of a restaurant, a local, classic diner, but with genuinely good food and service. The owning family all work there and are extremely friendly and ever present. They will remember who you are.“

“The service was excellent. Nick was fast and friendly. Checked on the table to make sure everything was okay and drinks were fresh. Broccoli was amazing and delicious!!! The place looked awesome inside and was clean as new!!! :)The only down side was the meats on my order.The steak was cooked to medium on one side and burnt on the other. The ribs were the same way. Burnt all the way down the curve.“

“Kim was our waitress. She did great, but seemed to be servicing maybe too many tables? We certainly would go back. Our food dollars and one glass of wine each, husband and I split a salmon and friend had her own salmon salad. Bill was $90. We did not have apps or dessert either!“

“Rusty Bucket is our go to restaurant. I appreciate that they have reservations when so many other places do not. The atmosphere is fun, the menu has a good variety, and they have good kids meal with a bookmark deal. My daughter's school just completed a read a thon so she was able to easily redeem her free kids meal this time. I always get a brown bag beer and it's fun to see what is inside; even the servers like to find out with me. We never have to wait too long for our food and the servers have been consistently good. The food is good and there is something for everyone. Oh, and I recommend getting the fried pickles but sliced not speared which they will do if you ask.“

“A nice place. Seemed clean and had friendly people working. The place seems to attract locals for their trivia games. My daughter ordered the bbq wings, while her husband had the buffalo wings. I had a 1/4 sub called the pistol without the bun. Everything was good. If you are in the area and want a relaxed, fun place, this is it.“

“Great food today. Double mushroom and Swiss burger with onion rings, and my wife had the cod meal with pretzel bites! Hit the spot! We followed up with a sundae and shake. Great taste! The highlight of our visit was the manager overhearing my wife mentioning lemons for her water, and he went and got her some- excellent customer service !“

“Visited 4/19/24 for dinner ordered a country fried steak which was 95% breading and 5% "meat" very disappointed sides were a smaller portion as well as my wife's side salad. I guess like everywhere else things have gone downhill I am just happy I had a GC to use.“

“The food is delicious. It's the only good place to get a good malt around here. The cashiers are friendly but not great at their tasks. Every visit I order the same thing and the price is different every visit. Please train your order takers better. Just ringing 3 items does not a basket make. Today A double bacon deluxe "basket" with a medium chocolate malt was $21 and some change. ??‍♂️ I'm going to order via the app from now on.“

“Food is always good, plus they have my favorite beer - Ky Bourbon Barrel Ale - on tap. Our waitress did an excellent job, and the support staff stopped by several times. It can get a little loud, they may want to consider adding acoustic tiles in the ceiling to absorb sound“

“Was able to see multiple tvs to watch March Madness from anywhere. Clean. Staff was polite. Food was average, nothing bad just wouldn’t make a trip just for the food. Tried multiple pizzas and subs. Was there for a party and it was a great location. Rained so couldn’t play corn hole, but it was set up. Everyone had a GREAT “

“Great place for some cold beer, good food. The staff is always friendly and helpful. They have great wings and the last time I was there I had their fried shrimp appetizer. Was really good. For those sports fans, there are plenty of TV's and seating. Definitely a place to check out.“

“We had the french toast, elevated egg sandwich, and million dollar bacon. All items were very good! I personally liked the French toast the most. The candied bacon was a little limp for my preference, but my fiancé loved it! Overall, would come again! 3 stars for service because we felt rushed by our server.“

“Super delicious. Took four boys in here and only one could finish they were so big. Got the pbj buger with sweet potato fries. It was delicious- would for sure order again. Limited menu only sandwiches mostly burgers and three salads but made it easier to order. Cute little place.“

“It has expanded since it first opened years ago. The layout is inviting and seems to cater to a wide variety of crowds (genX - genZ). The service is what you'd expect from any other sports bar, the bartenders are personable and attentive.The food is bar food, which isn't a bad thing, especially served with alcohol and alcohol, so enjoy.Prices are reflective of the current economy, inflation and supply issues make going out a little more tight, but this place was worth the hangout.“

“We had a large group and we were able to get the back room, we had 10-15 kids and another 10 adults. Our server was awesome, everything came out in a timely fashion. All drinks were filled, and food was delicious!!Kid-friendliness: We had an entire soccer team with us in between games.“

“This place is my fiancés heaven on earth. A timely place that was previously a cabin (can learn more about the stories from a book there explaining its origin). A cozy and homing feeling.... areas where u can eat.... the carriage house in the front section was part of the original cabin. Ever holiday or change of season, they have those types of seasonal gifts. It's a happy and calming place to be and experience. She got me hooked, as she started coming here as a child for every occasion.... sometimes just to feel happy! Be prepared to enjoy being there a while....we are usually there for hours. Highly recommend and hope that others get to experience the magic and light that she does from this place!“

“We went for lunch and were pleasantly surprised with the lunch combo meal ( choice of 2 soup, salad, flatbread or some sandwiches) We received 3 slices of flatbread and a good sized helping of their Millers salad for 12.99. It was a filling lunch and I had plenty of shrimp and tasso on my flatbread. Food was fresh and tasty with good service I'd definitely order the lunch combo again.“

“The Hilliard Yabo’s is an awesome place to eat and hang out with friends. The food and drinks are very good. They also have held a few bourbon tastings there also. You get to taste bourbon and learn a little more about it. They also pair up a taco that goes well with each of the bourbons. It was very well organized, informative and just plain fun! Can’t wait to do it again!! So if you’re looking for a great taco place, don’t hesitate to stop in and try the Hilliard Yabo’s!Parking: Plenty of parking in front of Yabo’s and in a lot across the street from them.“

“I went bowling here with these 5 super hot blondes. I loved it! The workers were very kind and sweet. Owen and Tyson especially showed a lot of kindness. The food was amazing too. Well only I had food. I didn't let the hot blondes get any food cause I didn't want them to ruin their breath!! HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA“

“Such a fun place to hang with the family for the afternoon. We went with our teenagers and their friends and got two lanes. Recommendation for parents - 1 hour bowling is plenty. Food is great and our waitress was very attentive with great service.“

“Love this little mom and pop place! Set right in the middle of downtown Hilliard,ohio, its a great place to eat and very welcoming. The staff make you feel like they know who you are from the moment you sit down, and are always willing to do what they can to help make the most of your experience w them! Would highly recommend!“

“My family and I, a group of 17 people, had lunch together at this restaurant. The restaurant is not very spacious, and we had to sit closely together at an L-shaped table to accommodate everyone. The ambiance appeared clean, except for the restrooms which needed some attention. The food we ordered arrived promptly, and the service was friendly with reasonable prices. However, the portion sizes were not substantial, and a few of us still felt hungry after the meal. The taste of the food varied depending on what each person ordered.“

“The burgers are so good! Juicy and delicious.. And the fries are just out of this world as long as they're hot and fresh. I would have loved to give a 5 star review but service has been iffy a couple times. This one female waitress we had one time was pretty bad. The food took over an hour to get and when the food came out, it wasnt fresh. Not that it's her fault but atleast an acknowledgement would've been nice. And no drink refills, no checking on us. But the last time we went, the service was outstanding, like 200% good, so it made up for the bad. Overall though it's a great restaurant.“

“This is the newest Old Bag of Nails and is certainly worth checking out. It's a spacious restaurant with an old-English vibe (unlike some of the others I've been to and my favorite thus far). The food was satisfying, and the service was great. I got the french onion soup and a side salad while my BF ordered the fish and chips. We came on Sunday for lunch, so it all worked out well for us.“

“great atmosphere...great eats IMHO...OBON's fish tacos rank amongst the best around. Other great dishes are the fish&chips, Cobb salad. For a pub it's not noisy like so many others...sound is dampened just right to be able to enjoy a meal at a table/booth with a great bar layout to hang with a crowd.“

“Great atmosphere a lot of happy employees very refreshing I work for Waffle House for 10 years they did a great job... I had a T-bone and eggs the eggs were perfectly prepared the toast was crispy and hot the T-bone was cooked to perfection and that is real hard with that thin T-Bone...“

“We absolutely love this place! The atmosphere is really nice, the happy hour menu has a different dish for every weekday at a great price, and the burgers are amazing! In particular, we really enjoyed the Nashvegss burger. I am a sucker with anything with pimento cheese. The bacon on this burger is so delicious too. This is going to be a place we frequent!“

“Parking: We stopped in here on our way thru Ohio. We had a very pleasant experience. We were immediately seated and our waiter was with us shortly after. Food came out quick and exactly as expected. The banana bread is the best part. Also purchased a candle for the first time. It is so fragrant and slow burning. Can't wait to come back again.“

“Great customer service from Lui very nice guy he was great with my son as we waited and I asked him some questions about where he was from and how long he's been doing it and it was nice the food is hot and fresh and there's tons of food on the gyro for sure? definitely will be coming back“

“Great place. The food is awesome and the drinks amazing. The staff are friendly.Vegetarian options: Not sure if there is an actual menu section for vegetarians, yet I know they can substitute a meat for cauliflower or tofu.Dietary restrictions: Just let the server know. Most items made from scratch so this is an easy fix.Parking: There is one row of parking right in front of the townhomes...don't be rude and take one of those places. People live thereKid-friendliness: Awesome place for kids to come as wellWheelchair accessibility: Plenty of wheelchair accessible entrances“

“Went to watch a bowl game and the atmosphere was the same as a TGI Friday's or Chili's. The service was good but lagged towards closing time (to be expected), though the kitchen closed an hour before the doors did.The food is ok, the wings were a little dry and several flavors were unavailable. I doubt i'd go back, but that's mostly a distance thing.“

“First time eating here, brunch with friends. We went on labor day and it wasn't very crowded. Google maps said it was closed so I almost went elsewhere. The waitstaff was great. The gentleman that was busing the tables was very knowledgeable about the history of the restaurant and the buildings in town. We enjoyed the bit of history lesson. The food was good and there was no issues with how it came out.“

“Walking in the place is dead. There was no one in the bar area but a kid. Probably an employees. There one only two tables outside that had customers at. The staff so far is very friendly. We had Dweep, very nice and funny. Covered the bar area. They played some very good music. Beer very cold the pub burger was very good had flavor but not overwhelming. The wings definitely were good. Bbq was generic but very baby was very good had a kick to it. Not to overbearing. My mom's gyro was excellent. Seem like the chef is on point with Greek food. The bologna sandwich was very good to my dad said he would order it again. So far no disappointment. Staff was not lazy always around. Dweep was here when we need anything. Overall we really liked it 4.5 starts for us. Always room for improvement. No complaints from us.“

“The waitress Breana took my order to go , and was very polite , and wrote my order down right . The kitchen did a great job with my food , everything was there and delicious ?. The guy at the register got my waitress when I came in .Parking: Parking there are about 40 parking spots , and also about 5 curbside pickup parking spots . The parking lot is got a good amount of lighting , that lights up the parking lot . I do think they need to redo the parking lot pavement, and some of the small chuck holes, but other than that the parking lot is great.“