26 Best Italian Restaurants near Sylvania

“First Italian restaurant I have been to since I have been here. This place is awesome. Nicole took care of me and she was awesome. Best service I have had since I have been Ohio. Food was excellent. The couple playing live music, were fun and sounded great. I loved everything about this place.“

“Service n food was outstanding“

“Very cozy atmosphere. Interesting & diverse menu. Love everything from their freshly made soups to salads to pizza to pasta to stromboli!! If you just want appetizers & a glass of wine you have LOTZ of unique options!! Good wait staff. Nice neighborhood dining spot.“

“My wife and I went there for our anniversary. Little bit of a wait for the food but we expected it out of a smaller kitchen and one chef. But boy was it worth it. It’s not listed below to select but, I had the Butchers Ragu and it was fantastic.“

“Star provided us with the BEST service we have had since COVID. She was so kind and friendly, food came quickly and was delicious and correct. She hooked us up and took great care of us. This was our first time visiting this location and we will back just for her!!“

“November 1, 2025
I would like to compliment Emily. She was our waitress. There were 12 of us, she was awesome, professional and kind. She took care of us. I felt comfortable as if I were home 🏡 being spoiled by a wonderful hostess!!
Thanks Emily
John and Kim D
Massachusetts“

“I've not been to this location. I just want everyone to know this is the best food I ever had (and im a big time foodie). We miss you Piada in Michigan!! The one in Troy MI used to have a big line at lunch wrapped around the building even day. What happened? Go here and the food will not disappoint! I may have to travel to Toledo just for Piada! Enjoy 😉“

“Excellent hummus and lemon chicken soup. I bounce back and forth between the shawarma and tawook, but they are both great!“

“We normally like everything at Sideline’s but today ordered the shrimp fettuccine. Normally very good. Today it was so salty you couldn’t eat it. The manager came out a blamed it a the prep chef. They did offer to make another meal. The issue I had was they kept serving that sauce to other customers. Someone is going to get very sick.. I can’t believe a real chef would continue to serve that.“

“Service was great, food was pretty good as usual. The portions are getting a lot smaller. My son likes going there for his birthday so we go every year. I always get the tour of Italy. It used to fill the entire plate. Today. The chicken parmesan was very small and the serving of lasagna was also very small. Not impressed. Tasted great but not impressed with the quantity.“

“The food here is always fantastic but the new expansion just elevated our experience. Stellar service by Anika and one of the new owners stopped by to chat. Bonus: everything was toddler approved! Will be making this one of our regular spots.“

“We are frequent guests at Mancy’s Italian, and every visit reminds us why we keep coming back — the food, the service, and the atmosphere are always excellent. Most recently, we hosted my daughter’s baby shower here, and it was absolutely fantastic from start to finish.

Kim, the event planner, was incredible. She was organized, attentive, and made the entire planning process stress-free. She truly went above and beyond to make sure every detail was perfect.

Our waitresses, Dina and Aubree, were amazing as well — friendly, professional, and so attentive to our guests. They made everyone feel comfortable and well taken care of throughout the entire event.

The baby shower was beautiful, seamless, and memorable, and we received so many compliments from our guests. Thank you to the entire team for making such a special day even more special. We can’t wait to return (again and again!)“

“Have been going here for along time. First time ordering pizza though. I ordered extra sauce which I did not get and only ate a few slices. I asked to get extra sauce to take home and the waitress said it would cost $2.00 more. But she wasn’t sure. We had to ask again about the sauce after we paid the bill. She said they would not give us extra sauce!! Hmmm!! Really? So for all you that like extra sauce on your pizza… they don’t do that! Also, the waitress never took any of our dirty dishes away.“

“This is my first time trying your veggie pizza and it is the best I’ve ever had. Thank you for the great experience and the awesome pizza“

“Great presentation and toppings on the Greek Pizza! 10/10“

“We had a Celebration of Life for my brother Jeff Fyock on Saturday July 27th. Everyone was so impressed with the event & how the girls we had kept me informed all evening. Growing up in South Toledo alot of our guests said that your pizza tasted like the old Gino's on Arlington Ave. This is my 3rd event that I've had @ Capers. Please give your staff a high five for helping my family make memories.“

“Love Vito’s, it’s always good. I probably come here every other week and I’m always pleased. They have great Tuesday specials with a different specialty pizza every week at a great price. It isn’t a sit down restaurant, so I can’t really say anything about atmosphere, but it’s fine for take out.“

“This is undoubtedly the best pizza I have ever had… I could seriously become addicted to this pie!“

“Pizza is ALWAYS delicious!! Staff is super friendly & helpful! Can never go wrong with a BBQ Chicken pizza 😉😍“

“Food is always hot and good. Friendly fast service. They have a small bar area, large dining. We love going there. Highly recommend the special pizza.“

“Perfect date night meal! Food was excellent and prices definitely reasonable. Service was good, and the time waiting for our meal was pleasantly spent watching the game and chatting. We will be back for sure!“

“hands down the best Gino's in the entire city. if you disagree, I can't trust your judgment on pretty much anything in existence“

“I can't speak for the food/order just yet but the person I spoke to on the phone - Doyle, was excellent. Very friendly and helpful. If I had a business and needed someone to answer customer calls - I would want to hire him! Hoping all goes well tomorrow with the order!!“

“Hands down the BEST pizza and wings our family has had in quite awhile. The prices are affordable, the staff friendly & attentive, and the atmosphere is family friendly. Kudos to having baked wings, healthy and/or dietary friendly options! Pictured is a personal pepp/sausage & XL gyro.“

“I just renewed but need to add something. I am not able to drive due to epalepsy and it is nice to be able to have pizza every once in a while. Thank you for delivering to me. You are six minutes away from my house. The Marcose on South Ave. is closer but they won't deliver.“

“Big menu.... Great food.... Great prices...And the GM is pretty sweet!!“