25 Best Italian Restaurants in Toledo

“Me and my sister we're here Monday night for a benefit dinner. It has been a while since we have made it here. We had a amazing evening Our server Brandy was Outstanding. Our drinks remained full , tables cleared and she was an absolute pleasure. Our food was amazing as always. Thank you for the amazing service and evening. We will be back“

“My wife and I went there for our anniversary. Little bit of a wait for the food but we expected it out of a smaller kitchen and one chef. But boy was it worth it. It’s not listed below to select but, I had the Butchers Ragu and it was fantastic.“

“On 7-15-25, we were served by Samantha and she did an outstanding job. Samantha was fast, friendly, efficient, checked on us frequently, and helped my with my gift card payment. This Toledo Olive Garden location in general is my favorite location. Thank You Samantha and Good Job!❤️👍👏“

“Please don't expect to get service at the window, even if you order ahead online. Apparently, walk-in customers will be priority then you will be "behind" all of them. We waited 18 minutes and online it says this is a time that is less busy than usual and usually no wait. One make your own bowl was missing a lot of the veggies selected. Pepperoni stick was not even wrapped. But we got a free cookie for our $46 order

Vegetarian options: Options available

Parking: Plenty of available parking

Wheelchair accessibility: Right in front, I believe“

“Love this place, definitely one of our favorites. Arrived 5.30ish on a Thursday - as is our norm we sat at the bar. Server made a point of letting us know about their happy hour (so we could order a second drink before it ended).

Hubs had the fettuccine bolognese and I had the salmon with gnocchi. We both had a side dinner salad which were cold and crisp. Hubs said his dinner was delicious. My salmon was perfectly cooked, gnocchi was soft and tender.

Waitress/bartender was nice - it appeared that she was the only waitstaff that evening. Watched her with other guests - provided good service to everyone.“

“Very cozy atmosphere. Interesting & diverse menu. Love everything from their freshly made soups to salads to pizza to pasta to stromboli!! If you just want appetizers & a glass of wine you have LOTZ of unique options!! Good wait staff. Nice neighborhood dining spot.“

“The fettuccine alfredo & tortellini wasn’t worth the price. The tortellini reminded me of chef Boyardee in a can. I recommend the Italian food at Antonio’s Italian cuisine or Olive Garden. The waitress was very polite, the atmosphere was great, however I wouldn’t eat any Italian dishes from here again.“

“Excellent friendly service, good traditional Italian cuisine, for a decent price. Will be back for sure.“

“Overall good experience at this Olive Garden. Hadn't been to one in a long time but the revamped menu made sense with solid Italian entree choices. Our waitress Jax was super great and very friendly. I had spaghetti and meat sauce which was good, sauce needed more meat I thought. I got sauteed shrimp on it as well and those were tasty. My wife got the Five Cheese Ziti al forno and that looked and tasted good. We both got the sausage potato soup which was a pleasant surprise. Breadsticks were ok, marinara we got with them was nothing special. My wife got an Italian margarita and that was nicely made. If you have a hankering for Italian and want good value, Olive Garden is your place!“

“Excellent hummus and lemon chicken soup. I bounce back and forth between the shawarma and tawook, but they are both great!“

“There are barely enough adjectives to describe how incredible Mancy’s Italian is. The dining area has a lot of ambiance, cozy booths, romantic lighting, classy artwork.
Hostess greeted us warmly, asked our seating preference. Our waitress arrived within 10-15 seconds with ice water and offered a wine list/cocktail menu. Nice wine list with plenty of by the glass options. (They have a bottle shop attached to the restaurant). Drinks were served within a few minutes, waitress brought bread with dipping oil at the same time.
For our appetizer we chose to split the zucchini bruschetta and it was delicious, will definitely be attempting at home. Della casa salad was excellent - fresh, crispy lettuce with a light and flavorful dressing served on chilled plates (which I really appreciate). Hubs had the summer squash pasta with added grilled chicken. I had the diavolo pasta - perfectly cooked lobster and shrimp, asparagus and mushrooms in a spicy lobster sauce - saying it was incred doesn’t do it justice. Would definitely order again.
Both the service and the food definitely live up to the Mancy reputation!“

“Have been going here for along time. First time ordering pizza though. I ordered extra sauce which I did not get and only ate a few slices. I asked to get extra sauce to take home and the waitress said it would cost $2.00 more. But she wasn’t sure. We had to ask again about the sauce after we paid the bill. She said they would not give us extra sauce!! Hmmm!! Really? So for all you that like extra sauce on your pizza… they don’t do that! Also, the waitress never took any of our dirty dishes away.“

“As a new Toledoan, I had the chance to check out one of the city’s oldest restaurants. It’s like walking into a different time period - a restaurant like no other in town. There’s a train car that goes through the center of the restaurant, old school Tiffany’s style lamps and almost like a saloon meets checkered tablecloth vibe. The team has been working there for years - some even 20+! Service is small-town friendly, there are plenty of rooms for big parties and 4 tops alike and the prices are great. There’s currently a BOGO deal for entire pasta entrees. The kitchen is a mostly scratch kitchen with the exception of then breads and pastas which are made in large pasta pots in the kitchen. The garlic butter is amazing and the lasagna and chicken parm were my two fav dishes. The Lambrusco is a yummy wine choice, and they offer Chianti and Pinot noir along with some others. This isn’t the fanciest meal you’ll have in town, but the sauce is good, the chicken is cooked perfectly on the Alfredo and the parm, and the prices are right. Come here for fun events like murder mystery parties and comedy shows on weekends! Also a perfect venue for group parties or showers.“

“Great presentation and toppings on the Greek Pizza! 10/10“

“This is my first time trying your veggie pizza and it is the best I’ve ever had. Thank you for the great experience and the awesome pizza“

“We had a Celebration of Life for my brother Jeff Fyock on Saturday July 27th. Everyone was so impressed with the event & how the girls we had kept me informed all evening. Growing up in South Toledo alot of our guests said that your pizza tasted like the old Gino's on Arlington Ave. This is my 3rd event that I've had @ Capers. Please give your staff a high five for helping my family make memories.“

“Pizza is ALWAYS delicious!! Staff is super friendly & helpful! Can never go wrong with a BBQ Chicken pizza 😉😍“

“This is undoubtedly the best pizza I have ever had… I could seriously become addicted to this pie!“

“hands down the best Gino's in the entire city. if you disagree, I can't trust your judgment on pretty much anything in existence“

“Had very good service there. Called in advance about some allergy questions. Brandon was very helpful. When I came in and ordered, Adrian was on point. I'm a former gm of another pizza joint. Respect“

“Food was spectacular, pizza is amazing, my 13 year old said "the food was "gas, low key". He explained that it means it's bussin.🙄 but yeah, I recommend it!“

“The staff here was great! I ordered takeout and sat in my car to wait. The lady came out with my order to find me! That was unexpected and appreciated! I've mentioned this to others and they also had positive things to say about their staff. Kudos to you all. It's refreshing to have people who provide such great service! Thank you!“

“I can't speak for the food/order just yet but the person I spoke to on the phone - Doyle, was excellent. Very friendly and helpful. If I had a business and needed someone to answer customer calls - I would want to hire him! Hoping all goes well tomorrow with the order!!“

“pizza & Wings... fast and easy to get..“

“Big menu.... Great food.... Great prices...And the GM is pretty sweet!!“