50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Upper Arlington

“So Bazemore Pizza Co. Is located inside Pointe Tavern in Upper Arlington Ohio.

Italian Sub - This was thee best take on a classic sub I have ever had. I’m still trying to figure out how something so simple and yet it tastes so complex? Like the taste of Bazemore’s Italian sub was absolutely F’n phenomenal! The bun had a crispy crust and the inside was warm and delight, everything inside was straight magic!

The Margarita Pizza - 1st off, full disclosure I should note that I came here mainly because the place was featured on One Bite and the fact Dave Portnoy gave it an amazing review. So yeah, I had to come and it’s worth the drive from Westerville to Upper Arlington. Just look at the picture! If that doesn’t tell you what it tastes like, then nothing will!

Chicken Wings - Classic Buffalo, Dank Dust Dry Rub (🔥 my favorite), Juli-Q (2nd fav)

Italian Meat Balls - These MF’ers melt in your mouth, just get them!

So I actually got to meet Billy & Todd, great guys. I just need them to move closer to my side of town.“

“Pizza is amazing! Staff is amazing! We're fans for life!“

“The BEST pizza!!! If you’re looking for pizza on game day, this is your place. Nothing more I want in a deep dish pizza, great flavor. It’s not cheap, but it’s a decent, price, especially for the flavor you’re getting. They have a good variety of options so you’ll find what you’re looking for!“

“I never order online, but I haven't been feeling well. I was not disappointed. I got exactly what I ordered, it was delicious! My delivery driver was so kind and amazing! I also thank you because he is an employee for you, I appreciated that. Working in a pizza place is not easy! You did an awesome job Marco's. Grace and blessings always, for you and your employees.“

“I ordered on the app and selected square cut, then picked up my order and brought it home only to find out it was the regular pie cut. Aside from that though, the pizza was perfectly good. I can emphatically recommend the garlic infused crust.“

“Delicious NY-style pizza! Whenever I want pizza, this is my go-to. The customer service is very nice when I pick up my order. I ordered delivery once, and it was also a great customer service experience. Five stars!“

“When are you guys going to come into this century and sign up with GrubHub or DoorDash? You'd definitely increase your profits. Driving to pick up food is old school, LOL!!“

“The food/pizza is amazing!“

“Fantastic Stromboli’s and high quality to detail, give it a try!!“

“Good pizza. Sausage was delicious 😋“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“Re. the Grandview location - Great food. But, building is just fair. It is freezing in there this time of year (late Fall/Winter). With the high ceilings, any heat never makes it to the patrons inside (please learn to use your ceiling fans to help with this). Also, having doors that open straight to the outside doesn't help. Each time they are opened, it is a blast of cold air for half the establishment.“

“Relaxing, entertaining & fun. The food is adequate.“

“This is one of the best pizza joints in the greater Columbus area. We got the breakfast pizza and some of their appetizers and were in LOVE. One suggestion I would make is to increase the lighting for the booths on the bar side of the restaurant.“

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“Fantastic Stromboli’s and high quality to detail, give it a try!!“

“Okay... Lesson #1... DON'T USE DOORDASH. Text came in Spanish, 2 drivers fighting over me... Late Pizza. Wonderful Young Lady answering my question on The Phone says Order Thursday through Sunday to Order Directly from a HardWorking, better actual Employee Driving... Lesson #2... HOW MUCH FOR JUST A CAN OF SODA POP?!? OUTRAGEOUS!! When I was your age... I expected a 2 Liter for nearly $3... Making America Great Again means Saving America at Home in The Great Buckeye State Saving Money... IT'S HAPPENING NOW... TRUMP EFFECT!!💥 KA POW!!💥 LOWER FOOD COSTS IN PROGRESS...✔️ THE ONE BITE PIZZA/BARSTOOL PIZZA DUDE, DAVE, HIGHLY RECOMMENDED AND HE IS SO RIGHT!! First time I had Emilio's was a Meet & Greet The CANDIDATE last Summer. 2nd time TONIGHT. I'm dieing of Congestive Heart Failure and no chance in Hell I'll ever Date again but... if I did find a Conservative Trump Supporting Star Trek lovin' Lady this Pizza would be on our "Let's get it on Menu..." THANK YOU!! COWABUNGA!! TURTLE & GREMLIN POWER!! FORGET THE RULES... EAT AFTER MIDNIGHT!! EXCITEMENT!!“

“We are from out of town and wanted to try a local pizza place. It WAS AMAZING! The food tasted GREAT, the service was exceptional. We even bought a giant jar of jelepenos to take back home. Next time we sre in the area, we will be stopping here again!“

“After working with the front and back staff for over a year I get to see how everything is running as far as receiving all the foods and produce in the back I know everything is kept very clean and organized in a busy kitchen with all the preps and cooks working together. Out front we have a bunch of young awsome experienced ladies always working together and keeping all the customers Happy and Full. The Food and staffs are second to none😎“

“First and absolutely not our last visit. Very enjoyable margarita pizza with fresh arugula, perfect crust, great flavor, delicious. We started with a lightly fried artichokes and potatoes with a lemon aioli, very good. This is one of the best pizza restaurants in the Columbus area! Great service with Rachel as well.“

“Love Dewey’s!! Their house salad is my favorite.“

“We had so much fun here today! Delicious pizza and so kind to us - my 5-year-old had a blast!“

“The food is great - we’ve tried most of their pizzas and the antipasti salad is to die for. Unfortunately I can’t speak as highly about the staff. On several occasions, usually on Sundays when they close at 7, I’ve gotten my food close to 7 but NEVER after 7. I’ve placed orders for pick-up at 6:45 and if I wasn’t there at 6:45 on the dot I’ve been called being harassed to get my food because they close at 7. Today I went in at 6:50 and they had already put everything away, taken out the trash, and sanitized everything and gave me lip about wanting to place my order (1 pizza and 1 salad). They proceeded to loudly complain to each other while making my order. Closing at 7 means you stop taking customers at 7 - not that staff gets to walk out the door and lock it behind them at 7.“

“A huge shout out to Romeo’s for absolutely nailing my lunch order today! Everything was perfect!“

“Very good pizza and bosco sticks, amazing customer service!“

“we love this place.we order from here alot. there food is so tasty and the people who run it are so very nice“

“I’ve been going to Rubino‘s for about 40 years. The pizzas is great. I love the thin crust and how the store hasn’t changed a bit. Looks just like it did in the 80s.“

“We had a pizza party with 17 difference pizzas and Cardinals was voted the best pizza! Pizza came from all over central Ohio. Figured I would leave this review so everyone knows that it’s just that good!“

“I don’t want to remove a star because your pickle pizza is dreamy but you made me waste money on those stupid for profit parking lots that don’t even use the funds to repair the lots. The parking is like 11 dollars we found another one for 6 bucks for two hours walk up to Slammers and it’s locked. Everything says it’s open, the web site, Google, the door sign itself… we’re not rich, just wanted to have a beer and pizza after a really bad day and tried To call but there’s no way to leave a message… just boo that wasn’t cool. Next time make a sign when you don’t feel like opening up during your normal hours, think of your customers. *waaah*“

“I went on a fairly busy night, so service was a bit minimal but I was checked on and the server was friendly. I enjoyed the chicken bacon ranch pizza quite a bit, though the caprese salad was disappointing. The tomatoes were unripe. I'd probably do outdoor seating next time I visit when the weather cools off.“

“Romeo’s is delicious pizza and very kind! They donated pizza to our pop up shop event while we have away prom dresses this past weekend. We couldn’t ask for a better community partner!“

“We ordered from the new store in Galloway, Ohio. Pizza and sub was very hot and delicious. I highly recommend trying their food.“

“I absolutely LOVE Pies and Pints. The pizza is AMAZING and the staff is incredibly friendly and nice. I tried the white pizza once and won't get anything else. Absolutely incredible!!!“

“Not sure how this doesn't have five stars across the board. We drove from almost ten hours away and after scouring places to eat we decided to stop here. The crust is crisp, not soggy or tough with good flavor and thickness. You can't go wrong with fresh ingredients like the mozzarella and mushrooms (fresh not canned, wowee!) either. We also tried Gina's Gem and between the beautiful focaccia and the dip being creamy while also sweet with a small back burn to it, you really can't go wrong. The bar is a great place to sit, no spoilers, but the walls and shelves are filled with awesome and hilarious things that make good conversation. It's a shame this wonderful place is so far from home but we're hoping to make it a yearly tradition. Thanks for the great food, staff, and atmosphere!“

“This crew knocks it out of the park every time.“

“Amazing pizza and wonderful people !!!“

“Great pizza! Friendly service! I highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza!“

“Ordered the bourbon chicken pizza from here recently and it was incredible. Highly recommend it and I will definitely be ordering from here again soon.“

“We had really good pizza this afternoon. The 12 inch classic was perfect! It was nice having real fresh toppings on our pizza. The cinnamon dough(cinnaBrenz)with cream cheese was outstanding! Thank you to the man making the pizza who recommended this. We will definitely be coming back. 🍕 Anthony and Amanda“

“Classic Columbus Pizza! Worth the trip.“

“The Don Corleone w/ sausage and my delicious date Judy.“

“Stopped in for pizza...it was amazing. We will definitely be back“

“I love romeos. Their pizza is delicious! My only complaint is they got rid of their dine in which was cool. They had a party room with a hockey table and Need for Speed arcade cabinets (HP2 and U1). All that’s sadly gone but the pizza is still worth buying alone!“

“Dewey's Pizza in Dublin was a fantastic lunch spot! The servers were friendly, responsive, and efficient. The pizzas we ordered were unique and delicious. The pizza throwers behind the window were so engaging and my son had a blast watching them make a pizza man face, write in flour, and “accidentally“ throw things at the window. We highly recommend going there. We will return for sure!“

“Hands down this place has the best pizza in the State and maybe the country. I watched the Netflix special on the famous pizza makers in America, they missed this one!!!! It is perfect! Stromboli’s and calzones kick it up a notch as well! Great food, great customer service. I drove by 15 or more pizza places to great here. No reason not to!!!“

“I look for a thinner crust, crunch when. I bite into and an even brown. it was all that and more. Top 5!!“

“I 💚 their pizza! Have been ordering here for a long time.. The girls in the kitchen are sweet and very helpful. If alcohol is your thing, you can find it here as well, they have a bar. Popular place so parking can be an issue sometimes. Other than that, it's all good!!“

“Home for the Columbus Spurs. Been to a few games here now and its a great venue to watch live sports. Great crowd and lots of TV screens to watch the game.

There's a specific breakfast menu available until 10am and a much more extensive menu for later. The service was great, both the bar and table service were friendly and attentive. The Italian sub was excellent.

Well worth a visit if you're a Tottenham fan visiting Columbus or just passing by and looking for somewhere to eat.“

“Ordered from the W. 3rd location lastnight. The food was great!! Fast delivery, food was hot on arrival and the price was good as well!! Definitely recommend!“