50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Upper Arlington

“Got carryout last weekend. Picked up my favorite, the mushroom and got a margherita to try for the first time. Both were amazing and possibly even better the next day. I've never had a pizza from Bazemore that I didn't love. Shout out to the owner who came out to hand me my pies, it's great to see people who take such pride in their craft.“

“Pizza is amazing! Staff is amazing! We're fans for life!“

“The pizza is above average. The go out of their way to make the food just the way one wants it. The space is small designed for order pickup, or delivery. The thick crust is excellent, but we always get extra sauce, since they skimp on the marinara sometimes. Otherwise, we recommend Jet's for delicious pizza.“

“Food was prepared and ready in about half hour after placing the order. I waited outside in parking lot for takeout. Great customer service was mostly appreciated as people don’t tend to be so polite and kind these days, let alone “extra nice” isn’t to be expected but this cook/cashier guy was awesome! 👏🏾 He actually smiled, greeted, and offered condiments all on his own accord! Thanks for the good food, getting my order correct, and excellent customer service! I gave really good tip and feedback on the survey. Will definitely be back to this store location #Reed Road. 😍
To mention, please turn on some lights -it was quite desolate and too dark inside the restaurant made feel creepy and unsafe considering it was after 9:00 pm.“

“This location is the absolute best location in Columbus, hands down! As easy as it is to order online, we prefer to call due to the always friendly service, order accuracy, food quality and they even handle special requests like love notes written on the box from my husband. They will always be OUR Domino's! Keep up the good work guys 🙂“

“When are you guys going to come into this century and sign up with GrubHub or DoorDash? You'd definitely increase your profits. Driving to pick up food is old school, LOL!!“

“Relaxing, entertaining & fun. The food is adequate.“

“Delicious NY-style pizza! Whenever I want pizza, this is my go-to. The customer service is very nice when I pick up my order. I ordered delivery once, and it was also a great customer service experience. Five stars!“

“Crust is excellent! Variety of toppings - only place that has turkey pepperoni 🙌🏻 Will be back!“

“Good pizza. Sausage was delicious 😋“

“Was working in Columbus all weekend closest spot was Mikey‘s. We ate there three nights in a row. Great pizza and cold beers. Highly recommend I will be back.“

“I was recommended to try this place. I stopped on my way out of town and I'm not joking when I say it exceeded my expectations! The women who waited on us was so kind and made us feel welcome, the atmosphere was awesome and the pizza was astounding.“

“My husband and I wend here for the first time after moving our son into his apartment today and absolutely loved the food, the dining experience and the conversation with the owner while we sat at the bar watching our food be freshly made definitely 10 out of 10 and the fact that the ingredients are local and fresh was huge!!!“

“Absolutely the best pizza we had in a long, long time the margarita the cheese pizza were all lunch specials are really good and a must try. The restaurant is very chic from inside. The decor is very cozy. I’ll definitely return, the gentleman With long curly hair, who took care of us was fantastic“

“This is gotta be hands down. The best pizza and salad in Columbus period“

“The best and crunchiest pizza I have ever had! First time having it and it will definitely be number one on my list! The sub was loaded with meat and super good too!“

“Love Dewey’s!! Their house salad is my favorite.“

“This place has been on my list for a while and I just tried it today. Everyone in the family and our son’s friend loved it! If you’re debating it, don’t. Go eat it.“

“Classic Columbus Pizza! Worth the trip.“

“Was working in Columbus all weekend closest spot was Mikey‘s. We ate there three nights in a row. Great pizza and cold beers. Highly recommend I will be back.“

“Dewey's Pizza in Dublin was a fantastic lunch spot! The servers were friendly, responsive, and efficient. The pizzas we ordered were unique and delicious. The pizza throwers behind the window were so engaging and my son had a blast watching them make a pizza man face, write in flour, and “accidentally“ throw things at the window. We highly recommend going there. We will return for sure!“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“Not sure how this doesn't have five stars across the board. We drove from almost ten hours away and after scouring places to eat we decided to stop here. The crust is crisp, not soggy or tough with good flavor and thickness. You can't go wrong with fresh ingredients like the mozzarella and mushrooms (fresh not canned, wowee!) either. We also tried Gina's Gem and between the beautiful focaccia and the dip being creamy while also sweet with a small back burn to it, you really can't go wrong. The bar is a great place to sit, no spoilers, but the walls and shelves are filled with awesome and hilarious things that make good conversation. It's a shame this wonderful place is so far from home but we're hoping to make it a yearly tradition. Thanks for the great food, staff, and atmosphere!“

“We ordered from the new store in Galloway, Ohio. Pizza and sub was very hot and delicious. I highly recommend trying their food.“

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“This crew knocks it out of the park every time.“

“Great food and people would Definitely go back“

“The Don Corleone w/ sausage and my delicious date Judy.“

“Fantastic Stromboli’s and high quality to detail, give it a try!!“

“I love Mexican food I recommend eating here. My family tried the beef and chicken birra enchiladas. We all loved it, even my three cats. 😋“

“Food is always tasty and enjoyable! We ❤️ the Make It Good Fish Sanswich 😉“

“Food is great however educate your staff on wines and cocktails. Also $63 for a hamburger fries, drink, and appetizers tip is getting ridiculous.“

“Amazing service and delicious food! We have been to multiple locations and they are all equally delicious!“

“Nu voor de 3de keer in bouillon en het eten is iedere keer goed.zeker gezellig nu met het mooie buiten terras zeker een aanrader om heen te gaan als je in bouillon bent“

“After working with the front and back staff for over a year I get to see how everything is running as far as receiving all the foods and produce in the back I know everything is kept very clean and organized in a busy kitchen with all the preps and cooks working together. Out front we have a bunch of young awsome experienced ladies always working together and keeping all the customers Happy and Full. The Food and staffs are second to none😎“

“I got a pizza today and unfortunately it was over cooked. Crust was way too crunchy and cheese burnt, but this is the first bad pizza I’ve gotten from here in all the years I’ve been going“

“Last night we tried Cattleman’s Pizza. We were greeted by 3 people as we walked through the door. We waited as they prepared our order! Everyone was so kind! Liz, the owner, has been in the business for 50 years! Talking to her for that short time, I could feel her passion and pride! We walked in as customers and left as friends! Highly recommend!“

“What a hidden 💎 gem. Wife and I found this on sleepy Sunday when everything else was closed. Enjoyed a BBQ pizza with some buffalo which was amzing plus the DownEast cider which was delightful. Wife loved the Slammade. Fun vibe inside and everyone is so friendly“

“Grew up with Josie’s weekly, excited to open the door to Jason & feeling all grown up saying “keep the change”. Moved away after college & only get to grab a pizza on occasional visits home. So happy the OG is still slingin the dough 🍕. Hope to see more business come to the new location, new Franklinton residents brings a whole new crowd so wishing only the best success for this family owned & community loved shop!“

“There is a lot of good pizza on the west side, but I find myself ordering from D&E-Z-O's almost every time. Crust is always good, sauce isn't too sweet, and they are always generous with the toppings. Really good pie and the people there are always so nice! Great value for the food.“

“Still the best sub in the city!! 5*“

“If Robert Peyton likes your Pizza, I'll love your Pizza!!!“

“Had two of the lunch specials and tuscan pesto bread. The salad, slices, and bread we had were all very fresh and are everything you want. Pizza crust and fresh made bread were outstanding. Service was quick and server made good recommendations on the house specialties.Highly recommend your try them.“

“I look for a thinner crust, crunch when. I bite into and an even brown. it was all that and more. Top 5!!“

“We had so much fun here today! Delicious pizza and so kind to us - my 5-year-old had a blast!“

“Delicious pizza! I ordered the meat lovers pizza and their boneless wings. I absolutely loved it. The pizza tastes very good and has a lot of toppings. They aren’t cheap with the toppings. I will be back! The customer service was great. Pricey but worth it if you want a delicious pizza. This might be the best pizza I ever had in columbus“

“The wings are amazing!!! The grape leaves are too! But the wings are done right. I am annoying. I ask for well done. Sauce on the side. They do that. Their well done wings are still juicy. Which is the right way! That you guys so much! Family run! Their pizza is Ohio pizza, (more so Columbus) which is good, just not my style. But by boyfriend and his friends loved it. I will go here weekly for the wings! They have other items I want to try and can’t wait to try them. We also got the baklava. That will be a later treat for tonight. You guys rock and your family is amazing. Love seeing family owned companies.“

“we love this place.we order from here alot. there food is so tasty and the people who run it are so very nice“

“Food is good but customer service is not okay. Called to order and the lady on the phone was just not friendly just acted like she hated life and didn’t care about anything“