23 Best American Restaurants in Willoughby

“Amazing amazing amazing! One of the best dinners I've ever had. I hope that banana cream pie is a staple. it was heavenly.“

“the Burek is amazing! I love the cheesecake they have.“

“First of all I am very picky about my pizza. But there isn't a pizza place around that makes a better pizza than Lucio's. I've had Original NY style, Chicago, Detroit. You name it I've have ate it. Lucio's never disappoints.“

“Haven’t been to JT’s Diner for about two years. Thought we’d give it a try as we remembered it being good at their previous location. We were very disappointed in our breakfasts. My crisp bacon was burnt to a crisp with burnt taste upon first bite. Our home fries used to be excellent “sliced” potato’s, but yesterday came as mush and the scrambled eggs were not even cut….just folded like an omelet. Coffee was good and hot, as in the past. For $20.53 I expected better. Don’t think I would return.“

“Nice patio area. Reasonable prices and large menu selection.“

“Very good food!Affordable meals! Yesterday, we dined in Willoughby, OH and we had an amazing server and very nice cashier!“

“Fantastic lunch with a great friend! couldn't decide between a couple items so the waitress suggested their Toofer - basically a soup and sandwich. I got the Seafood Bisque cup and a half Ruben sandwich. Both tasted great and waitress was spot on (there when we needed her and not there when we didn't need her). I'll definitely go back and try other menu options! RECOMMEND!“

“We had the best day watching The Buckeyes at The Wild Goose! One of our sons lives in Willoughby & the other son & his wife live in Shaker Heights. Fav spot for our kids but our first time. The pizzas, onion rings & buffalo dip were amazing! Outstanding selection of beers. Loved the atmosphere. Charming but lots of TVs as well. Can’t say enough about the staff!!! Outstanding service & so friendly! Cant wait to come back!“

“Cocktails were perfect. We were served by Adam, and he was extremely attentive to our needs, and then some. Great service. Will definitely return again.“

“Love this place the spicy garlic parm wings are fantastic and we come here often for prime rib and burgers. Its always really good food. The wait time for service can vary depending on when you go but they are usually pretty on top of things and take really good care of their regulars.“

“The owner lets A and B teams play against the C team, Takes the fun away. We’ll have to find a new place to play. To bad since we’ve been playing for 3 years now. Food and service is great.“

“Please go here. Don’t read anymore reviews, don’t compare it to any other places. Get in your car and start driving to Freshleys. I am going to stay healthy and fit so that I can live longer so I can eat more freshleys. I would eat my gyro if I dropped it on the ground. I would pay $30 for the gyro I just ate if I had to. I would walk to buy one if I could. I don’t even look forward to eating gyros anywhere else because I know they can’t possible compare to these ones. The angry gyro should be renamed the happy gyro, because that’s what it truly makes me feel. I would choose this as my last meal if I was getting sent to the electric chair and I’m dead serious. I want to fly the workers of Freshleys to Greece so they can show them how it is done. I can keep going all day, but that’s just time I would be wasting instead of working to make money to buy more freshleys. You will only regret going here because you will be hooked for the rest of your life. I love you freshleys I can’t wait to see you again.“

“Had lunch there today. My daughter graduated from Lakeland and I took her, my son, his wife and baby. Everyone enjoyed b the food, hot and delicious, service was spot on, very attentive. Enjoyed the whole experience. Definetly will go back. Thanks to the staff.“

“Best ham on earth 🌎 I Love this place!“

“Our first time here, we weren't sure what to expect. Local bar atmosphere but everyone was so friendly, even the other patrons. My Porch burger was excellent and prices very reasonable. Bonus, they are dog friendly! We'll be back.“

“Bands are free and usually my kind of music. Always have a good time.“

“The food was great. The experience was great“

“My work enjoyed our district year end celebration here this week! We had the best experience because of the service provided by Tatiana, Mandi & Zach! They were so easy to work with, communication was excellent and the catering was great! I 10/10 recommend them for business events or pleasure!!!!!“

“the food and the service“

“Every single time I come here omg for is great !!!? hot fresh great service!! My waitress is the best she need a raise! lol ? naw for real keep making people smile ? one day at a time ! I will be there more than often best breakfast ? ? ? in town!!

Parking: Lots of places to park!“

“Amazing food and Atmosphere“

“American comfort food restaurant with lots of breakfast, lunch, and dinner choices for the whole family. One of the best turkey sandwiches I’ve had. Real sliced turkey, not lunch meat, on whole grain bread with all the trimmings. Service is always good, and the restaurant is clean and well maintained. Diner-style meals in a comfortable setting.“

“We are new to Ohio and have tried different restaurants.Our waitress today was amazing.Her name is Jayla.She greeted us today with a smile.It never left her face.The food was also very good.The restaurant and bathroom were very clean.There is an Applebees closer to us but not as clean and lacks in customer service.We will return to Willowby.Keep serving your customers With care and great service.“