17 Best Sandwich Shops near Xenia

“I've always liked the Italian sub. But I had the ask for Italian dressing for a Italian sub. It doesn't come with it. And it's waaay over priced for what You get. My lunch was $15 for a medium sub, small fry and small drink. Fries are horrible. The Philly is Roast beef and very underwhelming. They are false advertising with calling it a Philly. There's nothing about that a Philly. the service was good. It was very cold in there. They had the a/c on.“

“Not joking, this is by far the BEST Subway in the county. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, they werent out of anything. The building was impressively clean, I love the Subway atmosphere. P.S. If your a wrap person, come here, ive never had anyone from Subway make a clean wrap except the young lady who served me today. Team members here were respectful and straight up good at their jobs. Managing the lunch rush while running thr drive thru flawlessly. Well done. Im extremely impressed.“

“I visit this Penn station at least twice a week sometimes three times a week… never a disappointment they went above an beyond to make sure my little app worked since it was not reflecting my points an literally the same day he said he was gonna talk to corporate about it. They reached out to me via email and was very prompt and helpful and now I’m just waiting on my points to load best Penn station ever I walk in they greet me by my name know exactly what I want to order and how I want it.“

“I rarely leave reviews at food places but the care this gentleman put in making my sub perfect was second to none! He took his time and made everything evenly proportioned and not sloppy at all. I’ll definitely be coming back. The store was clean and so was the food line section. He was polite and dedicated to making a great sub and not just rushing to get you out of there with a sloppy fast sub. A+ for sure. I even left a $5 tip.“

“Great place for food and ice cream. 5 stars.“

“Great service and attention to detail on my subs for me and the wife, thank you Kavi & Shruthi. My wife very pleased with the sandwich and over appearance was pleasing“

“I support the sub house!!!“

“The location is excellent if you’re a student at CU who wants to taste and experience something off campus. They accept gift card online orders. The one downside is that they don’t include the chips in your order. Otherwise, a typical Sunday afternoon.“

“Stopped by this location for a quick lunch while working. Good service, decent food but way overpriced for what You actually get. Reg Meatball sub Fry's and a drink (med) was almost $17. I could tell the meatballs are frozen. I'll probably not be going back.“

“Very creative orders ordering scheme you have to pick a bag that you want if you want chicken or steak or whatever they serving and you put all of your ingredients on the bag like write them on the bag and then give them the bag and they'll make your sandwich to your specifications I love which witch very very creative“

“Amber, you did outstanding today. Great, friendly service. TWO refills on our drinks. I appreciate you! As always, I love McAllister’s and consider myself a regular.“

“Great Sandwich’s, chips & tea. Bread is delicious. Friendly staff & clean facility. And thank you for supporting USTA tennis! 🎾“

“I had a wonderful experience at this Subway. I went there on 01/09/2026 and ordered the new italian trio that was more then expectations. The staff are extremely friendly, polite, and professional. They are keep on taking to customers regarding their choice and taste. The service was quick and excellent, and they really make you feel valued as a customer. Will definitely be coming back! Highly recommended.“

“I love y'all! Nice, professional, fast! The food is delicious they were not stingy at all with the meats and toppings!“

“This location is currently closed temporarily stop writing bad reviews when they have been close for weeks I’m a former employee of this location and for the people with the bad reviews I’ve witnessed first hand how you started the attitude therefore you got bad customer service in return thank you have a nice day/night?“

“This is one of my top picks for lunch in the Fairborn/Beavercreek area! I’m a regular at this location, and often come here rather than the closest Penn Station to me. Sarah and her staff are helpful and friendly, and the food is always hot, fresh, and delicious. 10/10 recommend!“