10 Best Sandwich Shops in Youngstown

“I don’t live in the area BUT every time I visit the area PB here I come. Do forget they have 1/2 off on wings Sun and Mondays. Also they have a membership please join it. Finally while at the airport by all means go by the restaurant and grab a sandwich. Don’t forget to get your condiments because that’s on you to ask for. I have never been able to eat their sandwich in one setting.“

“Just enjoyed another great lunch at McAlister’s. Everything is so fresh and delicious, and the carrot cake is phenomenal. Also, the staff members are always super friendly and do an amazing job. 💖“

“My family and I love Jimmy John's we love number #9. The cookies are delicious too. The wait is not that long the staff are really nice. I tell everyone to try you won't be disappointed.“

“love the everything bread“

“I have been a customer of Boardman Sandwich Factory since it opened. (Proces have changed a tad...) As a little kid, we used to go to eat and play video games. My favorite has always been their fish sandwich. It's changed over the years, but it has never been bad. :) Their bread is always fresh and delicious. Shop local folks! Always a friendly smiling face taking your order, an you can watch then make your sandwich. Go get you some! :)“

“Oh my goodness this food is the best! I put only 3 stars for atmosphere because they need all new furniture, what they have is kinda falling apart, but don't let that stop you from eating here! Everything is homemade and absolutely delicious! And the serving sizes are huge! Pricing great too! We will definitely be making this a frequent place to eat! The waitress we had was so sweet, the cook... what can I say she knows how to cook! Awesomeness go try it!

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp into the building.“

“Wish the portions were bigger, and that more choices were available maybe a option to customize what you order. My panini was like 80% onion ... Its Like the only vegetarian food in the southern park mall. So I am grateful ? my java smoothie was not anything like the one I got there years and years ago ... It was like watered down chocolate milk . way to thin. way to much chocolate. and way to watery ...

Vegetarian options: They have a vegetarian panini and its like the only place in southern park mall that has even a option for vegetarians.“

“One of the worst Subway restaurants in the area, honestly. They are not open on time, they close early, and the staff genuinely act like they dont want to be there. I watched the girl making a sandwich just dump dressing all over. Most of the dressing made it 'on' the sandwiche, but it was a mess. I came in at 8pm, and they told me thay the toaster was broken so they couldn't heat anything up. I get the feeling that they cleaned the machine and didn't want to clean it again. Subway is a decent option for food, but when the people who work there dont care about the job that needs done, it shows. I won't be back here until I forget what this experience was like and I need a reminder, for sure.“

“The service was fast and courteous, Tineka was on point fixing my sandwich and it is so good!!????“

“Update 2025: Stopped in for a sandwich today. I was waiting patiently for someone to come to the counter when another customer came in. She walked to the other side of me and looked at the menu. When the kid came up to the counter, she quickly stepped up, ignoring the fact that I had already been waiting to order. When I tried to tell her I had been there first, she rudely gave her order instead of letting someone else go before her. One of the other employees quickly noticed and came around to wait on me at the other register. And once I received my food, the other employee apologized. I appreciated it, although I told him it was not him that was rude but the lady. I love the food here and the service is pretty good too!! Thank you for apologizing for something that was not your fault!!

When I was little, there was a sandwich factory in Warren that my mom always took me to. Then it closed (and now little wings is there, so it’s ok). When I found this one in Austintown, I was so excited and they lived up to my memories! The bread is amazing and when you add the vinegar, I melt. I’m almost drooling just thinking about their subs! I try and stop every time I go to Austintown now! Thanks for keeping a littles girls memories alive!“