17 Best Pizza Restaurants in East York

“Road under construction out front and no sidewalk.

Vegetarian options: Could count selections as 2 for 1 to encourage more healthy choices.

Parking: Persevere through the construction, it's worth it.“

“Not only the most authentic and delicious Italian food in Toronto, but also the best service too!“

“Genuniely amazing pizza and sauce, I bought a medium pizza with one sauce and he ended up giving me an extra one... they are very very nice here, I recommend.

My favourite part was the homemade garlic sauce, its sooo much better than the big pizza companies.

Pizza is best eaten straight away but I did heat up some today and it was still good.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Amazing Calzone!
The calzone at Pizzaiolo St. Clair Ave East is outstanding—perfectly crisp dough, delicious fillings, and great flavour. Huge shout-out to Santosh, who made it fresh and absolutely nailed it. Highly recommend! 🍕✨“

“What a gem! Bravo to the people who work there! I have ate a whole pizza to myself now 2 days in a row 🙃 I had the cowspiracy, the tour de france, and I shared the Dino bones pizza lol I love different things. I also love quality good deals. This was it! One of the best things I have ever had and I almost feel you all have up my flavor pallette 👌💯🙌“

“If we are not making our vegan pizza at home, we get it from Pizza Nova, and have ordered from many different locations. It's very often hit and miss. Sometimes it's great, and sometimes it's horrible. Not for Leaside, however. Every time we have ordered from there, the pizza is great, crust was crunchy, sauce was good, and the toppings fresh; the store is clean, and the staff is super-friendly. They smile, welcome you, and talk to you. They genuinely look happy to see their customers, and that's what it's all about. Best Pizza Nova location for us!“

“I live in the neighborhood and have been a customer for more than 10 years. My grandchildren go here twice a week for their pizza lunch. This Pizza Pizza location always has fantastic pizza and great service — we’ve never had any issues with their products. Highly recommend! 🍕“

“This place completely surprised me. It was the best thin pizza I have had in Toronto in a long time. Not over loaded with sauce or cheese but it was the perfect amount for the thickness of the pizza. Very tasty! I have been thinking about this pizza since I ordered it and can't wait to try another one.“

“lovely atmosphere. food was amazing!! The chef did a wonderful job. Joey, our host was attentive and made us feel welcome. I would highly recommend this restaurant.“

“I always order pizza from Watan Grill Pizza, and they never disappoint! Their service is fast and efficient, making every order a pleasant experience. I recently tried their Tandoori Pizza, and it was absolutely delicious—bursting with unique flavors that set it apart from other places. The quality of the pizza is consistently top-notch, with fresh ingredients that make all the difference. I’m truly impressed with the taste and overall dining experience. Thank you, Watan Grill Pizza, for offering such amazing food and excellent service. Highly recommended!“

“Back in the day from 2003-2013, I used to work at the hospital around the corner. This place was a staple for me. Very generous pies and an even nicer middle eastern man (possibly Iranian) who was the owner. Price point was always dynamite. Drove by the other day and it brought back memories.“

“i am in the area all summer as I go to Kiwanis pool daily. I stopped in one day to get a slice and they offered veggie or pepperoni. I chose veggie and the slice was gigantic and dripping with cheese and profuse toppings! The crust was crispy and excellent and I was amazed at how great it was! I am disabled and need to use a walker and the worker at the front held the door open for me and was extremely accommodating! I have been back several times since then. I am going to try the chicken and the ribs next time. The owner is Sri Lankan and very friendly as well as his children who work there. The prices are also very good, 6.00 for a slice with pop! The restaurant was very clean also.“

“Today was my first time trying Papa John's and I was not disappointed! I usually go to Domino's but am happy to support Papa John's because it's local, it's closer to my home, and the price is the same as Domino's. I would actually prefer Papa John's over Domino's now because Papa John's still offers anchovies and the tomato sauce is sweeter than Domino's. I also got some extras that I didn't ask for ;) thanks!“

“I order pizza from this restaurant almost every week, and they never disappoint! The pizza is always hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. The staff are incredibly respectful and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. I truly appreciate their consistent quality and service. Highly recommend!“

“Open after a concert at history on a Sunday night. My friend and I had quality service. Pizza slice was a great price and delicious. Honestly the best post concert pizza I’ve ever had. The employee even made a pizza for a family at 12am before close because the young boy was upset. Good to see that there is still good people in this world.“

“Pizzaville never disappoints! The crust is perfectly baked, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and they’re always generous with the toppings. Whether it's a classic pepperoni or something more loaded, everything tastes fresh and satisfying. Delivery is fast and reliable, and the staff are always friendly. Great value and consistent quality“

“We had Diamond for a family lunch recently. I’m giving it a 4/5. I knew going in it was going to be hole in the wall type of food. So for that it exceeded my expectations. We ordered over $100 of food and it was all ready to go on time. The staff were helpful in packaging everything up properly. The food was hot and the group was happy with it. I understand a lot of people frequent the joint. Personally, I don’t crave this and won’t be including it in my regular rotation of food options.“