10 Best Sandwich Shops in Newmarket

“Ordered catering through Firehouse Subs earlier this month for a birthday party. Bradford location did a wonderful job at ensuring our order was what we wanted. Letting us know we can modify it. And, they had everything ready and beautiful packaged for pickup. It was affordable and a hit with the kids at the party. The customer service was extraordinary! Food was delicious 🙂“

“Honestly, after a few times coming here its time for me to put my words here so others can have another review to read and have part of their choice making.

Bobby was so friendly, quick and pays attention to detail. He really does care about what he does and keep the customers happy. This place is very very lucky to have someone like that here. This is someone that will just skyrocket this place even more!

Again needed to say that. Everytime he makes it its just the best experiance i can ever find in ANY subway establishment in ontario nowadays.“

“Pita Pit Newmarket is hands-down the best place for a fresh and healthy meal! The staff are always so welcoming and take the time to make your pita exactly how you like it. Everything tastes super fresh and flavorful. The service is fast, the ingredients are top quality, and the portions are perfect. Whether I'm grabbing lunch on the go or ordering for the family, they never disappoint. Highly recommend!“

“To be honest I’ve never been in the store. One of my brothers lives close by and anytime he comes to visit on a Sunday I have to get him to stop into this location for 2 spicy chicken subs.
The quality and care that the young lady puts into making them is impressive and far superior to any other location.
She even wraps tomatoes and puts the bbq in a container so the 2nd sub I have the next day is a fresh as the first !
By far the best subs I’ve ever had in my 50 young years.
Thank you so much
This location deserves 10 stars hands down.“

“Adorei pretendo voltar! Fui mto bem atendida. 👏“

“I just pulled up to this spot for a late-night pickup, and what I saw blew my mind. There were like 6 people ahead of me, and I’m thinking, “Aight, this gonna take a minute.” But nah — this dude behind the counter (tattoos on his left arm, you’ll know who I’m talkin’ about) went full beast mode. I’m talkin’ sub-speed legend status.
It was around 10PM, so he’d clearly been grinding all day, but the energy? Still on point. He was slicing, stacking, wrapping — all while keeping it cool as hell. No stress, no slowdown, just pure efficiency. He handled the whole line in what felt like seconds. I’ve never seen a sandwich artist move like that. Other places move like they’re in slow motion compared to him.
Respect to this guy — not only is he fast, he’s chill, professional, and clearly takes pride in the hustle. This is exactly the kind of energy that makes a spot worth coming back to. I don’t even care what’s on the menu anymore — if he’s making it, I’m ordering it.

Easily a 10-star experience. Give that man a raise!“

“Easily one of the best Subway chains Iv’e gone to. The staff is very friendly and helpful, especially Hiral. He made our sandwiches very quickly and was very sweet. The atmosphere of the restaurant was comforting and quiet and very clean. I would definitely go again!“

“This franchise supports local community events. I won a free FL sub at Newmarket Hurricanes game.
In Newmarket we need more business support from owners like this.
Thanks very much for supporting our community!!!
Purchased a soft drink.“

“Recently ordered from Skip the Dishes. Quick delivery. Good portion size and the food tasted great. Would def order again.“

“3 days in a row.

Original breaded chicken on the Mediterranean bread
And cheese lettuce tomato cucumber black olives
Andd yellow mustard and light mayo
Its brilliant
They're clean and fresh, i never get a stomach ache (i get stomach aches from a lot of places.)
Love it here“