12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Niagara On The Lake

“Great atmosphere, service, food & drinks! It’s a hot spot, so make reservations… and You’re Welcome!“

“Really enjoyed our dinner at BarrelHead. Friendly staff on arrival. Didn’t have to wait too long for a table, and was able to enjoy a drink upstairs while we waited. The pizza was delicious! The live band added a great vibe too.“

“Excellent pizza. Great taste from fresh ingredients. The pie was perfectly baked. I'll be back again and so will you!“

“Stopped in for a sub. Just at the takeout window so I can't speak to the atmosphere. But the lady who made the sub fresh was very nice and the sub was delicious. Price after tax was 12.15 which is very reasonable for a chicken Parm sub. Will definitely stop in again“

“My wife and I went for the first time everything we heard about it is true. The atmosphere the service the food is outstanding. This is a place you don’t want to mess put it on your list if you want to try and upbeat friendly and great food atmosphere“

“We tried this Domino's Pizza Branch on Niagara Stone Rd and ordered Mediterranean Veggie and they made it fantastic. taste was great, looked great too. The plaza looked behind in time but the pizza itself made all differences.
Kudus to the team“

“Visited Pizza Hut with my family. Ordered Canadian pizza and small pepperoni for my older daughter, she is a picky eater. We were met by Baban,she was very sweet and helped with choosing the best pizza for us. We will definitely be back to taste other dishes“

“Great for hosting a party! We had Greg’s 60th there. The party room holds 30 people. We had 22. We had pizza and wings. Veggie Pizza there is so delicious! Mel, our server, was the best! So personable and helpful all night!!!❤️“

“Nina Gelateria & Pastry Shop is an absolute gem in the heart of Niagara-on-the-Lake! Tucked away on charming Queen Street, this family-run spot feels like a slice of Europe with its authentic Swiss-Italian influences and old-world charm.
From the moment you walk in, you're greeted by the most stunning display of freshly made pastries, vibrant gelato flavors, and mouthwatering treats—all crafted in-house daily with top-quality ingredients and no preservatives.
I couldn't resist trying the pistachio gelato (hands down the creamiest and most flavorful I've ever had), paired with a flaky almond croissant and a perfectly pulled espresso. Everything was bursting with authentic taste, and the textures were spot-on. They even have fantastic keto and gluten-free options, making it inclusive for everyone.
The staff are incredibly friendly and attentive, adding to the warm, welcoming vibe. Prices are reasonable for the quality, especially in such a touristy area.
Whether you're grabbing a quick crepe, a savory panini, or indulging in their beautiful tarts and macarons, Nina's never disappoints. It's my must-visit every time I'm in the area—highly recommend!“

“Frankie...Thanks for hosting as a stop on our Annual BRO bike ride...you and your staff (Carly) were amazing. Philly steak was awesome too! See you again soon...“

“I had a wonderful experience at Sbarro located at the Niagara Premium Outlet centre food court. We reached there when the outlet was about to close on a Sunday around 6PM. Despite that we were served well with our orders. I would highly recommend the Stromboli if you need a quick bite after getting tired of shopping. It's really delicious and fulfilling. Will definitely revisit. The staff was helpful and friendly.“

“We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner here. Just a short walk away from where we were. We'd made a reservation beforehand as we'd been advised to. Lovely space. Beautiful decor. Can accommodate groups of all sizes. There were two large groups sat in the main area but there were still lots of tables and spaces for smaller groups and couples. We were looked after by Shannon who was very welcoming, knowledgeable and attentive from the moment we sat down till when we left. She recommended the Oriecchiete main served with shaved Beef tips which I'd never had befoe but definitely will be in future! Great restaurant which I would recommend to anyone!“