8 Best Italian Restaurants in Peterborough

One Fine Food Italian • $$$
800 Erskine Ave, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Aged Balsamic & Olive Oil
Woof-Fired Pizza Diablo
Quattro Formaggi Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Margherita Pizza
Pizza Fantastic
Tiramisu Cake
The One Pizza
Carrot Cake
Shrimps

“This was my first time buying a prepared Christmas dinner and I was really nervous. But One Fine Food really delivered!! We had a delicious meal, everything was flavourful, the turkey was moist and the veggies were not overcooked. The stuffing was a big hit...next year I'll order an extra! Thank you for going the extra mile to make such an easy and tasty dinner. You made my holiday!!“

4.4 Superb211 Reviews
Capra Toro Pizza • $$
139 Hunter St W, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Margherita Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Mangia Cake
Bruschetta
Focaccia
Noodles
Gnocchi
Sauce
Chef

“Enjoyed my birthday dinner here with friends. food was amazing! Sangria was tasty! They adjusted because I can't have oranges. staff was kind and friendly. checked on us lots to make sure foods was good and drinks were full. I would recommend!“

4.2 Good77 Reviews
Pasta Shop (The) Pasta • $$
165 Sherbrooke St, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Spinach and Cheese Cannelloni

“Very happy with the service at The Pasta Shop! I was looking to have a beautiful basket of goodies sent to my mom and was able to connect with one of the managers to arrange this. Through a few text messages we were able to create a delicious basket which she was thrilled by upon receiving!! Living outside Ontario this meant the world to me. Always looking for new ways to surprise my family in Ptbo. From the idea to creation to delivery I was so impressed with their service. Now I only wish I were there to enjoy it with my mom. Highly suggest this spot!!“

5 Superb9 Reviews
East Side Mario's Italian • $$
933 Lansdowne St W, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Dandy Cotton Candy
Chicken Tetrazzini
Mozzarella Sticks
The East Side
Ceasar Salad
Garden Salad
Pesto Penne
Fettuccine
Brownie

“I don't leave many reviews, but I had too this time. So I'm not sure fan of east side Mario's typically. Every one that I've been too I found the food awful. But that changed when I moved to Peterborough and went to this location. The food is amazing!! My fiance and I go here at least twice a month. The service is great too. I find myself recommending this location very often to many others. My dad is a huge fan of East side Mario's and is currently undergoing radiation for cancer. I promised him that when he's feeling a bit better, I plan to bring him here for lunch because I know he'll enjoy it and could use a good meal that won't disappoint :)“

3.8 Good82 Reviews
Kettle Drums Italian • $$
224 Hunter St W, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Portobello Aioli Bacon Pizza
Sweet Potato Kettle Chips
Margherita Pizza
Grilled Cheese
Pasta Primavera
Fish and Chips
Caesar Salad
House Salad
Kettle Club
Calamari

“Lunch at Kettle Drums was such a delightful experience, especially since we went during quieter hours.?The ambiance, with its warm and spacious interior, was just lovely, and the staff was incredibly friendly, checking on us occasionally. I adored the attention to detail, like using graters as part of the ceiling decor – those little touches make a place unique!? Now, onto the food! While the menu didn't offer a wide variety, there were more items like steak after 3 pm. We indulged in some Sweet Potato Fries and Shrimp. The fries were presented beautifully – crunchy, flavorful, and a generous portion for one person. They were worth every penny! As for the shrimp, it didn't quite hit the mark in terms of both price and size, but it was still decent.? For drinks, I opted for the Raspberry concoction, which was pretty good; I'd order it again. My friend tried the Lavender, and although I didn't taste it myself, it looked and sounded delightful.A big shoutout to my friend Greatness for sharing your food and letting me snap some pictures! It made the whole experience even more enjoyable. ?“

3.8 Good61 Reviews
Jim's Pizza & Pasta Italian • $
395 Aylmer St N, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Special Pizza
Small 10 Pizza
Ceasar Salad
Garlic Bread
Lasagna
Jim

“Went to Jim’s based off a recommendation and we were not disappointed. The cheese and bacon garlic bread was amazing crunchy yet soft and so much flavor. We had the chicken Caesar salad it was the best chicken Caesar salad I have ever had, the dressing was perfection and the chicken was so juicy and flavorful! We ordered a meat lovers pizza the sauce slightly sweet but savory and not to saucy, the meats… well they had the meats and they put it on the pizza, and the crust soft on the inside crunchy on the outside and the perfect thin yet thick! The staff was amazing so friendly and helpful. The owner came out and greeted us she was so nice, this restaurant has been in their family for 50 years. We will definitely be back.“

3.6 Good59 Reviews
Pizza Pizza Pizza • $
871 Chemong Rd, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Hawaiian Pizza Slice
Fries

“I just went in to grab a Hawaiian slice. I have not been in this location for 20 years. They didn't have any Hawaiian slices left, so the very kind and sweet girl behind the counter made one specially for me. I didn't even take a picture of it because it so good I ate it so fast! I don't remember pizza pizza Ever Tasting this good! This location is steller!“

3.5 Good88 Reviews
The Original Spaghetti House Pizzeria Pizza • $
512 George St S, Peterborough

Customers` Favorites

House Special Baked Spaghetti
Garlic Bread with Cheese
House Special Spaghetti
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Fettuccine Alfredo
Spaghetti Special
Side of Meatballs
Fettuccini Plain
Veal Parmigiana
Baked Rigatoni

“We tried not expecting too much wanted to take a gamble. We got pick up and ate at home. We were very happy with the two medium pizzas we got. Two toppings on each. They didn’t skimp on cheese or toppings. The sizes were bigger than we thought as well. I think the quality of cheese was nothing special but not bad at all. Unfortunately the large Caesar salad wasn’t very large and the dressing wasn’t house made, I don’t think; lacked depth of flavour. Again, a solid 4/5 stars and we will order again.“

3.5 Good89 Reviews
Loading...
map Map