37 Best Italian Restaurants in Scarborough

“Rough day for our family and we decided to go out for dinner. We chose Scaddabush Despite our own issues the serving staff were all attentive, cheery and delightful. Definitely made for a better ending to what had been a rotten day. Really appreciate how polite and cheerful the whole team was. Ashley was our primary server but the whole team mirrored her postive and cheerful demeanor.“

“We had good time for our friends 67th Birthday. Everyone enjoyed their meal. The food was delicious. I had Jumbo Shrimp Alfredo it was fresh with great flavour. Very large servings, I couldn't finish it all. My drink was a Peach Bellini, it was refreshing and tasty. Our server was very quick in bringing out our order. I would recommend the Mario Parm Sampler as well because you get to try 3 different dish for reasonable price. I would recommend East Side Mario's Scarborough“

“My husband and I went for dinner last night and it was delicious. We ordered fried calamari as an app. I ordered the Linguine Mare and my husband ordered the veal marsala for the mains. Everything tasted fabulous. Service is excellent and Sal is amazing at welcoming everyone. This was our first visit but certainly won't be the last.“

“I placed a pick-up order at Pizza Hut, and the experience was smooth and convenient. The order was ready right on time, and the staff at the counter were friendly and efficient. The pizza was hot, fresh, and exactly as I ordered. I really liked that the crust was baked perfectly—crispy on the outside and soft inside.“

“Great Value, Taste and Service. Jennifer and Leah are Wonderbar“

“Stopped in for a late breakfast this week and was very happy with the quality of the food and the pleasant staff. The waitress was friendly, efficient and attentive. Overall such a nice breakfast and I would recommend it.“

“I usually get lunch from Pizza Manna , the gentelman who works here is super friendly, polite, patient, professional, nice and respectful and he always smiles, I have never seen such a great customer service in my whole life ! I really appreciate his service

Vegetarian options: Really nice eggplant plate“

“The bolognese pasta at Remezzo is honestly the best I’ve ever had! The flavor is incredible, the portion is huge, and the quality is always consistent. One order lasts me three meals, which makes it such amazing value for the price. Highly recommend if you love authentic, delicious Italian food!“

“Had a Combo #2 (Calzone with 2 Meat Balls, and a choclate milk) for $13.98. Good food, filling, served hot. Excellent service, very friendly staff. The guy in charge always has a smile, which is nice being that it's inside a hospital. Located in Centenary Hospital in the food court. Worth a visit!“

“Saurav really helped me and it's wonderful to have him here and thanks for doing the grateful.

Pizza was delicious and exactly as it is advertised. I am satisfied in customer service and the food quantity and quality.“

“This Pizza Pizza location on Ellesmere is awesome! The staff are super nice and always make the food fresh. My order came out quick, hot, and loaded with toppings. The place is clean and the service is fast, which I really like.

Whenever I’m in the area and craving pizza, this is my go-to spot. Consistent, tasty and never disappoints“

“Came in late at night jaybe (sorry if I spelt it wrong ) was working I asked him how fast he could make me a pizza he said 15 mins I was in a hurry so I told him pls hurry he made my pizza in 8 mins ? he's the best employee here 5 stars to you man“

“I had a great experience at this Pizza Hut! The staff was friendly, and Veerpal in particular stood out — she was very nice and super helpful. She made sure my order was perfect and went out of her way to make the experience easy and enjoyable. Service like this makes a big difference — thank you!“

“We went on a weekday for dinner. It was nice and warm ambiance. We ordered 2 medium pizza deal. It took 10-15 mins only for our order. Pizza toppings were fresh and got enough amount of toppings on each slices. Slices were nicely cut. We wanted spicy yet Indian tastes so asked for chilli and coriander to add. We really liked the service of their staff.“

“The food is very good and the people working there are helpful and nice. Now I'm craving pizza, sigh.

Kid-friendliness: It's a pizza joint and the employees are nice.

Wheelchair accessibility: A little bit cramped, but it's accessible.“

“Why can’t I have a customized pizza to my liking ?

Trying something new
I order a pizza April 18 2025 . 12:40 asking the lady
If I can put mozzarella pepperoni then sauce she’s like no. And o ask for well done gives me soft pizza
Well other pizza pizza store can what a waste of my time.
This sucks.loosing one customer means nothing. I’ll just visit another location :).“

“I came in for dinner with my dad and was helped by Brianna. I had asked if we could sit in a booth since my dad recently fractured his back and it’s more comfortable for him than sitting in a chair. Even though no booths were available, she quickly and kindly cleaned one off so we could sit there, which I really appreciated.

Later on, as the sun was setting, it was shining right into my dad’s eyes. He didn’t complain, but I noticed it was bothering him because of his vision issues. I caught Brianna’s attention and right away she went over and closed the blinds.

It may seem small, but both moments made a big difference in my dad’s comfort and in our evening. I just want to say thank you to Brianna for her attentiveness and care—it really stood out and meant a lot.“

“on buffet all wayes freshly filling everything every few minutes customer not waiting“

“Fantastic pizza and great neighbourhood vibe. thanks Joe!“

“Amazing service at this Pizza Pizza location! Pruthvi is absolutely fantastic—super friendly, professional, and always ensures customers get the best experience. The pizza was fresh, delicious, and made to perfection. If you’re looking for great pizza and outstanding customer service, ask for Pruthvi—he truly makes the experience memorable! Highly recommend!“

“Lamanna’s Bakery was added in our Must Visit list and we finally understand why during our first visit!

They have a huge selection of Italian pastries and gelato, freshly made. Please don’t skip or leave without tasting at least their Bomboloni. Their Tiramisu is also good! We’ll definetely be back to try out more.

The pizza slices, on the other hand, looks amazing, but the Magherita slice just didn’t make it for us… Unfortunately, the sauce was
bland and lacked in favour. However, the pizza slices had the perfect texture and amount of cheese — very generous portions, great to share amongst others. Would probably try a different flavour next time.

As a vegetarian option, their vegetarian lasagna is highly recommended… very filling and yet again, generous portions, and great service from the staff to ask us if we wanted extra sauce.

I appreciate the different queue lines created for savoury and sweet foods — it’s time efficient instead of having just one line.

Although we were able to find a spot, there is little seating available.“

“Great service and good quality meal.“

“Never disappointed:)“

“Great spot in Scarborough for Italian snacks and desserts! Full hot table of meals and lots of bakery and pastry options. They make delicious wood oven pizza that is well worth coming here for! Great staff and service and plenty of space to relax!“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“my daughter recommended this place . I tried it today and will definitely be going to Rosa's again,the food is of great quantity and quality.“

“Pizza Hut never fails to impress! The pizzas are always hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The crust is amazing—perfectly crispy yet soft inside. Their variety of toppings and cheesy goodness make every bite satisfying. The service is quick and efficient.“

“Nice little place when looking for a change of pace. Not a whole lot of sit down Italian restaurant options in the area.

Service can occasionally be a bit slow. But we are rarely in a rush. Some of the chairs are kinda flimsy. Be sure to sit gingerly if you’re a customer of size.

Ordered the panzerotto for the first time. Decent. Might order again if in the mood. Meatballs tasted a bit processed. Was surprised by that.

Scoring 5’s across the board to bump the average because I don’t think 3.9 is a fair score per the current standings. But the location is definitely more of a 4.3 kinda place.“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“Customer service was phenomenal — friendly and fast. The two pizzas I got were hot and the crust was cooked to perfection.

Pizza Hut and this location do not skimp on toppings and probably consistently give some of the most of all the chain pizza shops around. They’re the only pizza shop within a few blocks of McCowan and Eglinton so I’m glad they don’t take it for granted!“

“Amazing food, service and staff! A great place for grabbing a bite with friends or just hanging out. The staff is super friendly and made us feel really welcome, which is always a nice touch.

The crust was perfect, the toppings were fresh, and the flavors were spot-on. I also tried their garlic bread and a side of wings—both were ridiculously good and well coated with sauce.“

“Ordered the panzerotti woth mushrooms.
I was right outside so went in when I saw the employee preparing my order and asked him to please wash his hands as I cannot have no meat AT ALL.
He kindly advised that he had just washed his hands which I was appreciatetive for.
Got the order hot and fresh.

Vegetarian options: They have several vegetarian options.“

“Individual 6 pieces veggie pizza 10/10. It's small a little bit than it looks in the photo, The size for me is good as a snack so it might not be enough for someone who is too hungry lol. Anyway it's tasty and fresh I like it 👍“

“Tehran, the manager here is very friendly, always makes my day with his friendly smile and ofcourse makes sure the food is fresh and perfect always!!! Been visiting here since 2 years even if I have to skip a few locations of pizza pizza I always to make it here!!!

Dietary restrictions: Halal friendly options available here always

Wheelchair accessibility: This is wheelchair accessible location“

“I love pizza pizza, maybe it’s the nostalgia but I really enjoy it. This location I’ve been to twice and I feel like it’s been more of an exceptional experience because of the cleanliness of the store and the staff are really friendly. I was sad to read some negative reviews but so far my experience has been better than expected“

“I’ve always had a great experience at Pizza Pizza! The staff is friendly, and the service is quick. The pizza is consistently delicious with just the right amount of toppings and a crispy crust. Whether it’s a quick lunch or a late-night snack, they never disappoint. Highly recommend for anyone craving tasty pizza and great service!“

“Atmosphere and staff were great. Food was terrible and tasteless. Potatoes were ice cold, fish dried out and vegetables over cooked. Many years ago ( when it was licsyed near the front of the mall) my family & I use to eat there frequently and the food was delicious.“