50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Scarborough

“I recently visited your store and would like to highlight one particular employee of yours, Menakshi.
She went above and beyond to explain every tiny piece of query that I had and delivered excellent customer service.
Thank you to the pizza pizza team for the amazing food.“

“Stayed in Toronto for over 2 weeks. This place was by far the best we aye from; Tasy Italian pizzas, proper juicy, tender Shawarma, Home made Hummus and Knafa. I'll miss this place when I'm back in the UK.“

“I placed a pick-up order at Pizza Hut, and the experience was smooth and convenient. The order was ready right on time, and the staff at the counter were friendly and efficient. The pizza was hot, fresh, and exactly as I ordered. I really liked that the crust was baked perfectly—crispy on the outside and soft inside.“

“Great local pizza! Friendly and quality ingredients.“

“Saw this spot when visiting the bakery a few doors over and had to give it a try! This chicken shawarma platter was huge and hit all the right spots. Service was super fast and portions were awesome. Give them a try and stop drooling over the photos. 😆“

“This place is Awesome! The chicken is so fresh and delicious. The coating on the wedges makes my mouth water. The customer service and attention to detail from the owner and his employees is second to none. If you haven't been here you're missing out.“

“This is by far the best pizza I have had in Canada. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza , regular crust , regular crust and well done. It was really thick chunky pizza and really good. We also got chicken wings and fries but they were very oily and did not really taste good.“

“Ordered from the pizza pizza app, the app said my order was delivered but wasn't...
If it wasn't for the manger at this location, calling pizza pizza headquarters and getting everything fixed. I wouldn't have gotten everything fixed with getting my pizzas. Much respect 🙏. Will be ordering from this location more often“

“I will recommended this restaurant to my family and friends, friendly staff, you just call them. They placed your ordered right away. Delivered to your home comfort“

“Bought pizza on the go to Scarborough Bluffs last Friday. My original pizza shop switched over to a Kabab House. Found Pizzally on Google. Reviews seemed decent. Bought two large pizzas. The meat lover was amazing. Sorry no pics as it got eaten pretty fast. Overall the quality was very impressive. Their meat is hand slaughtered for anyone who is particular about how their meat is source. Really good. Will go back.“

“Saurav really helped me and it's wonderful to have him here and thanks for doing the grateful.

Pizza was delicious and exactly as it is advertised. I am satisfied in customer service and the food quantity and quality.“

“I came in for dinner with my dad and was helped by Brianna. I had asked if we could sit in a booth since my dad recently fractured his back and it’s more comfortable for him than sitting in a chair. Even though no booths were available, she quickly and kindly cleaned one off so we could sit there, which I really appreciated.

Later on, as the sun was setting, it was shining right into my dad’s eyes. He didn’t complain, but I noticed it was bothering him because of his vision issues. I caught Brianna’s attention and right away she went over and closed the blinds.

It may seem small, but both moments made a big difference in my dad’s comfort and in our evening. I just want to say thank you to Brianna for her attentiveness and care—it really stood out and meant a lot.“

“The food is very good and the people working there are helpful and nice. Now I'm craving pizza, sigh.

Kid-friendliness: It's a pizza joint and the employees are nice.

Wheelchair accessibility: A little bit cramped, but it's accessible.“

“Fantastic pizza and great neighbourhood vibe. thanks Joe!“

“I ordered from Pizza Pizza last night and was pleasantly surprised! The pizza arrived hot, the crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were fresh. The staff was friendly, and the order was ready right on time. Their garlic dipping sauce is always a winner. Overall, a great experience—would definitely come back!“

“This Pizza Pizza location on Ellesmere is awesome! The staff are super nice and always make the food fresh. My order came out quick, hot, and loaded with toppings. The place is clean and the service is fast, which I really like.

Whenever I’m in the area and craving pizza, this is my go-to spot. Consistent, tasty and never disappoints“

“I had a great experience at this Pizza Hut! The staff was friendly, and Veerpal in particular stood out — she was very nice and super helpful. She made sure my order was perfect and went out of her way to make the experience easy and enjoyable. Service like this makes a big difference — thank you!“

“A very nostalgic taste from your childhood. Cooked to perfection. Juicy and crunchy crust.“

“Rough day for our family and we decided to go out for dinner. We chose Scaddabush Despite our own issues the serving staff were all attentive, cheery and delightful. Definitely made for a better ending to what had been a rotten day. Really appreciate how polite and cheerful the whole team was. Ashley was our primary server but the whole team mirrored her postive and cheerful demeanor.“

“Excellent food. Great service by Rup. Thoroughly enjoyed time spent at Boston Pizza. Will certainly return.“

“Why can’t I have a customized pizza to my liking ?

Trying something new
I order a pizza April 18 2025 . 12:40 asking the lady
If I can put mozzarella pepperoni then sauce she’s like no. And o ask for well done gives me soft pizza
Well other pizza pizza store can what a waste of my time.
This sucks.loosing one customer means nothing. I’ll just visit another location :).“

“This Pizza Pizza location makes really good thin crust pizzas. They don't skimp on toppings, there's just the right amount of sauce, and the staff is always smiling and friendly.

I took a star off due to inconsistencies in regular and lightly baked. More often than not, regular bake turns into well done. Not a big deal but we do prefer a certain crust texture.

Their wings aren't too bad and the cauliflower bites are worth a try.

Convenient location and they have ample seating space and pizzas can be enjoyed in-store. Parking is quite limited though as there are other stores in the plaza.

4.5 out of 5“

“Overall, my experience at Domino’s was very good. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, and the staff was friendly and attentive. The service was prompt, though a little slow with water refills. The restaurant had a nice vibe, and the prices were reasonable for the quality. I would definitely return.“

“This white sauce pasta was absolutely delicious! The sauce was perfectly creamy, rich, and flavorful with just the right balance of herbs and spices. The pasta was cooked to perfection, and the bits of onion and bell pepper added a nice crunch and freshness. The garlic bread was crisp, buttery, and paired so well with the pasta — great for dipping into that smooth sauce. A comforting, satisfying meal that I’d definitely love to have again!“

“Ordered two Hawaiian pizzas at different times. Both very tasty with generous toppings. Excellent pizza!“

“My friends and I wanted to try a local pizza shop in Scarborough, and safe to say this hidden gem was the best we have had!
They have amazing customer service, very welcoming, and overall gave us a great experience.
The deals they had are unmatched and the pricing is very fair compared to most places, as they had a variety of options to choose from.
Will definitely be coming back!“

“Had an amazing experience! The food was perfectly cooked. The Fries had the right balance of toppings and cheese and packed with flavor.

The service was quick and friendly, Definitely one of the best spots in town for pizza and wings—I’ll be coming back for sure!“

“This Pizza Pizza location really impressed me.The food was fresh and the service was even better. The girl working there was cheerful and made sure our order was perfect. It’s nice to see staff who enjoy what they do. The pizza and garlic dip combo was unbeatable. I’ll definitely be returning soon..“

“I had a great experience at this pizza shop! The tandoori pizza was really tasty and full of flavor – definitely something I’d recommend trying. The pizza was ready right on time, and the service was excellent. The owner was very friendly and welcoming, which made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be coming back again!“

“on buffet all wayes freshly filling everything every few minutes customer not waiting“

“I have only ordered online from Popular Pizza. And their food is obviously top notch. But my 5 star rating is not because of the obviously tasty and good quality food. It is for the service. I have ordered only twice from them. And both the times I had called in to either verify my order, or make some changes or know the status. And the guy answering my call has been nothing but polite and very accommodating. Apart from this, the second time I ordered from them they sent me a complimentary pizza because my pizza got some bubbles while baking (not sure what it was but something like that). This only goes out to show that they really care to over deliver without even the customer saying !! I have never seen any place how much ever big it is to accommodate customers like this. Any other place would have just let the pizza be as is. This place not only identified the problem (without the customer mentioning) BUT delivered the solution too. 6/5 stars.“

“If you’re craving a late-night pizza, this place is a must-try. The pizza comes hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings, perfect for satisfying those late-night cravings. The crust is just the right balance of crispy and chewy, and the sauce has a nice zesty kick. Plus, they’ve got a fantastic deal where you can buy one pizza and get another one for free. It’s a great way to stock up for a midnight snack or share with friends!“

“To me Gino's Pizza at 681 Markham road is one of the best Pizzeria in town.
They may not be fancy but they taste great. Love the friendly staff, especially Binit Sreshta, who always greets you with a smile and gives the right suggestion from what to choose for.
My daughter's favorite pizza joint. Cheers to Gino's Pizza 🍕“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“Vaishnavi provided outstanding service during my visit to Papa John’s, 1245 Ellesmere! I ordered the BBQ Chicken Pizza, Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks, and a Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, and everything was delicious. She was attentive, friendly, and made sure my order was prepared perfectly. Her professionalism and cheerful attitude truly made the experience memorable. I’ll definitely be back thanks to her excellent service and the amazing food! Can’t wait to visit then next time I visit my family ♥️“

“Had an amazing experience at Mr Singh Pizza , Scarborough . The pizza was delicious, and the service was fantastic. A special shout-out to Harman for her friendly and attentive service, she made our visit extra enjoyable. Highly recommend🥰“

“I am the pizza lunch co-ordinator at my kid's school and we made a decision to switch to Gino's for this year's pizza lunches, and I can't say enough great things about Gino's.

First of all, I think what makes this location great is the owner who always goes above and beyond to accommodate any requests that are made. Being on top of large orders every 2 weeks is not an easy task, but he makes it happen with consistency and sincerity. He always checks in after the pizza lunches for feedback to see how the pizzas were which really impressed me. How many chain pizza places does that? Our previous suppliers certainly did not, and that's why they're our PREVIOUS suppliers.

Now on to the good stuff! Gino's pizza strikes a great balance for me as it's not as junky as some of the other chains. I really like their tomato sauce which reminds me more of the type of sauce you get from an Italian bakery hot table which is lighter and less sugary. The dough is also lovely with a good chew and fluffy goodness.

I hope to continue to support this excellent business for many years to come! Thank you, Gino's!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Best Pizza and Even Better Service!

I had an amazing experience at this pizza place! Not only was the pizza absolutely delicious—crispy crust, rich toppings, and perfectly melted cheese—but the service was what truly stood out. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and friendly attitude. The staff was attentive, quick to take the order, and made sure everything was perfect throughout my visit.

They even took the time to check in after serving the food to see if we needed anything else. The place was clean, the atmosphere was cozy, and the team clearly cared about making every customer feel welcome. It's rare to find this level of service nowadays!

Highly recommend this spot to anyone who loves great pizza and top-notch customer service. Definitely coming back again! 🍕🔥“

“So me and my friends were really hungry and wanted to eat out. Came out to this wonderful restaurant for pizza with an excellent service from the young lady at the cashier “Reet”😍. Word! She was so so so wonderful that she helped us out to decide what to eat and lo she was so good at explaining what to get and what not to. Showed us a couple of good choices and toppings and honestly it was mind blowing. Thank you so much Reet. Really really enjoyed the food and your helping nature elevated the whole dining experience.
The pizza was amazing and the wings were delicious.
Ps- Give Reet a raise cause people like her really stand out in exceptional customer service❤️!“

“You guys are always smiling while you serve and always maintain the quality of all the pizzas, I often come there for cheese pizzas and veggie slices (the slices are also very fresh everytime). Shoutout to the whole team and thank you, cheers!“

“Lovely pizza. Fresh, tasty and fast service. ? authentic and halal. Everyone at the shop are friendly. This is my go to place for pizza.

Kid-friendliness: Kids can stay inside the shop without hesitant and no worries. Only thing is there are vehicles outside constantly moving, so watch out. Any type of pizza ? your child prefers, ask them. Very friendly staff.

Parking: Most of the time is full. However, there are parking spaces all the time.“

“Jessica is the best waitress. She made us feel right at home and did an amazing job checking in on us and recommending her favourites on the menu. I highly recommend finding a table that she is at. August 8 is lucky to have Jessica and we will be back to see them!“

“I love Pizza Kabob pepperoni and chicken pizza. The crust is sweet and chewy and pizza sauce is better than other pizza.“

“Easily my go to pizza place in the area. I was not always the biggest dominos guy but this particular location is definitely special. Amazing staff and very good service. Again my go to pizza place and easily my favourite dominos location. I strongly recommend this location.“

“My friend Jordan LOVES this restaurant SO MUCH. He says a the best pizza ever! Domino’s? F*ck no. Regino’s all the way, baby!“

“No doubt, the best pizza in town! My family’s favorite is the Goshtkhor. On top of that, Hina & Umair from the Markham branch provided excellent customer service. Keep it up, guys!“

“good food for when you're on the go even if it's not a hot and ready pick 6 minutes and you're on your way again 5⭐ fast and friendly“

“I recently tried Big Slice Pizza & Chicken and I loved it! I ordered their Hot & Hunny Wings, Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza and Hot Peri Tenders. Everything was absolutely delicious! The pizza had the perfect balance of heat and flavor, and the tenders were crispy, juicy, and packed with spice and their wings were crispy, saucy, and perfectly cooked!

Love their Tuesday deal too! buy one gourmet pizza, get the second 50% off! Definitely coming back here!!!“

“I usually get lunch from Pizza Manna , the gentelman who works here is super friendly, polite, patient, professional, nice and respectful and he always smiles, I have never seen such a great customer service in my whole life ! I really appreciate his service

Vegetarian options: Really nice eggplant plate“