50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Scarborough

“I recently visited your store and would like to highlight one particular employee of yours, Menakshi.
She went above and beyond to explain every tiny piece of query that I had and delivered excellent customer service.
Thank you to the pizza pizza team for the amazing food.“

“Stayed in Toronto for over 2 weeks. This place was by far the best we aye from; Tasy Italian pizzas, proper juicy, tender Shawarma, Home made Hummus and Knafa. I'll miss this place when I'm back in the UK.“

“Great local pizza! Friendly and quality ingredients.“

“Just thought id take a minute and leave a review im not even done eating yet and I can't ever remember even leaving a review before. The mixed shawarma plate i just got from here is the best iv ever had and I had alot. 100% try this place.“

“Went in to grab some pizza for lunch, wasn’t thinking too much about it. But I was pleasantly surprised by the customer service from Wijay, the gentleman who served me. We exchanged some jokes and laughs and the service was was quick and easy. If you happen to come here, I hope you get to meet Wijay as well!
And of course the pizza was good too!“

“Have to leave a review because I was that impressed with their lasagna. A lot of cheese, meat and layers. Super quality and full of flavour. Can easily feed 2 people. It came with garlic bread, parm, and a little brownie bite for a sweet finish! Highly recommend and will certainly be back!“

“Had this a long time ago but at a different location. The servings was more than I expected. Staff is friendly.

If youve never been here but want to come, the building is L shaped and the entrance is under a different sign of some indian take out (taste of agvra?)“

“Ordered from the pizza pizza app, the app said my order was delivered but wasn't...
If it wasn't for the manger at this location, calling pizza pizza headquarters and getting everything fixed. I wouldn't have gotten everything fixed with getting my pizzas. Much respect 🙏. Will be ordering from this location more often“

“Bought pizza on the go to Scarborough Bluffs last Friday. My original pizza shop switched over to a Kabab House. Found Pizzally on Google. Reviews seemed decent. Bought two large pizzas. The meat lover was amazing. Sorry no pics as it got eaten pretty fast. Overall the quality was very impressive. Their meat is hand slaughtered for anyone who is particular about how their meat is source. Really good. Will go back.“

“I will recommended this restaurant to my family and friends, friendly staff, you just call them. They placed your ordered right away. Delivered to your home comfort“

“Saurav really helped me and it's wonderful to have him here and thanks for doing the grateful.

Pizza was delicious and exactly as it is advertised. I am satisfied in customer service and the food quantity and quality.“

“We went for dinner and had a great dining experience.
Our waitress Christa was awesome! Excellent customer service.
The food was very good as expected.
The kids loved the experience also as there was Santa.

Our pizza was made perfect.“

“Been here a few times. Great customer service. Friendly and quick. Quality is great. Couple of spots to sit down and eat which aren't usually too busy so you'll likely find a place to sit if that's what you want. Typically I see people getting take out.
Convenient location with plenty of parking and other shops close by to run multiple errands while you're here.“

“Fantastic pizza and great neighbourhood vibe. thanks Joe!“

“I ordered from Pizza Pizza last night and was pleasantly surprised! The pizza arrived hot, the crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were fresh. The staff was friendly, and the order was ready right on time. Their garlic dipping sauce is always a winner. Overall, a great experience—would definitely come back!“

“I visited on Christmas night, arriving at closing time. The staff graciously accepted my pizza order, even though they could have declined given the late hour. They went above and beyond to prepare my pizza. My sincere appreciation goes to the team for their dedication during the holiday and for fulfilling my order.“

“A very nostalgic taste from your childhood. Cooked to perfection. Juicy and crunchy crust.“

“I had a great experience at this Pizza Hut! The staff was friendly, and Veerpal in particular stood out — she was very nice and super helpful. She made sure my order was perfect and went out of her way to make the experience easy and enjoyable. Service like this makes a big difference — thank you!“

“Great experience. Our server Kiyya was on point from beginning to end, making sure that we were taken care of in a timely manner. She was very helpful especially with assisting me to create great options for the keto diet that I'm currently on. Great job!“

“Excellent food. Great service by Rup. Thoroughly enjoyed time spent at Boston Pizza. Will certainly return.“

“I picked up a few pizzas for our lunch at work, and amazing, met the lovely owner, and they run a good shop. We will be back. I had stopped ordering with pizza pizza years ago, but recently have given this location a try and really good stuff. Thanks!!“

“I’ve come here a few times and both the pizza and poutine are amazing. Poutine specifically is so good, portions are huge, fries are so yummy and their gravy and cheese pair really well together. I highly reccomend asking for extra cheese & gravy. They don’t have cheese curds but it doesn’t matter it’s still really good and worth its modest price. Customer service is always so kind too! Such an amazing small business“

“So I bought pizza to surprise my wife last night and I was very surprised on how much it cost for one large pizza so I challenged my wife to buy one cheaper tonight not only did she buy $15 cheaper from Domino’s, but we got a large and medium Pizza for that price so I guess she won meant to be quite frank. The Domino’s Pizza was much better.“

“This is the only pizza pizza location I go to!
It has the best dough. It’s soft and fluffy when I order thin crust. It doesn’t taste like cardboard box like other locations. They also put toppings on the pizza properly! It never feels too little. Location is always clean and quiet. Yesterday when I picked up the front staff was very cheerful. Overall this location is the only reason why I still like pizza pizza today. It taste way better than any other location. Noticeably better!“

“This white sauce pasta was absolutely delicious! The sauce was perfectly creamy, rich, and flavorful with just the right balance of herbs and spices. The pasta was cooked to perfection, and the bits of onion and bell pepper added a nice crunch and freshness. The garlic bread was crisp, buttery, and paired so well with the pasta — great for dipping into that smooth sauce. A comforting, satisfying meal that I’d definitely love to have again!“

“Just tried the pizza at the new Big Brothers Gourmet Pizza location - delicious! Fresh ingredients and scrumptious dough. Highly recommend it. - Brian McIntyre, Brian McIntyre Real Estate .“

“My friends and I wanted to try a local pizza shop in Scarborough, and safe to say this hidden gem was the best we have had!
They have amazing customer service, very welcoming, and overall gave us a great experience.
The deals they had are unmatched and the pricing is very fair compared to most places, as they had a variety of options to choose from.
Will definitely be coming back!“

“Ordered two Hawaiian pizzas at different times. Both very tasty with generous toppings. Excellent pizza!“

“Late Night Pizza is an absolute gem! The people here are incredibly friendly and welcoming — you can really tell they care about their customers. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after a long day or ordering for a group, they always make you feel right at home.

And the food? Amazing. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. The crust has that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the toppings taste super fresh. You can’t go wrong with any of their specials, and the late-night hours are a lifesaver!

Highly recommend this spot — great people, great pizza, great vibes. 🍕✨“

“This Pizza Pizza location really impressed me.The food was fresh and the service was even better. The girl working there was cheerful and made sure our order was perfect. It’s nice to see staff who enjoy what they do. The pizza and garlic dip combo was unbeatable. I’ll definitely be returning soon..“

“The staff here are what make this place great! They are always friendly and willing to help. The food is delicious as you can taste the care & pride they put into everything they make. I only gave 4 stars on atmosphere because while the place is very clean, it's a takeout spot and not a sit-down restaurant.“

“I had a great experience at this pizza shop! The tandoori pizza was really tasty and full of flavor – definitely something I’d recommend trying. The pizza was ready right on time, and the service was excellent. The owner was very friendly and welcoming, which made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be coming back again!“

“To me Gino's Pizza at 681 Markham road is one of the best Pizzeria in town.
They may not be fancy but they taste great. Love the friendly staff, especially Binit Sreshta, who always greets you with a smile and gives the right suggestion from what to choose for.
My daughter's favorite pizza joint. Cheers to Gino's Pizza 🍕“

“Had an amazing experience at Mr Singh Pizza , Scarborough . The pizza was delicious, and the service was fantastic. A special shout-out to Harman for her friendly and attentive service, she made our visit extra enjoyable. Highly recommend🥰“

“This place was my first time i came for my driving test i was hungry so i went there their costumers service was very good a guy name dhruv helped me to pick mh toppings adn also complimented the seasonings from the top
And seasonings of origano and chilliflex with a bit hot sauce frim the top was awesome it made my day so i took some for my girl of heart shape as well with some baked wings it was pocket friendly will come back again for sure for those juicy wings and pizzas.“

“Taste - No one can beat. Really delicious 😋
Service- Taking down 1 star as I placed a big order of 10 pizza (1 day advance scheduled) for 12pm for a company event and food was delivered at 1.08pm and lots of employees left as they were hungry. Event was a flop due to delay in food.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Best Pizza and Even Better Service!

I had an amazing experience at this pizza place! Not only was the pizza absolutely delicious—crispy crust, rich toppings, and perfectly melted cheese—but the service was what truly stood out. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and friendly attitude. The staff was attentive, quick to take the order, and made sure everything was perfect throughout my visit.

They even took the time to check in after serving the food to see if we needed anything else. The place was clean, the atmosphere was cozy, and the team clearly cared about making every customer feel welcome. It's rare to find this level of service nowadays!

Highly recommend this spot to anyone who loves great pizza and top-notch customer service. Definitely coming back again! 🍕🔥“

“I had an amazing experience at Aly’s Pizza Restaurant! The food was absolutely delicious — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. I visited there to grab a couple of slices for my dinner, but Akash and Nidhi completely changed my mind with their amazing service and great attitude! Their friendly approach and excellent selling skills convinced me to try a full pizza — and I’m so glad I did! The tandoori pizza was fresh, delicious, and worth every bite. Great service and great food — highly recommend this place!“

“My friend Jordan LOVES this restaurant SO MUCH. He says a the best pizza ever! Domino’s? F*ck no. Regino’s all the way, baby!“

“You guys are always smiling while you serve and always maintain the quality of all the pizzas, I often come there for cheese pizzas and veggie slices (the slices are also very fresh everytime). Shoutout to the whole team and thank you, cheers!“

“on buffet all wayes freshly filling everything every few minutes customer not waiting“

“August 8 is hands down one of my favourite sushi spots. At least this specific location for me is. Honestly, it feels like it should be a high-end restaurant, the quality of the food is that good.

Of course, their sushi is amazing (fresh, flavourful, and beautifully done), but what really stands out is the variety on the menu. The flavours they use are insane. They have these beef tacos that are absolutely phenomenal I think about them all the time. I always pick the dinner option because I feel like it has more variety to choose from.

My boyfriend and I literally drive all the way from Vaughan just to come here, which says everything about how worth it it is. The staff are also incredible there are always plenty of team members on the floor, so service is fast, attentive, and super efficient.

Everything tastes so fresh, the vibes are great, and they always play good music, which just adds to the whole experience.

Definitely my go-to sushi spot and easily one of the best I’ve been to.“

“Lovely pizza. Fresh, tasty and fast service. ? authentic and halal. Everyone at the shop are friendly. This is my go to place for pizza.

Kid-friendliness: Kids can stay inside the shop without hesitant and no worries. Only thing is there are vehicles outside constantly moving, so watch out. Any type of pizza ? your child prefers, ask them. Very friendly staff.

Parking: Most of the time is full. However, there are parking spaces all the time.“

“I love Pizza Kabob pepperoni and chicken pizza. The crust is sweet and chewy and pizza sauce is better than other pizza.“

“Simplicity at its best. For some reason, this pizza tastes different than other chains. Dough is light and crispy (not doughy), the sauce is sweet and pleasant, and it’s always cooked to perfection with just a little bit of char on top. It also makes me feel a lot less bloated than anywhere else. Amazing!“

“Easily my go to pizza place in the area. I was not always the biggest dominos guy but this particular location is definitely special. Amazing staff and very good service. Again my go to pizza place and easily my favourite dominos location. I strongly recommend this location.“

“No doubt, the best pizza in town! My family’s favorite is the Goshtkhor. On top of that, Hina & Umair from the Markham branch provided excellent customer service. Keep it up, guys!“

“I had an amazing experience at The Big Slice. The food was so delicious, especially the pizza fresh, tasty, and full of flavor. The service was excellent and the staff were very nice with great behavior. Everything was perfect. I definitely recommend this place. And he give me discount too thanks the big slice pizza.“

“Exceptional service deserves recognition, and Hamayoon at Bilal Pizza consistently delivers just that. From the moment you walk through the door or place an order over the phone, his warm and friendly demeanor makes you feel like a valued guest.

Hamayoon embodies what true customer service should be. He is incredibly welcoming, patient, and attentive. Whether you're deciding on your favorite Special pizza or seeking a recommendation, he offers genuine suggestions with a smile that lights up the room. His positive attitude is infectious and turns a simple pizza pickup into a pleasant experience.

The food, especially the signature Special pizza, is always fresh, delicious, and made to perfection. But what truly makes Bilal Pizza a five-star establishment is the outstanding service provided by Hamayoon. He manages orders with impressive efficiency, ensures everything is accurate, and does it all with a level of care and courtesy that is rare to find.

Hamayoon is a tremendous asset to Bilal Pizza and the main reason my family and I are loyal customers. Thank you for your consistently excellent and friendly service, Hamayoon!

Highly recommended without hesitation!“

“This place is a hidden gem! I went in on a whim and was the best decision I made. It’s flavourful and always fresh they will accommodate any request you make or have and they are amazing people I would recommend going to famous pizza and not listen to what one or two people have to say. I go here before pizza pizza and dominos Try it and be amazed by good food and people. Keep pumping out good food“