23 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines

“I felt like I was in Italy.“

“Wonderful dinner experience, great food and service!“

“Great service, bartender Liam was great, friendly staff and the pesto chicken pizza was excellent.“

“We booked the Barrel Room for my Dad's 80th Birthday. Janine was easy to work with, and our servers were incredibly helpful. The guests commented on how much they loved the atmosphere of the room - but the food took centre stage! Personally, I highly recommend the mushroom ravioli in the rose sauce. Mmmm.“

“Exceptional service and the food is exquisite! I've been here twice now -- one time for my birthday and I came for the second time tonight with my parents. The restaurant is absolutely stunning on the inside with elegant decor and lighting, and comfortable seating. And their rooftop patio is lovely, too. I have to mention that both times we've been here, the service was unparalleled. I have a food allergy and for one dish I ordered, the chef made a special sauce for me from scratch so that I could still enjoy it without having an allergic reaction. Our waitress mentioned that the kitchen will always work to accommodate allergies or other food sensitivities. And for my birthday, the kitchen brought us some of their signature cannolis with a birthday candle. The servers are all very friendly and conversational, which makes the dining experience even better. My family came to eat tonight forgetting it was a holiday weekend, and Jared went above and beyond to find a place for us and attended to our every need all throughout dinner. The owner and chef even came out to speak with us, and we had a nice conversation. My parents were wowed to say the least, and we're already talking about coming back. It's worth visiting Solaia on a routine basis as many of their menu items will change to suit the season. They have different cocktails every season, too. The burrata, gnocchi, and risotto are very good, as is the fresh bread and butter made in house every day. We can't wait to come back!“

“hands down, best Italian restaurant in the region. food is delicious and the service is excellent!“

“absolutely beyond amazing food, anything on the menu, prepared with love and care. I personally love Kelly's white pizza as I can't have tomato sauce, topped with ham, bacon and mushrooms. Along with delicious mozzarella sticks or garlic thangs which are over the top!!“

“Shared a meal to celebrate the season with our team last evening. Food and service was impeccable. Thank you.“

“First time customer last night. The ambiance was very nice. The food was very good. There was 7 of us for dinner and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meals. Overall, the food was fantastic and the price was reasonable for the portion size. (large portions) We will be back soon.“

“Amazing food, great service, great atmosphere. Enjoyed a datenight on Friday with some super tasty eats. Loved the flavour on the angel hair garlic shrimp pasta. Will 100% be back just for that! :)“

“I catered a dinner with specific dietary instructions for a portion of our dinner to be delivered to my house at a specific time. The meal arrived on time, was hot and delicious. The dietary request was made exactly to my instructions. Will definitely cater again from Big Marcos. Their steak subs were arranged on the tray with care,
generously filled, and a delicious hit with everyone.“

“Vegan food was phenomenal! Staff was so super nice and friendly. Overall great experience. We live in the states and will be back here for sure when we visit.“

“Awesome local cafe, fresh amazing food and deserts!! The pasta workshops are awesome we had so much fun!! Thank you again for an amazing evening!!! We will be back for Ravioli workshop!!!“

“Fantastic place to enjoy a delicious meal. Cafe Amore has now risen to the top of my list of favourite restaurants. The first time I was there it was a summer dinner outside. I experienced the Black and Blue pasta. Simply delectable. Last night we returned for an early Valentine’s Day dinner. This time I could not resist the Steak Gorgonzola. So incredibly decadent, so delicious. My wife had the Penne Alfredo with Lobster and Crab. Also a beautifully presented dish that was delicious. The Caesar salad is definitely worth the upgrade too. Cozy and warm dining experience with a great staff. We are looking forward to coming back soon. There’s just too many delicious options on that menu. See you soon!“

“Friendly staff and fresh products. Limited parking out from. Careful pulling in and out onto Pelham Rd. Gelato and cakes here is amazing. Perogies here are awesome. Many frozen items you can buy for home. Clean store. Some picnic tables outside for your use.

Parking: Limited parking in the front. Careful pulling in and out of the lot.“

“I had a fantastic experience at this place! The menu has so many great options—everything is fresh, tasty, and reasonably priced. They offer a great variety of specialty pizzas and toppings, so there's something for everyone. The service was also really friendly and welcoming. I absolutely loved their veggie pizza—every bite was delicious. I’ll definitely be ordering from here again and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza!“

“First time ordering. I had a calzone and wings, both were delicious! I have never had such a good calzone in my life. Thanks!“

“Today was our first time here and I absolutely loved the experience. The restaurant has an amazing vibe, and the live music was a great bonus — Lost Boys was playing that night. As for the service, Carlie was our server and she truly made everything even better. From the moment we arrived at the table, she introduced herself with a fantastic attitude — kind, respectful, and genuinely friendly. She recommended every dish we ordered and even helped my husband with his lactose intolerance by offering him the option to customize his pizza. The place itself was excellent, but the exceptional service provided by Carlie took it to another level. I totally recommend this spot — and when you go, make sure to ask for her!“

“Here's a glowing review for Pizza Pizza:

"I'm absolutely obsessed with Pizza Pizza! The moment that perfectly cooked crust comes out of the oven, I know I'm in for a treat. The combination of flavorful sauce, gooey melted cheese, and an assortment of toppings is pure perfection.

The service is always top-notch, with friendly staff and prompt delivery. Plus, their deals and promotions can't be beat!“

“One of the greatest place to be. The staffs and the services over there are superb.“

“We had our wedding reception there 5 years ago and our guests are still raving and talking about their meals to this day!!! Lino is a master chef whose menus are 5 star cuisine!! I also take my work crews there for lunch often their hot table is unmatched with a huge variety of delicious items!! A MUST TRY!!!!! Paul Kotsopoulos“

“I had an excellent experience picking up takeout from Pizza Hut! From the moment I walked in, the staff was welcoming and attentive. They greeted me with a smile and quickly assisted me with my order.

The restaurant was clean and well-organized, creating a pleasant atmosphere while I waited. My pizza was prepared right on time, fresh out of the oven, and packaged perfectly. The crust was crispy, the toppings were generous, and the flavours were just perfect exactly what I was hoping for!

The entire process was smooth, quick, and enjoyable. Great customer service and delicious food. I'll definitely be coming back for more! Highly recommend this location for anyone looking for a hassle-free takeout experience.“

“We stopped by while travelling and server Lorie was really nice and welcoming! She pointed us all the deals and everything and we saved money because of her! We ordered 2 large pizzas Canadian and Hawaiian both are good but we liked the Canadian better! Garlic bread was nice addition and my three year old enjoyed it“