24 Best Italian Restaurants in St. Catharines

“I felt like I was in Italy.“

“Wonderful dinner experience, great food and service!“

“Great atmosphere, amazing food. The HONEY GARLIC BRUSSELS SPROUTS were absolutely delicious, one of the best appetizers I’ve ever had. The beef tenderloin melted in my mouth, will definitely return. Highly recommend…“

“Amazing dinner last night! Everything was so fresh! The manicotti was one of the best I've had!“

“absolutely beyond amazing food, anything on the menu, prepared with love and care. I personally love Kelly's white pizza as I can't have tomato sauce, topped with ham, bacon and mushrooms. Along with delicious mozzarella sticks or garlic thangs which are over the top!!“

“Ambience,service and food..all perfection!“

“We booked the Barrel Room for my Dad's 80th Birthday. Janine was easy to work with, and our servers were incredibly helpful. The guests commented on how much they loved the atmosphere of the room - but the food took centre stage! Personally, I highly recommend the mushroom ravioli in the rose sauce. Mmmm.“

“Tapas are always the best! Crab cakes are sooooo good! 10/10 date night! Staff are all really kind as well.“

“Amazing food, great service, great atmosphere. Enjoyed a datenight on Friday with some super tasty eats. Loved the flavour on the angel hair garlic shrimp pasta. Will 100% be back just for that! :)“

“First time customer last night. The ambiance was very nice. The food was very good. There was 7 of us for dinner and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meals. Overall, the food was fantastic and the price was reasonable for the portion size. (large portions) We will be back soon.“

“Big shout out to Big Marcos for having the Welland Wizards u10 Girls team tonight. The service was fantastic and they were extremely accommodating to our team. We will certainly enjoy coming back as a team and as individual families too. Thank you again for the hospitality and great food!“

“Amazing food, great service, great atmosphere. Enjoyed a datenight on Friday with some super tasty eats. Loved the flavour on the angel hair garlic shrimp pasta. Will 100% be back just for that! :)“

“well i was there last nite for the show(lynn)...awesome show.....she really spoke to me thru her mind....great flatbread and of course canoli....i bought 4....thanx to the wonderful attitive staff...until we meet again...Maria“

“Vegan food was phenomenal! Staff was so super nice and friendly. Overall great experience. We live in the states and will be back here for sure when we visit.“

“Amazing experience! We were allowed in early & served before I realized the open sign wasn't on yet... (Embarrassing). The gentleman was very kind! The food was hot & fresh, not to mention super yummy. Would definitely come back & highly recommend this location!“

“We ordered the Thanksgiving Family Meal and by far it was the most delicious Thanksgiving feast I’ve ever had. I’m typically not a turkey fan but this turkey was mouthwatering and had incredible flavour…don't even get me started on the stuffing?! Do yourself a favour and order from Valentinos, save yourself the headache and dirty dishes and impress your guests who will be talking about it months later. We’ll be ordering again because I haven’t stopped thinking about it.“

“Fantastic place to enjoy a delicious meal. Cafe Amore has now risen to the top of my list of favourite restaurants. The first time I was there it was a summer dinner outside. I experienced the Black and Blue pasta. Simply delectable. Last night we returned for an early Valentine’s Day dinner. This time I could not resist the Steak Gorgonzola. So incredibly decadent, so delicious. My wife had the Penne Alfredo with Lobster and Crab. Also a beautifully presented dish that was delicious. The Caesar salad is definitely worth the upgrade too. Cozy and warm dining experience with a great staff. We are looking forward to coming back soon. There’s just too many delicious options on that menu. See you soon!“

“nice atmosphere and the waitress tina is very good with her customers“

“Surprisingly Amazing Garlic Bread!
I dropped by Pizza Pizza recently and decided to try something different — their garlic bread. Honestly, I didn’t expect it to be so good! It was warm, buttery, and had the perfect amount of garlic and herbs. The outside had a nice crisp while the inside stayed soft. It made for a perfect quick snack. The staff was friendly and the service was fast. I’ll definitely be getting it again next time I’m there! And the owner is really nice 😊“

“We had our wedding reception there 5 years ago and our guests are still raving and talking about their meals to this day!!! Lino is a master chef whose menus are 5 star cuisine!! I also take my work crews there for lunch often their hot table is unmatched with a huge variety of delicious items!! A MUST TRY!!!!! Paul Kotsopoulos“

“Today was our first time here and I absolutely loved the experience. The restaurant has an amazing vibe, and the live music was a great bonus — Lost Boys was playing that night. As for the service, Carlie was our server and she truly made everything even better. From the moment we arrived at the table, she introduced herself with a fantastic attitude — kind, respectful, and genuinely friendly. She recommended every dish we ordered and even helped my husband with his lactose intolerance by offering him the option to customize his pizza. The place itself was excellent, but the exceptional service provided by Carlie took it to another level. I totally recommend this spot — and when you go, make sure to ask for her!“

“Best pizza & wings in Niagara region, perfect place for chill beer 🍻 & wine 🍷.highly recommend this place.“

“Great food, chill vibes

Stopped by Pizza Hut with some friends and we were not disappointed! The wings were crispy, the pan pizza was loaded with toppings, and everything came out hot and fresh. The staff were super chill and made us feel welcome. Definitely a great place and enjoy good food without breaking the bank.“

“Pizza hut is my favourite always love pepperoni pizza pan, hot and fresh.
Have good deals.
Service is okay not much but greetable at entrance.
Atmosphere is dying, old chair's seating areas with holes, outdoor signs are falling off the walls. This place needs help!!!“